What are the nonegative integral solutions to $k^2 = 2 n^2 +1$? $n = 2$ and $k = 3$ works, what is the next smallest pair?
-
3$\begingroup$ Can you give some context to your question - why do you need to know, what have you tried etc $\endgroup$– Mark BennetCommented Oct 22, 2014 at 15:05
-
$\begingroup$ This question ultimately boils down to determining triangular numbers that are also perfect squares. $\endgroup$– LucianCommented Oct 22, 2014 at 16:03
-
$\begingroup$ Why? To answer to a question posed by Will Shortz (puzzle master of NY Times), originally by Martin Gardner, on Sunday, October 19 AM. $\endgroup$– Bill PblkCommented Oct 22, 2014 at 17:18
1 Answer
First, take the square root of both:
$\sqrt{k^2}=\sqrt{2n^2+1} \iff |k| = \sqrt{2n^2+1}$. In order to get both variables to positive integers, you need to have $2n^2+1$ to be a square number:
If $n = 1 \iff 2n^2+1 = 3$ and is no square number:
$n = 1 \iff 2n^2+1 = 3$
$\color{blue}{n = 2 \iff 2n^2+1 = 9} \rightarrow$ which is a square number
$n = 3 \iff 2n^2+1 = 19$
$n = 4 \iff 2n^2+1 = 33$
$n = 5 \iff 2n^2+1 = 51$
$n = 6 \iff 2n^2+1 = 73$
$n = 7 \iff 2n^2+1 = 99$
$n = 8 \iff 2n^2+1 = 129$
$n = 9 \iff 2n^2+1 = 163$
$n = 10 \iff 2n^2+1 = 201$
$n = 11 \iff 2n^2+1 = 243$
$\color{blue}{n = 12 \iff 2n^2+1 = 289} \rightarrow$ which is also a square number
So, the second value for $n = 12$ and $k=\sqrt{2n^2+1}=\sqrt{289}=17$.
-
$\begingroup$ Are there infinitely many solutions? Are they quite rare? $\endgroup$ Commented Oct 22, 2014 at 17:15