While doing some mathematical modelling of planetary orbits I have come up with two definite integrals $D_1$ and $D_2$ which appear to produce the same result when I test (using www.WolframAlpha.com) for various values of $a$ where $0<a<1$. $$ D_1 \, =\, \int_0^{2\pi}f_1\,\mathrm{d}\theta \, =\, \int_0^{2\pi}\frac{3a\sin^2\theta}{(1-a\cos \theta)^4}\mathrm{d}\theta \,=\, \frac{3a\pi}{(1-a^2)^{5/2}} \, =\,R $$ and $$ D_2 \, =\, \int_0^{2\pi}f_2\,\mathrm{d}\theta \, =\, \int_0^{2\pi}\frac{\cos \theta}{(1-a\cos \theta)^3}\,\mathrm{d}\theta \, =\, \frac{3a\pi}{(1-a^2)^{5/2}} \, =\,R $$

How could I go about proving:-

(1) $D_1$ = $D_2$,

(SOLVED, I think, by my two answers below, but using WolframAlpha to obtain integral solutions) $$$$

(2) $D_1$ = $R$ or $D_2$ = $R$.

(MOVED to a separate question: Prove $\int_0^{2\pi}\frac{3a\sin^2\theta}{(1-a\cos \theta)^4}$ or $\int_0^{2\pi}\frac{\cos\theta}{(1-a\cos\theta)^3}=\frac{3a\pi}{(1-a^2)^{5/2}}$).


You can see how WolframAlpha produces these results by inputting the following input texts:-

For Eqtn 1 with a=0.1 input: integrate (3*0.1(sinx)^2)/((1-0.1*cosx)^4) from x=0 to 2*pi

For Eqtn 2 with a=0.1 input: integrate (cosx)/((1-0.1*cosx)^3) from x=0 to 2*pi

for Result with a=0.1 input: evaluate 3 0.1 pi/(1-0.1^2)^(5/2)


WolframAlpha also computes expressions for the indefinite integrals as follows:- $$I_1 \, =\, \int\frac{3a\sin^2\theta}{(1-a\cos \theta)^4}\mathrm{d}\theta \,=\, $$ $$constant1 + \frac {a\,\sqrt{a^2-1}\sin\theta\,[-(2a^3+a)\cos^2\theta+3(a^2+1)cos\theta+a(2a^2-5)]} {2(a^2-1)^{5/2}(a\cos\theta-1)^3} $$

$$-\frac {6a\,(a\cos\theta-1)^3\,\tanh^-1 \left( \frac{(a+1)\tan(\theta/2)}{\sqrt{a^2-1}} \right) } {(2(a^2-1)^{5/2}\,(a\cos\theta-1)^3} $$ $$$$ $$$$

$$I_2 \, =\, \int\frac{\cos \theta}{(1-a\cos \theta)^3}\,\mathrm{d}\theta \, =\, $$ $$constant2 - \frac {2a^2\sin\theta-sin\theta} {2(a^2-1)^2(a\cos\theta-1)} -\frac {\sin\theta} {2(a^2-1)(a\cos\theta-1)^2} $$

$$ -\frac {3a\tanh^-1\left(\frac{(a+1)\tan(\theta/2)}{\sqrt{a^2-1}}\right)} {(a^2-1)^{5/2}} $$ Note that the final terms of each expression are equivalent to each other. This could be useful. For example we can define a difference function $f_3 = f_1-f_2$ whose indefinite integral $I_3 = I_1-I_2$ will exclude the common awkward third term.

Let us assume that $f_3$ is continuously integrable over the range $0,2\pi$ (we cannot be sure by inspection alone, but it can be shown, see my answer below). Then, if $D_1=D_2$ over the range $0,2\pi$ then $D_1-D_2=0$ and so $D_3$ (=$\int_0^{2\pi}f_3\,d\theta$) should have value zero. This is expanded on in my answer below.

  • 3
    $\begingroup$ Have you taken any Complex Analysis class? $\endgroup$ – Yiorgos S. Smyrlis Oct 20 '14 at 20:04
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ $${\sin^{2}\left(\theta\right) \over \left[1 - \cos\left(\theta\right)\right]^{4}} \sim {16 \over \theta^{6}}\ \mbox{when}\ \theta\sim 0$$. Do they converge ?. $\endgroup$ – Felix Marin Oct 20 '14 at 20:22
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Can you include some of your WA testing? As Felix has just indicated, there are problems of convergence with these integrals... $\endgroup$ – Semiclassical Oct 20 '14 at 20:24
  • $\begingroup$ Apologies, I missed a factor "a" from the LHS denominators. Now corrected. $\endgroup$ – steveOw Oct 20 '14 at 21:41
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ You can at least prove that the two integrals are equal by a simple integration by parts, though this doesn't tell you what the value is. $\endgroup$ – David H Oct 20 '14 at 21:46


Observe that,

$$\frac{\partial}{\partial a}\left[\frac{1}{\left(1-a\cos{\theta}\right)^2}\right]=\frac{2\cos{\theta}}{\left(1-a\cos{\theta}\right)^3}.$$

Thus, we can simplify the integral we have to compute via the technique of differentiating under the integral sign:

$$\begin{align} I(a) &=\int_{0}^{2\pi}\frac{\cos{\theta}}{\left(1-a\cos{\theta}\right)^3}\,\mathrm{d}\theta\\ &=\frac12\int_{0}^{2\pi}\frac{\partial}{\partial a}\left[\frac{1}{\left(1-a\cos{\theta}\right)^2}\right]\,\mathrm{d}\theta\\ &=\frac12\frac{\partial}{\partial a}\int_{0}^{2\pi}\frac{\mathrm{d}\theta}{\left(1-a\cos{\theta}\right)^2}.\\ \end{align}$$

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks. I am reading up on "differentiation under the integral" and hopefully will apply it in my separate answer. But maybe instead use d/da[1/(1 - a cos \theta)^3]? $\endgroup$ – steveOw Oct 21 '14 at 11:36
  • $\begingroup$ Differentiation under the integral is beyond my present ability so I have "cheated" and used WolframAlpha (see my answer). I would be interested to see how d-u-t-i can be applied to this problem but it looks like it will be a lot of effort. Cheers :-). – $\endgroup$ – steveOw Oct 23 '14 at 10:10
  • $\begingroup$ Aha, I was thinking this hint referred to integrating by parts (your earlier comment) but now I see IBP solves the first part of the problem, quite simply. I will do another answer based on IBP (unless you would like to do it yourself?). $\endgroup$ – steveOw Oct 24 '14 at 18:12


Consider whether the Difference Function $\,f_3=f_1-f_2$ integrates to zero over the interval $0,2\pi$. If it does then $D_1 = D_2$.


The difference function does integrate to zero over the given interval. Therefore the two definite integrals $D_1$ and $D_2$ are equal.


Let us try to prove the hypothesis that the two definite integral expressions $D_1$, $D_2$ are equal for all values of $a$ (where $0<a<1$), i.e. $$ D_1= \int_0^{2\pi}\frac{3a\sin^2\theta}{(1-a\cos \theta)^4} d\theta =\int_0^{2\pi}\frac{(1-a \cos\theta)\cos \theta}{(1-a\cos \theta)^4}d\theta =D_2 $$

Let us define functions $f_1$, $f_2$ and their respective indefinite integrals $I_1$ and $I_2$ such that $$ I_1(a,\theta) = \int f_1(a,\theta) \, \mathrm{d}\theta =\int\frac{3a\sin^2\theta}{(1-a\cos \theta)^4} d\theta $$ and $$I_2(a,\theta) = \int f_2(a,\theta) \, \mathrm{d}\theta =\int\frac{(1-a \cos\theta)\cos \theta}{(1-a\cos \theta)^4}d\theta $$

WolframAlpha gives us for the indefinite integrals $I_1$ and $I_2$ $$I_1(a,\theta) \, =\, \int\frac{3a\sin^2\theta}{(1-a\cos \theta)^4}\mathrm{d}\theta \,=\, $$ $$constant1 + \frac {a\,\sqrt{a^2-1}\sin\theta\,[-(2a^3+a)\cos^2\theta+3(a^2+1)cos\theta+a(2a^2-5)]} {2(a^2-1)^{5/2}(a\cos\theta-1)^3} $$

$$-\frac {6a\,(a\cos\theta-1)^3\,\tanh^-1 \left( \frac{(a+1)\tan(\theta/2)}{\sqrt{a^2-1}} \right) } {(2(a^2-1)^{5/2}\,(a\cos\theta-1)^3} $$ and $$I_2(a,\theta) \, =\, \int\frac{\cos \theta}{(1-a\cos \theta)^3}\,\mathrm{d}\theta \, =\, $$ $$constant2 - \frac {2a^2\sin\theta-sin\theta} {2(a^2-1)^2(a\cos\theta-1)} -\frac {\sin\theta} {2(a^2-1)(a\cos\theta-1)^2} $$

$$ -\frac {3a\tanh^-1\left(\frac{(a+1)\tan(\theta/2)}{\sqrt{a^2-1}}\right)} {(a^2-1)^{5/2}} $$

If the functions $I_1$ and $I_2$ were continuous over the interval $0,2\pi$ we could simply test whether the following statement is true: $$I_1(a,2\pi) - I_1(a,0) = I_2(a,2\pi) - I_2(a,0)$$ However the functions $I_1$ and $I_2$ are not continuous over the interval $0,2\pi$. This is due to the incorporation, in both of these functions, of the awkward term involving $\tanh^1()$ and $\tan(\theta/2)$ which produces a singularity when $\theta/2 = \pi/2$.

As an alternative approach let us obtain the function $I_3$ which is the indefinite integral of the Difference Function $f_3$ defined by $$f3(a,\theta) =f1(a,\theta)-f2(a,\theta)$$

As mentioned in the Question ( Update 2 ) subtraction of $I_2$ from $I_1$ will eliminate from $I_3$ the awkward final term in $\tanh^-1()$ which is common to both $I_1$ and $I_2$. Presumably then, although I haven't proved it, we could find a simple expression for $I_3$ by algebraic rationalisation of $I_1 - I_2$.

Conveniently however, when given the formula for $I_3$, WolframAlpha returns a simple result thus

$$I_3(a,\theta) = \int\frac{3a\sin^2\theta - \cos \theta(1-a \cos\theta)} {(1-a\cos \theta)^4} d\theta =\frac{sin\theta}{(a\cos\theta-1)^3}+ constant3 $$

Now, to prove that $D_1=D_2$ we simply need to show that $D_3=0$. This can be done by showing that $I_3(a,2\pi)-I_3(a,0) = 0$.

Knowing that $\sin(2\pi)=\sin(0)=0$ and that $\cos(2\pi)=\cos(0)=1$, it is simple to show that

$$ I_3(a,2\pi)=\frac{sin(2\pi)}{(a\cos(2\pi)-1)^3}+ constant3= 0+ constant3 $$ and $$ I_3(a,0)=\frac{sin(0)}{(a\cos(0)-1)^3}+ constant3= 0+ constant3 $$ So $$ I_3(a,2\pi)-I_3(a,0) = 0+ constant3 -(0+ constant3) = 0 $$ Therefore the original hypothesis is confirmed: $$ \int_0^{2\pi}\frac{3a\sin^2\theta}{(1-a\cos \theta)^4} d\theta =\int_0^{2\pi}\frac{(1-a \cos\theta)\cos \theta}{(1-a\cos \theta)^4}d\theta $$


Note: Part (2) of the question is not answered by this.


(as per David H's suggestion to use Integration By Parts)

Hypothesis: The two definite integrals $D_1$ and $D_2$ have the same value, i.e. $D_1 = D_2$.

Using integration by parts $$ \int uv' \,d\theta= uv-\int u'v \,d\theta $$ let us define $$ u = \frac{1}{(1-a\cos\theta)^3} \qquad v' = \cos\theta $$ So ($u'$ obtained from WolframAlpha) $$ u'=\frac{-3a\sin\theta}{(1-a\cos\theta)^4} \qquad v=\sin\theta $$ Then $$ \int\frac{\cos\theta}{(1-a\cos\theta)^3}\,d\theta= uv - \int u'v\, d\theta $$

$$=\frac{-\sin\theta}{(1-a\cos\theta)^3} -\int \frac{-3a\sin^2\theta}{(1-a\cos\theta)^4} $$ So $$\int\frac{\cos\theta}{(1-a\cos\theta)^3}\,d\theta= \frac{-\sin\theta}{(1-a\cos\theta)^3} +\int \frac{3a\sin^2\theta}{(1-a\cos\theta)^4}\,d\theta. $$ Now consider the definite integrals over the range $0,2\pi$

$$\int_0^{2\pi}\frac{\cos\theta}{(1-a\cos\theta)^3}\,d\theta= \left[\frac{-\sin\theta}{(1-a\cos\theta)^3}\right]_0^{2\pi} +\int_0^{2\pi} \frac{3a\sin^2\theta}{(1-a\cos\theta)^4}\,d\theta $$ The term in square brackets clearly goes to zero over the range $0,2\pi$ because $\sin(0)=\sin(2\pi)=0$ and therefore we have $D_1=D_2$.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.