I'm having trouble understanding Corollary 1.28 of Hatcher which proves that for every group $G$ there is a space $X_G$ such that $\pi_1(X_G)=G$.

Since $G$ is the quotient of a free group $F$, we have some map $\varphi\colon F\to G$ with kernel $K$. Let $g_\alpha$ be the generators of $F$, and $r_\beta$ the generators of $K$. He gets $G=\langle g_\alpha\mid r_\beta\rangle$ is a presentation of the group. I follows this so far.

Then the construction follows by attaching $2$-cells $e_\beta^2$ to the wedge $\bigvee_\alpha S^1_\alpha$ by the words specified by $r_\beta$. I don't get why attaching the $2$-cells in this ways makes things work out.

There is a proposition on the preceding page that says the inclusion $X\to Y$ induces a surjection $\pi_1(X,x_0)\to\pi_1(Y,x_0)$ with kernel the space generated by all loops $\gamma_\alpha\varphi_\alpha\gamma_\alpha^{-1}$ for varying $\alpha$, where $\gamma_\alpha$ is a path from $x_0$ to $\varphi_\alpha(s_0)$ for each attaching map $\varphi_\alpha$ of $e_\alpha^2$.

So I assume the specific case here is that the inclusion $\bigvee_\alpha S^1_\alpha\to X_G$ leads to an isomorphism $\pi_1(X_G)\simeq\pi_1(\bigvee S^1_\alpha)/N$. I know $\pi_1(\bigvee S^1_\alpha)\simeq F$, but I can't see why the $N$ generated by the loops should be the same as $K$ generated by the words to get the desired isomorphism.


The subgroup $K < F$ is the kernel of $\phi$. Being a kernel, it's a normal subgroup. Its generators (as a subgroup) are the $r_\beta$.

In the definition of $X_G$, the $\phi_\beta$ are taken to be loops such that $[\phi_\beta] = r_\beta \in \pi_1(X, x_0)$. Therefore as you say $N$ is generated (as a subgroup) by all the $[\gamma] r_\beta [\gamma]^{-1}$. This group $N$ clearly contains $K$ (because for $\gamma$ a constant loop you get that $r_\beta \in N$, $\forall \beta$). On the other hand, $K$ is normal, so every $[\gamma] r_\beta [\gamma]^{-1}$ is actually also in $K$, and therefore $N \subset K$. Therefore, $N = K$.

| cite | improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.