3
$\begingroup$

While solving problems on indefinite integrals many a times I get answers which are different from those given in my text book's answer keys page. I then verify my solution steps to ensure that even my answer is correct. Now my question is, Can it have different answers? If yes how can I ensure that all those different answers are correct?

$\endgroup$
  • 5
    $\begingroup$ Any two answers must differ by a constant. Note you could always check your proposed answer by differentiating it and seeing if it gives the integrand back. $\endgroup$ – David Mitra Jul 13 '14 at 13:32
  • 4
    $\begingroup$ You can have answers which look different but which are identical. This can be the case with trigonometric or hyperbolic functions. But, as David Mitra commented, it is always a good practice to check you result differentiating it. $\endgroup$ – Claude Leibovici Jul 13 '14 at 13:35
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Here's an example for Claude Leibovici's comment: $$\int \frac{1}{\sqrt{1+x^2}}\, dx={\rm arcsinh}\left(x\right) = \log{(x+\sqrt{1+x^2})}$$ $\endgroup$ – gar Jul 13 '14 at 14:24
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ In case of function over disconnected domain, your answer will be differ by a bunch of constant, each constant for each connected subset of the domain. $\endgroup$ – Gina Jul 19 '14 at 7:36
1
$\begingroup$

Indeed this will be the case when answers differ by a constant. An example where this is not so obvious is the integral of something like $1/(3x)$. By taking a third out of the integral you would get the result of $$\frac{\ln(x)}{3}+C,$$ but by multiplying the top by $3$, and multiplying the integral by $1/3$ you would get $$\frac{\ln(3x)}{3}+c.$$ These look starkly different however you may notice that $$ln(3x) = ln(x) + ln(3).$$ So the two answers do indeed differ by a constant. Of particular interest is the fact that if you differentiate both answers they will be the same.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ What does the last sentence refer to? When I differentiate $\frac{\ln(x)}3+C$ and $\frac{\ln(3x)}3+c$, I get the same thing. $\endgroup$ – Milo Brandt Jan 14 '16 at 20:49
0
$\begingroup$

Two factors may be in play: first, note that indefinite integrals always include an arbitrary constant, which means that different approaches may result in shifting the rest by a constant. For example, your book might say that the solution is $\sin(x) + c$, while your answer is $\sin(x) + 1 + c$; there's no difference, because the $c$ "eats" the $1$. It can be more cleverly disguised; as noted in Orange Peel's answer, $\ln(3x)$ and $\ln(x)$ differ only by a constant, $\ln(3)$, so if you get $\ln(3x)+c$ and your text says $\ln(x)+c$ you're still right.

The second factor is just plain old simplification. Especially when it comes to trigonometric expressions and logarithms, it's not always obvious when two expressions are the same; for example, $\sec^2(x)\cos(x) = \cos(x) + \tan(x)\sin(x)$. In doing an integral, using one approach might give you one expression, and another approach might give you another; both are right, but it's not immediately obvious that they're the same. This can be further complicated by the first factor; $\sec^2(x) = \tan^2(x) + 1$, so $\sec^2(x) + c$ and $\tan^2(x) + c$ are equivalent as solutions to an indefinite integral.

On the other hand, there are no cases in which an integral actually has two different solutions; they can only "look" different. For example, $x + c$ and $x^2 + c$ cannot both be solutions to the same integral, because $x$ and $x^2$ don't differ by a constant.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.