Assume $(E, e_0)$ and $(B, b_0)$ are based spaces with the indicated base points.

Given a based fibration $p: E \rightarrow B$. We have the respective homotopy: fiber \begin{equation} Fp= \{(e,\beta) | \beta(1)=p(e)\} \subset E \times F(I,B) \end{equation} I wrote $F(I,B)$ as the path space for $B$ or space of based maps from the unit interval to $B$ that send $0$ to $b_0$.

Question: The fibre $F=p^{-1}(b_0)$ has an inclusion map $\phi: F \rightarrow Fp$ where $e \mapsto (e, c_{b_0})$ is an homotopy equivalence.

What I've thought of so far: The path mapping space $Np=\{(e, \beta)| \beta(1)=p(e)\}\subset E \times F(I_{+}, B)$. $I_{+}$ is a the union of the unit interval and some arbitrary disjoint base point.

We can replace $p: E \rightarrow B$ with the composition of $\nu:E \rightarrow Np$ with $ \rho: Np \rightarrow B$. $\nu$ will send $e \mapsto (e, c_{p(e)})$ and $\rho$ will send $(e,\beta) \mapsto \beta(1)$.

The map $\nu$ is a homotopy equivalence since we can deform $Np$ to $\nu(E)$ using the homotopy which sends $(e, \beta(t), s)$ to $(e, \beta((1-s)t)$. We also have that $\rho^{-1}(b_0)$ is the homotopy fiber $Fp$.

It is difficult to pull off a similar deformation if there is one. This is where I am currently stuck and any hints on the matter will be helpful.


This is a very general fact about model categories and homotopy pullbacks, as evidenced by Zhen Lin's comment. It's also proven as a special case of Proposition 4.65 in Hatcher's book. Let me nevertheless spell out the argument precisely for topological spaces.

Define $E_p = \{ (y, \gamma) \in E \times B^{[0,1]} \mid p(y) = \gamma(0) \}$. There's a map (in fact a fibration) $q : E_p \to B$, $(y,\gamma) \mapsto \gamma(1)$, and the homotopy fiber is the fiber $F_p = q^{-1}(b_0)$. The inclusion $$i : F = p^{-1}(b_0) \to F_p$$ is given by $i(y) = (y, \mathrm{cst}_{b_0})$.

Define a homotopy $g_t : E_p \to B$, $(y,\gamma) \mapsto \gamma(t)$. Then $g_0(y, \gamma) = \gamma(0) = p(y)$, so $g_0$ lifts through $p$ by $\bar{g}_0 : E_p \to E$, $\bar{g}_0(y,\gamma) = y$ (i.e. $p \circ \bar{g}_0 = g_0$). Because $E \to B$ is a fibration, by the homotopy lifting property, there is a full lift $\bar{g}_t : E_p \to E$ of $g_t$ through $p$. In other words, $\bar{g}_t$ satisfies the following equation: $$p(\bar{g}_t(y,\gamma)) = \gamma(t).$$

Now restrict everything to the fibers: let $h_t : F_p \to F_p$ be given by $h_t(y,\gamma) = \bigl(\bar{g}_t(y,\gamma), \gamma_{\mid [t,1]} \bigr)$ (because of the previous equation, this is in $F_p$). Then $h_0$ is the identity, whereas $h_1(y,\gamma) = (\bar{g}_1(y,\gamma), \mathrm{cst}_{b_0})$ is in the image of $i : F \to F_p$. And now that $h_t$ is a homotopy between $ih_1$ and the identity, while the restriction of $h_t$ is a homotopy between $h_1i$ and the identity. Thus $F$ and $F_p$ are homotopy equivalent.

Final remark: it's much simpler to prove that $F$ and $F_p$ are weakly homotopy equivalent, because the map $i$ induces easily an isomorphism on all homotopy groups. The square $$\require{AMScd} \begin{CD} E @>>> E_p \\ @VVV @VVV \\ B @>>> B \end{CD}$$ induces a map between the long exact sequences of the respective fibrations: $$\begin{CD} \dots @>>> \pi_n(F) @>>> \pi_n(E) @>>> \pi_n(B) @>>> \pi_{n-1}(E) @>>> \dots \\ @. @VVV @VVV @VVV @VVV @. \\ \dots @>>> \pi_n(F_p) @>>> \pi_n(E_p) @>>> \pi_n(B) @>>> \pi_{n-1}(E) @>>> \dots \end{CD}$$ Since $E$ and $E_p$ are homotopy weakly homotopy equivalent ($PB$ is contractible), and so by the five lemma and induction, the maps $\pi_n(F) \to \pi_n(F_p)$ are isomorphisms.

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks, this looks to be what I was looking for. $\endgroup$ – user135520 Sep 28 '15 at 15:31
  • $\begingroup$ "is given by $(y, \text{cst}_{b_0})$." What does the cst stand for here? $\endgroup$ – user268197 Oct 17 '15 at 20:52
  • $\begingroup$ @BrianNg This is the constant map equal to $b_0$. $\endgroup$ – Najib Idrissi Oct 18 '15 at 7:16

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.