I have following question:

Fields with equal divergence and equal curls $F_1$ and $F_2$ are two vectors fields, you may write them as $F_1 = M_1i+N_1j+P_1k$, $F_2 = M_2i+N_2j+P_2k$. Suppose that $\nabla \cdot F_1 = \nabla \cdot F_2$ and $\nabla \times F_1 = \nabla \times F_2$ over a region D enclosed by the oriented surface S with outward unit normal n and that $F_1 \cdot n = F_2 \cdot n$ on S. Prove that $F_1=F_2$ throughout D.

I came across this question when studying "Stokes's Theorem and Divergence Theorem" in Thomas Calculus, so I suppose we should use either of them to solve this, except I don't know how.
All I could figure out is $$F_1 \cdot n = F_2 \cdot n\Rightarrow\iint\limits_s F_1 \cdot n \, d\sigma = \iint\limits_s F_2 \cdot n \, d\sigma\Rightarrow\iiint\limits_D \nabla \times F_1\, dv = \iiint\limits_D \nabla \times F_2 \, dv,$$ the last step using divergence theorem. Or $$\nabla \times F_1 = \nabla \times F_2 \Rightarrow\iint\limits_s \nabla \times F_1\cdot n \, d\sigma= \iint\limits_s \nabla \times F_2 \cdot n \, d\sigma \Rightarrow \oint\limits_c F_1 \cdot dr =\oint\limits_c F_2 \cdot dr,$$ the last step using Stokes's theorem. This is all I get, then what? Am I on a wrong path? Can anyone solve this problem? Thanks.


Setting $F=F_1-F_2$, we're supposed to prove that: if $F \cdot n=0$ on $S$ and $\nabla\cdot F=0$, $\nabla\times F=0$ in $D$ then $F=0$ in $D$. We actually need one more assumption: $D$ is simply connected (the statement is not true e.g. for the solid torus). $\nabla\times F=0$ implies that there is a function $f$ such that $F=\nabla f$ (here we use that $D$ is simply-connected). The condition $\nabla\cdot F=0$ becomes $\Delta f=0$.

Now the standard trick is $\nabla\cdot(f\nabla f)=\nabla f\cdot\nabla f+f\Delta f=\nabla f\cdot\nabla f$, hence $$\iiint_D \nabla f\cdot\nabla f\, dV =\iiint_D\nabla \cdot (f\nabla f)\, dV=\iint_S f\nabla f \cdot n\,dS=0$$ as $\nabla f \cdot n=F \cdot n=0$. Since $\nabla f\cdot\nabla f\geq0$ and the integral is $0$, we get $\nabla f=0$, i.e. $F=0$.

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks very much! This is the correct answer. $\endgroup$ – wangshuaijie May 23 '14 at 8:18

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.