I would like to know necessary and sufficient conditions on $x$ and $y$ to have $\langle x,y\rangle=\langle x\rangle\langle xy\rangle$.

Sure that:

$\bullet$ $\langle x\rangle$ and $\langle xy\rangle$ must commute (otherwise the product wouldn't be a group).

$\bullet$ $x\notin\langle xy\rangle$, otherwise $\langle xy\rangle=\langle x,y\rangle$ (in fact $x\in\langle xy\rangle\Rightarrow x^{-1}\in\langle xy\rangle\Rightarrow y\in\langle xy\rangle$) hence we would have that a group generated by two elements is cyclic, a contradiction (it's implicit that 2 is the lowest number of generators). Similarly $y\notin\langle xy\rangle$.

But I can't extrapolate more informations. If someone help me it would be great. Thanks


Suppose $x,y \in G$ and $G$ is some group. Then $\langle x,y\rangle$ is always a group, so if $\langle x \rangle \langle xy \rangle$ is a group then $\langle x \rangle \langle xy \rangle = \langle xy \rangle\langle x \rangle$ (that is $\langle x \rangle$ and $\langle xy \rangle$ permute in the modern English language). Conversely suppose $\langle x \rangle$ and $\langle xy \rangle$ permute. Then $x = x (xy)^0 \in \langle x \rangle \langle xy \rangle$ and $y = x^{-1} (xy)^1 \in \langle x \rangle \langle xy \rangle$, so $\langle x,y \rangle \leq \langle x \rangle \langle xy \rangle$. Of course $x^i (xy)^j \in \langle x,y\rangle$ so $\langle x \rangle \langle xy \rangle \subset \langle x,y \rangle$.

Hence the necessary and sufficient condition for $\langle x,y \rangle = \langle x \rangle \langle xy \rangle$ is that $\langle x \rangle$ and $\langle xy \rangle$ permute.

I'm not sure what you want to say as far as $\langle x,y \rangle$ not being cyclic.

  • $\begingroup$ Thank you Jack! However my definition of cylcic group is a group that is generated by one element. Hence $\langle x,y\rangle$ couldn't be cyclic by definition. $\endgroup$ – Joe Apr 10 '14 at 17:53

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.