I have a problem understanding Stokes' Theorem and Gauss' Divergence Theorem. Suppose the following:

Let $F$ be a vector field in $\Bbb R^3$. Let $S$ be an oriented closed smooth Surface enclosing a volume $V$ and let $C$ be a positively-oriented closed curve surrounding $S$

Stokes' Theorem says: $$ \int_C F·dr=\iint_S (\nabla \times F) · dS $$

Then, by the Divergence Theorem: $$ \iint_S (\nabla \times F)·dS = \iiint_V \nabla·(\nabla \times F) dV $$

But $ \nabla·(\nabla \times F)=0$. So everything is $0$

What is it that I am not seeing?

  • 6
    $\begingroup$ If $S$ encloses $V$, then there is no curve $C$ surrounding $S$, since $S$ is a closed surface (or a "sum" of several such). $\endgroup$ – Daniel Fischer Feb 23 '14 at 21:28
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks, I know understand how Stockes' theorem works, I was quite confused! $\endgroup$ – Francisco Feb 24 '14 at 13:05

While Daniel Fischer's answer probably is more direct, I find this way of showing that the circulation over a closed surface is zero (using Stokes theorem) more intuitive:

A closed surface split in two open surfaces

Here I split the closed surface $S$ into two surfaces $S_1$ and $S_2$ with a shared boundary, the curve $C_1$. If we apply Stokes theorem to the two surfaces separately we get:

$$\int{\int_{S_1} (\nabla \times \bar F) d \bar S} = \int_{C_1} {\bar F \cdot d \bar r}$$


$$\int{\int_{S_2} (\nabla \times \bar F) d \bar S} = - \int_{C_1} {\bar F \cdot d \bar r}$$

notice the negative sign before the right hand integral in the second equation. This is because the curve $C_1$ runs in the opposite direction to the normals of $S_2$ compared to $S_1$.

Combing the two surface integrals to get the integral over the entire surface, $S = S_1 \cup S_2$:

$$ \begin{eqnarray} \int{\int_{S} (\nabla \times \bar F) d \bar S} &=& \int{\int_{S_1} (\nabla \times \bar F) d \bar S} + \int{\int_{S_2} (\nabla \times \bar F) d \bar S} \\ \int{\int_{S} (\nabla \times \bar F) d \bar S} &=& \int_{C_1} {\bar F \cdot d \bar r} - \int_{C_1} {\bar F \cdot d \bar r} \\ &=& 0 \end{eqnarray} $$


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.