Let $f: [a,b] \rightarrow \mathbb R$ be of bounded variation. For $y \in \mathbb R$, define the Banach Indicatrix of $y$ by $N(y) = \# f^{pre} (y)$, ie. $N(y)$ is the cardinality of the pre-image of $y$ under $f$. I seek to prove the following: .

(a) N(y) is finite for almost every $y \in \mathbb R$

(b) The function $y \mapsto N(y)$ is measurable.

(c) The total variation of $f$ is given by $TV(f) = \int_c ^d N(y) dy$.

I have tried partitioning $[a,b]$ and looking at the variation over them in order to bound the size of the set where $N(y)$ is infinite, but this hasn't yielded much success.

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ I think that $\int_{c}^{d} N(y)\,dy$ only gives the total variation of the continuous part of $f$ in the Lebesgue decomposition. Consider the characteristic function of a subinterval of $[a,b]$, for example. $\endgroup$ – t.b. Sep 30 '11 at 16:51

I can only answer the question for continuous functions, but I hope that this is a start. As I mentioned in my comment, I suspect that the statement of your question needs to be modified: I would expect $N$ to be measurable at least for Borel measurable functions and if $f$ is measurable and of bounded variation then I think $\int N$ should give the total variation of the continuous part of $f$ in the Lebesgue decomposition. Maybe a refinement of the argument below yields the result for general functions of bounded variation, but admittedly, I don't see how to do that at the moment.

The argument I present is Banach's, as given in Sur les lignes rectifiables et les surfaces dont l'aire est finie, Fund. Math. 7 (1925), 225–236 (Théorèmes 1 and 2), which I reproduce here for the convenience of the readers who don't read French.

Let $f\colon [a,b] \to \mathbb{R}$ be a continuous function and for $t \in \mathbb{R}$ let $N(t) = \# f^{-1}(t)$.

a) The function $t \mapsto N(t)$ is measurable.

For $k \geq 1$ partition the interval $[a,b]$ into $2^k$ intervals $I_{1}^{(k)},\ldots,I_{2^k}^{(k)}$ of length $2^{-k}(b-a)$. For $y \in \mathbb{R}$ and $1 \leq n \leq 2^k$ let $$ L_{n}^{(k)}(t) = \begin{cases} 1, & \text{if } t \in f(I_{n}^{(k)}), \\ 0, & \text{otherwise.} \end{cases} $$ Note that $t \mapsto L_{n}^{(k)}(t)$ is measurable because it has at most two points of discontinuity, therefore the function $$ N_k(t) = L_{1}^{(k)}(t) + \cdots + L_{2^k}^{(k)}(t) $$ is also measurable. Note that $N_k(t)$ simply counts on how many of the intervals $I_{1}^{(k)},\ldots,I_{2^k}^{(k)}$ the function $f$ attains the value $t$ at least once. Thus, the sequence $(N_k)_{k=1}^\infty$ of measurable functions is increasing and therefore the pointwise limit $$ \widetilde{N}(t) = \lim_{k\to\infty} N_k(t) $$ exists and is a measurable function of $t$. Observe that by definition $N(t) \geq N_k(t)$ for all $k$, so $N(t) \geq \widetilde{N}(t)$. Let us argue that $\widetilde{N}(t) \geq N(t)$. Let $m$ be an integer such that $N(t) \geq m$. Then there exist points $a \leq x_1 \lt \cdots \lt x_m \leq b$ such that $f(x_i) = t$. If $k$ is so large that $\frac{b-a}{2^k} \lt \min{\{x_{i+1} - x_i\,:\,i=1,\dots,m-1\}}$ then $N_k(t) \geq m$. This shows $\widetilde{N}(t) \geq N(t)$ and thus $\widetilde{N}(t) = N(t)$, establishing measurability.

Note: Since $L_{n}^{(k)}$ only has no more than two discontinuities, it is at most of first Baire class, hence so are the $N_k$ and thus their pointwise limit $N$ is of Baire class at most two.

b) Let $f$ be a continuous function. Then $N$ is integrable if and only if $f$ is of bounded variation and in that case $\operatorname{Var}_{a}^b(f) = \int N$.

Keep the notations of part a). Let $M_{n}^{(k)} = \sup_{x \in I_{n}^{(k)}} f(x)$ and $m_{n}^{(k)} = \inf_{x \in I_{n}^{(k)}} f(x)$. Notice that $\int L_{n}^{(k)} = M_{n}^{(k)} - m_{n}^{(k)}$ so that $\int N_k = \sum_{n=1}^{2^k} M_{n}^{(k)} - m_{n}^{(k)}$. If $f$ is of bounded variation then this last sum is bounded above by $\operatorname{Var}_{a}^b(f)$ so that the monotone convergence theorem implies that $$ \int N = \lim_{k \to \infty} \int N_k \leq \operatorname{Var}_{a}^b(f). $$ On the other hand, if $f$ is continuous (of bounded variation or not), it is not hard to show that for every $c \lt \operatorname{Var}_{a}^b(f)$ there is $\delta \gt 0$ such that for all partitions $a = a_0 \lt a_1 \lt \cdots \lt a_n = b$ with $a_{m} - a_{m-1} \lt \delta$ we have $\sum_{m=1}^n \lvert f(a_{m}) - f(a_{m-1})\rvert \geq c$. Thus, we have for $k$ sufficiently large that $\sum_{n=1}^{2^k} M_{n}^{(k)} - m_{n}^{(k)} \geq c$ and from this we conclude that $\int N \geq \operatorname{Var}_{a}^b(f)$ if the latter is finite.

Conversely, suppose that $N$ is integrable. Since $N \geq N_k$ we have that $\sum_{n=1}^{2^k} M_{n}^{(k)} - m_{n}^{(k)} = \int N_k \leq \int N \lt \infty$ for all $k$, and this implies that $\operatorname{Var}_{a}^b(f) \leq \int N$, as we wanted.

c) If $f$ is continuous and of bounded variation then $N(t) \lt \infty$ almost everywhere.

This is clear, as $\int N = \operatorname{Var}_{a}^b(f) \lt \infty$ implies that $N$ can be infinite only on a set of measure zero.

Added: See also this related question where the accepted answer mentions a paper containing necessary and sufficient conditions for a measurable function $N: \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{N} \cup \{\aleph_0, \mathfrak{c}\}$ to be the Banach indicatrix of a continuous function $f: [a,b] \to \mathbb{R}$.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.