Here is a math puzzle I've been working on - enter image description here

The set-up - I am a dog, 50 feet from the water. A rubber duck is in the water 50 feet from shore and 140 feet to my right. This makes a triangle base of 140 ft, height 100 ft. I can run 30fps on land, 4fps in water. What is the fastest I can get to the duck?

Given the only real choice is to vary the point he hits the water, I have the image showing that point, and how it produces two right triangles. So we have this equation to minimize.


Graphing this produces the conclusion that at X= 133.71, Y= 17.357. I got this far, but manipulating to get rid of radicals sent me down a rabbit hole.

Disclosure, a high school junior came to me with this problem. If the solution requires calculus, I'd love to see the method, but the students that had this problem were not that advanced.

(I'd welcome a better title for this problem)

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ I would like to see the original. $\endgroup$ – John Habert Feb 11 '14 at 18:23

The $x$-value at which $y$ attains its minimum turns out to be the smaller of the two real roots of the polynomial $11025000000 - 157500000 x + 4884100 x^2 - 61880 x^3 + 221 x^4$, which is irreducible over the integers. So I doubt any by-hand method is going to be very clean.

  • $\begingroup$ Thank you. As I started to try to remove the radicals and saw x^4 happening, I stopped. I'm wondering if the students were expected to find the equation I produced and work by trial and error to get to the numbers. $\endgroup$ – JTP - Apologise to Monica Feb 11 '14 at 23:25
  • $\begingroup$ No idea :} Sometimes the $x^4$ doesn't ruin things - if it's a biquadratic $ax^4+bx^2+c$, for example, or if it's reducible. But here I don't see what any reasonable human would do...! $\endgroup$ – Greg Martin Feb 12 '14 at 0:10
  • $\begingroup$ When I graph this, X=133.71 is a zero, which implies the equation is the first derivative already, right? Am I reading this wrong? $\endgroup$ – JTP - Apologise to Monica Feb 12 '14 at 15:10
  • $\begingroup$ I didn't mean to imply that this polynomial equals the first derivative of your function $y$. All I'm saying is that the root of the derivative of $y$ near $133.71$ is also a root of this polynomial. $\endgroup$ – Greg Martin Feb 12 '14 at 17:26
  • $\begingroup$ got it, thanks again. $\endgroup$ – JTP - Apologise to Monica Feb 12 '14 at 18:12

Refer to the below diagram (hopefully this diagram is clear enough, sorry for the poor quality):

enter image description here

We want to reach from the point $P$ to the point $Q$ in the shortest amount of time. For your problem, $a=50,\,b=50$ and $c=140$. Our speed in water $v_w=4$ and on land, $v_l=30$.

Let the optimal point at which we should reach the interface between land and water be at a horizontal distance $x$ from $Q$ (in the direction of $P$).

The time taken to traverse $PR$ is $\dfrac{\sqrt{(c-x)^2+b^2}}{v_l}$ and to traverse $RQ$ is $\dfrac{\sqrt{a^2+x^2}}{v_w}$.

So, we want to minimize $t=\dfrac{\sqrt{(c-x)^2+b^2}}{v_l}+\dfrac{\sqrt{a^2+x^2}}{v_w}$.

We differentiate the above with respect to $x$ and set it equal to $0$.

We get, $\dfrac{-(c-x)}{v_l\sqrt{(c-x)^2+b^2}}+\dfrac{x}{v_w\sqrt{a^2+x^2}}=0$

or $\dfrac{x}{v_w\sqrt{a^2+x^2}}=\dfrac{(c-x)}{v_l\sqrt{(c-x)^2+b^2}}$.

From the figure, $\dfrac{x}{\sqrt{a^2+x^2}}=\sin m$ and $\dfrac{(c-x)}{\sqrt{(c-x)^2+b^2}}=\sin n$.

Thus, $\dfrac{\sin m}{v_w}=\dfrac{\sin n}{v_l}$.

Hence, we want to reach the water at a point such that the angles $m$ and $n$ satisfy the above equation. As is clear from the geometry, the angles $n$ and $m$ are constrained such that if one of them is determined then both of them are. We can obtain this constraint by noting that $x=c-b\tan n$ and thus, $\tan m=\dfrac{x}{a}=\dfrac{c-b\tan n}{a}$.

This is not a complete solution since solving these two equations for $m$ and $n$ is probably as difficult as solving the quartic presented by Greg Martin. But this hopefully provides a nice interpretation to the nature of the solution.

This problem is usually discussed in relation to Snell's law in ray optics. Snell's law can be derived from Fermat's principle which states that the path taken by light between two points is such that it takes light the least amount of time to traverse it. Thus, you can interpret the above problem as a ray of light going from point $P$ to $Q$ with speed $v_l$ in air and $v_w$ in water. Since light follows the principle of least time, we have shown the above relation $\dfrac{\sin m}{v_w}=\dfrac{\sin n}{v_l}$ (which is Snell's law) holds for light (go to the links for more details).


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.