This is a question from Hatcher's Algebraic Topology (Chapter 0, Question 13):

13. Show that any two deformation retractions $r^0_t$ and $r^1_t$ of a space $X$ onto a subspace $A$ can be joined by a continuous family of deformation retractions $r^s_t, 0 \leq s \leq 1$, of $X$ onto $A$, where continuity means that the map $X \times I \times I \to X$ sending $(x,s,t)$ to $r^s_t(x)$ is continuous.

I have the feeling that this problem needs to use techniques and ideas from the Homotopy Extension section of the chapter. In particular, I have been able to find a homotopy from $r^0_t$ to $r^1_t$, by the following means:

There exists a retraction from $I \times I \to \partial I \times I \cup I \times \{ 0 \}$. From this we can obtain an retraction

$$ X \times I \times I \to X \times \partial I \times I \cup X \times I \times \{ 0 \}. $$

The homotopy extension characterization states $(X \times I, X \times \partial I)$ satisfies the homotopy extension property which yields an extension (by the following composition):

$$ X \times I \times I \to X \times \partial I \times I \cup X \times I \times \{ 0 \} \to X, $$

that agrees with $r^0_t$ and $r^1_t$.

The issue I have is that I can't show that $r^s_t \|_A$ is the identity map. Nor am I able to show that $r^s_1(X) \subset A$ for all $s$. Can anyone offer some help here? Perhaps my idea just isn't going to work and there is something else we are supposed to try here.

  • $\begingroup$ Although it's possible that there is a solution along these lines, it's simpler to just write a formula for $r_t^s(x)$ directly. $\endgroup$ – Jim Belk Jan 20 '14 at 6:36
  • $\begingroup$ Jim; were you able to find an explicit solution? I would be very curious to see this. I find it quite surprising since we don't know much about the deformation retractions or the space X. $\endgroup$ – breeden Jan 20 '14 at 7:18
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ The key idea is that you should do $s$ seconds of $r_t^1$, followed by all of $r_t^0$. $\endgroup$ – Jim Belk Jan 20 '14 at 7:40
  • $\begingroup$ Jim; I remember trying something along these lines, but ran into problems pasting them together (needing something like proving that the two retractions $r^1_1$ and $r^0_1$ are homotopic, but I'll give it another shot. I'll let you know if I still struggle afterwards. :) $\endgroup$ – breeden Jan 20 '14 at 7:52
  • $\begingroup$ Jim; I realized shortly after responding to your comment that it is indeed true that those two retractions are homotopic (and this turns out to be a very easy thing to prove). It turns your that your hint, going backward from $r^1$ to start $r^0$ all over again is actually re-deriving that the two maps are homotopic. Thanks again! $\endgroup$ – breeden Jan 20 '14 at 8:37

I finally figured out a solution to the problem. It took me a lot of trial and error and making a few leaps of faith to point me in the right direction, so it's hard for me to provide insight into how I arrived at this solution. But ultimately it steamed from when I was trying to find a homotopy from the two retractions $r^0_1$ to $r^1_1$ while keeping each step as a retraction and fixing $A$ then entire route. That approach ultimately failed, but it hinted to this solution (and is in fact a non-drastic mondification of the previous homotopy):

Define the homotopy by:

$$ r^s_t = \begin{cases} r^0_t \circ r^1_{2st} && 0 \leq s \leq \frac{1}{2} \\ r^0_{2t(1 - s)} \circ r^1_t && \frac{1}{2} \leq s \leq 1 \\ \end{cases} $$

We claim that this homotopy has the desired properties. So there is a list of properties we need to verify:

(a) $r^s_t$ is indeed a homotopy from $r^0_t$ to $r^1_t$:

  • $r^s_t$ is continuous since it's the composition of continuous maps
  • $r^0_t = r^0_t \circ r^1_0 = r^0_t$, since $r^1_0 = id_X$.
  • $r^1_t = r^0_0 \circ r^1_t = r^1_t$, since $r^0_0 = id_X$.

(b) For any fixed $s$, $r^s_t$ defines a deformation retraction from $X$ onto $A$.

  • $r^s_t$ fixes $A$ since $r^s_t$ is a composition of maps that fix $A$.
  • $r^s_0 = r^0_0 \circ r^1_0 = id_x \circ id_x = id_x$.
  • $r^s_1(X) = \begin{cases} r^0_1 \circ r^1_{2s}(X) \subset r^0_1(X) \subset A && 0 \leq s \leq \frac{1}{2} \\ r^0_{2(1 - s)} \circ r^1_1(X) \subset r^0_{2(1-s)}(A) \subset A && \frac{1}{2} \leq s \leq 1 \\ \end{cases}$

And we're done.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.