In Munkres's Topology (section 17 Closed Sets and Limit Points, 2nd edition), Theorem 17.4 shows that (below, $\bar{A}$ is the closure of $A$):

Theorem 17.4: Let $Y$ be a subspace of $X$; let $A$ be a subset of $Y$; let $\bar{A}$ denote the closure of $A$ in $X$. Then the closure of $A$ in $Y$ equals $\bar{A} \cap Y$.

Let $B$ denote the closure of $A$ in $Y$. The proof is to show that both $B \subset (\bar{A} \cap Y)$ and $(\bar{A} \cap Y) \subset B$ are satisfied. I can follow the first part; however, I am confused about the proof of $(\bar{A} \cap Y) \subset B$:

$B$ is the closure of $A$ in $Y$, so $B$ is closed in $Y$. By Theorem 17.2, $B = C \cap Y$ for some set $C$ closed in $X$. Then $C$ is a closed set of $X$ containing $A$; because $\bar{A}$ is the intersection of all such closed sets, we conclude that $\bar{A} \subset C$. Then $(\bar{A} \cap Y) \subset (C \cap Y) = B$.

My problem is that (as indicated in bold) why $C$ here is a closed set of $X$ containing $A$, especially why is $A \subset C$?


Since $B$ is the closure of $A$ (in $Y$), $A\subset B=C\cap Y\subset C$, so $A\subset C$.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.