Let $X$ be a Hausdorff space and $A$ a closed subspace. Suppose the inclusion $A \hookrightarrow X$ is a cofibration. Let $f, g: X \to Y$ be maps that agree on $A$ and which are homotopic. Are they homotopic relative to $A$?

My motivation for asking this question comes from the following result:

Let $i: A \to X, j: A \to Y$ be cofibrations. Suppose $f: X \to Y$ is a map which makes the natural triangle commutative. Suppose $f$ is a homotopy equivalence. Then $f$ is a cofiber homotopy equivalence.

On the other hand, I'm having trouble adapting the proof in Peter May's book of this to the question I asked. Nonetheless, the standard examples of pairs of maps which are homotopic but not with respect to which some subset on which they agree (say, the identity map of a comb space and its collapsing to a suitably chosen point), don't seem to involve NDR pairs.


I think the machinery of obstruction theory deals with the special case where the spaces are skeleta of a CW-complex. Here's the setup (I'm basically just copying from pp. 6-7 of Mosher & Tangora here):

Let $Y$ be simply-connected for simplicity. First, let $B$ be a complex and $A$ be a subcomplex. Let $f:A\cup B^n\rightarrow Y$. Then we get an obstruction cochain $c(f)\in C^{n+1}(B,A;\pi_n(Y))$ (i.e. a function on relative $(n+1)$-cells with values in $\pi_n(Y)$). Similarly, let $K$ be a complex; then for any two maps $f,g:K\rightarrow Y$ that agree on $K^{n-1}$, we similarly get a difference cochain $d(f,g)\in C^n(K;\pi_n(Y))$.

Here are the two results.

  • Theorem: There is a map $g:A\cup B^{n+1}\rightarrow Y$ agreeing with $f$ on $A\cup B^{n-1}$ iff $[c(f)]=0 \in H^{n+1}(B,A;\pi_n(Y))$.
  • Theorem: The restrictions of $f$ and $g$ to $X^n$ are homotopic rel $K^{n-1}$ iff $d(f,g)=0 \in C^n(K;\pi_n(Y))$. They are homotopic rel $K^{n-2}$ iff $[d(f,g)]=0 \in H^n(K;\pi_n(Y))$.
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ I just realized that this doesn't explicitly address your question -- the first theorem is about extending the definition of a map, and the second is about two maps that may or may not be homotopic (although probably you could use this to create a counterexample). Here's an easy one. Let $X=[0,1]$, $A=\{0,1\}$, $Y=S^1$. Then the degree $\pm 1$ maps $(X,A)\rightarrow (Y,*)$ agree on $A$, are homotopic, but are not homotopic rel $A$. $\endgroup$ – Aaron Mazel-Gee Oct 10 '10 at 19:32
  • $\begingroup$ Sorry for the slow response: thanks! That's a nice example. $\endgroup$ – Akhil Mathew Oct 11 '10 at 13:03

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.