I have this question in my homework and I'm unable to find what $x$ is. I keep coming up with a negative number but I don't think it can be a negative number because you can't have $\sqrt{-x}$. Here's the question:

Solve the following equation. State any restrictions on x.

$\sqrt{3x+15} = -6$

Here was my attempt at it:

$$\sqrt{3x+15} = -6^2$$

$$(3x)^2+15^2 = 36$$ $$9x^2 + 225 = 36$$ $$9x^2 + 225 - 225 = 36 - 225$$ $$9x^2 = -189$$ $$\frac{9x^2}{9} = \frac{-189}{9}$$ $$x^2 = -21$$ $$x = \sqrt{-21}$$

Now if I go backwards and try to replace $x$ with $\sqrt{-21}$ this is what happens:

$$\sqrt{3(\sqrt{-21}) + 15} = NaN$$

I understand it's because of $\sqrt{-21}$ and you can't find the squareroot of a negative number, but that means there's another solution to this. Any ideas?

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ When you square $\sqrt{x+3}$ you should get $x+3$. And the whole question is rather strange, since usually $\sqrt{b}$ is defined to be the non-negative number whose square is $b$. $\endgroup$ – André Nicolas Jan 14 '14 at 0:52

Well, your first step right out of the gate is problematic (as is your first equation, but we'll get to that in a moment).

If $x$ is a number such that $$\sqrt{3x+15}=-6,$$ then we have $$3x+15=(-6)^2.$$ This is because for any real number $b,$ $\sqrt{b}$ is necessarily a number whose square is $b.$ At that point, we have $$3x+15=36\\3x=21\\x=7.$$ However, when we resubstitute, we find that $3x+15=36$ (as we might expect), but $\sqrt{36}=6\ne-6.$ This is because $\sqrt{b}$ is defined to be the nonnegative number (if any) whose square is $b.$ If we keep that in mind, we should see that something is wrong at the very start, and that the equation has no real solution.

As a side note, $\sqrt{-x}$ does make sense if we happen to know that $x$ is a nonpositive real number. Also, $\sqrt{3x+15}$ makes sense (in the context of real numbers) exactly when $x\ge-5.$ (Why?)


$$(\sqrt{3x+15})^2 = -6^2$$

$$3x + 15 = 36~~~~\text{ Square from both sides}$$ $$3x = 21~~~~~~ \text{ Subtract 15 from both sides}$$ $$x = 7~~~ \text{ Divide both sides by 3}$$

One key thing to note is that when you square a square root, you do not distribute the square inside. $(\sqrt{a+b})^2= a+b$. This is not (usually) the same as $a^2 + b^2$.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.