I have a (circular) segment of known height and known chord length. Is is possible to determine the radius of the circle?
Any help much appreciated.
Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this communityI have a (circular) segment of known height and known chord length. Is is possible to determine the radius of the circle?
Any help much appreciated.
We can apply the Intersecting Chords Theorem.
You chord length is the length $UV$ and the segment height is the length $PX$.
The intersecting chords theorem tells us that $XP \times XQ = XU \times XV$.
Let $\ell = UV$ and $h=XP$. It follows that $UX = XV = \tfrac{1}{2}\ell$. The ICT then tells us that
$$\tfrac{1}{2}\ell \times \tfrac{1}{2}\ell = h \times XQ \, ,$$ i.e. $XQ = \tfrac{1}{4h}\ell^2$. The diameter $PQ=PX+XQ$ and $$PX + XQ = h + \frac{\ell^2}{4h}=\frac{4h^2+\ell^2}{4h}$$
The radius is then one half of this, i.e.
$$CQ = \frac{4h^2+\ell^2}{8h} \, . $$
Here is the solution using trigonometry
Consider given the height $h=DE$ and the half length $a=DB$. The triangle ADB produces the following two equations
$$ a = r \sin \theta \\ r-h = r \cos \theta $$
where $r$ is the unknown radius, and $\theta$ is the included half angle (denoted on point A above)
If these two equations are squared and added together they make
$$ a^2 + (r-h)^2 = (r \sin\theta)^2 + (r \cos \theta)^2 = r^2 $$
The solution to this is $$ \boxed{ r = \dfrac{a^2+h^2}{2 h} } $$
This problem can be solved as follows. There are two knowns and two unknowns. The two knowns are the chord length $UV$ ($l$) and the chord height $XP$ ($h$). The two unknowns are the radius ($PC$ or $r$) and $XC$ which is part of the radius. Lets call this $q$. I used the drawing and symbols from the first answer to the problem.
We can write two distinct equations using the two knowns and two unknowns, so we can solve this problem:
(1) $h + q = r$
(2) Using the Pythagorean theorem, $(\frac{l}{2})^2 + q^2 = r^2$. To see this draw a line from $C$ to $V$ (this distance is $r$ of course). Since $PC$ bisects $UV$, the angle $CXV$ must be a right angle, so the Pythagorean theorem applies
By rearranging (1) as $q = r - h$, substitute $r - h$ for $q$ in equation (2)
Without going through all the math, you can solve equation (2) for $r$
The solution is: $$r = \dfrac{\left(\frac{l}{2}\right)^2 + h^2}{2h}$$
or
$$r = \dfrac{\frac{l^2}{4} + h^2}{2h}$$
Multiply numerator and denominator by $4$ and you get the same answer as previously submitted
Any two cords that intersect within the same circle will create two equal area rectangles if you multiply the two segments of the same cord together, the segments created by the intersection of the other second cord.
Given one cord and creating a second imaginary cord that intersects the given cord at the mid point and also intersects the circles center, we can find the diameter of the circle. The height of the circular segment becomes one of the segments of the second imaginary cord. We can solve the second segment by dividing the square of the given two segments by the height of the circular segment. The height of the circular segment is one of the segments of our imaginary created cord. If we add them both together they create the diameter length of the circle.
(1/2 cord)^2 / circular segment height, equals the diameter if you add the height of the circular segment to it. If you want the radius just divide the diameter by 2.
Sincerely,
William McCormick
I have been exploring the design of certain church doorways from the mid 1700's and this problem came up. I tried to think of how they might have solved this problem back then and came up with the following solution:
Draw a long vertical line. Measure and mark h from the top. Draw a horizontal line equal to l centered on that point. Take your compass with the sharp end moving down the vertical line and expand it until it scribes an arc that includes the top of the horizontal line and the end of the vertical lines. Measure that length and you get the radius.
Math is a powerful interpretive language to describe certain things, but it is not those things. It's interesting to speculate how the masons of those days solved these complex problems with little or no knowledge of the calculations that we would use today.
Let $h$ be the segment height, $2c$ the chord and $r$ radius. For Pythagoras: $$r^2=c^2+(r-h)^2\rightarrow r^2=c^2+r^2-2hr+h^2\rightarrow h^2-2rh+c^2=0\rightarrow$$ $$2rh=h^2+c^2\rightarrow r=\dfrac{1}{2h}(h^2+c^2)$$
Consider one half of the segment. Slant side length = $\sqrt{c^2+h^2}$.
Note similarity of this right triangle of smaller sides $(c,h)$ at left with main triangle diameter as hypotenuse $2r$
Ratio of corresponding sides should be same:
$$\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{c^2+h^2}}=\dfrac{\sqrt{c^2+h^2}}{2r} \rightarrow 2rh ={c^2+h^2} $$
Note that the result is true either if $h$ is the major segment height or the minor segment height.
I would suggest that you read a book on telescope mirror making. The telescope maker's approximate formula for the radius of curvature of a mirror surface is s = r^2/2R, where r is half the mirror diameter, s is the radius of curvature of the surface (half the focal length), and R is the saggita (depth of the curve). If the mirror is a paraboloid instead of a sphere, this formula is exact, but it is darn close for spherical mirrors.
This problem, with the same solution, comes up in amateur radio: how far can two UHF stations communicate at at sea where the earth is smooth, given the radius of the earth and the height of their antennas.
Or how far the mast of a ship must be to disappear from the horizon, given the height of the mast and the curvature of the earth. Don't ask why Columbus did not do such a measurement.
To fint the center of a circle connecting three points you don't have to calculate or measure anything. Using a compass draw a circle centered on one of the points with a radius a little more than half the distance to another one of the points. Then draw a second circle with the same radius centered on the second point. The circles should intersect in two points. With a straight edge draw a line through thos points long enough to reach beyond the center of the circle you're trying to construct. Repeat the process using one of the points used already with the unused point. The intersection of the two lines is the center of the circle you're seeking.