Find at least three numbers that satisfy all three conditions:

(1) there is a remainder of $1$ when the number is divided by $2$;

(2) there is a remainder of $2$ when the number is divided by $3$;

(3) there is a remainder of $3$ when the number is divided by $4$.

Since the LCM($2, 3, 4$) is $12$, all of them can divide $12$ without giving a remainder.

So, $12 - 1=11$ gives

a remainder of $1$ when divided by $2$,

a remainder of $2$ when divided by $3$,

a remainder of $3$ when divided by $4$.

Similarly $12*2-1=23$

and $12*3-1=35$

How would I explain to middle school students the "pulling out of a hat" of

first the $LCM-1$,

and secondly the $LCM*(n)-1$ parts?


(1) there is a remainder of 1 when the number is divided by 2;

(2) there is a remainder of 2 when the number is divided by 3;

(3) there is a remainder of 3 when the number is divided by 4.

Well, the first condition says that $n=2k+1$, the second one says that $n=3k'+1$ and the third one says that $n=4k''+3$. Note that all of them can be written as $n=mk-1$ for some k, where $m=2,3,4$. Now any number of the form $n=Lq-1$ where $L$ is a common multiple of $2,3,4$ will satisfy all the 3 conditions. Definitely, the least common multiple works, and since it's the least one all other common multiples of these numbers will be a multiple of it. So, any such number can be written as $n=12k-1$. This is how I would explain it to them.

  • 3
    $\begingroup$ I noticed that your user name is $\exists 1\nu4u$. $\endgroup$ – dfeuer Sep 3 '13 at 22:17
  • $\begingroup$ That's really cool. Thank you for pointing that out. I'll always use this one wherever they allow LaTeX from now on. $\endgroup$ – user66733 Sep 3 '13 at 22:20
  • 7
    $\begingroup$ Even better: $\sum 1\nu4u$ :P $\endgroup$ – dfeuer Sep 3 '13 at 22:29
  • $\begingroup$ I suppose that doesn't work for Irish M Powers.... although I can get close with $\text{Irish}^{M}s$ $\endgroup$ – Irish M Powers Sep 3 '13 at 22:34
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @skullpatrol: well, by division algorithm it's obvious that you can write them as $n=2k+1$, $n=3k'+2$ and $n=4k''+3$. Now, you can write $n=2k+1=2k+(+2-1)=2(k+1)-1$, $n=3k'+2=3k'+(+3-1)=3(k'+1)-1$, $n=4k''+3=4k''+(4-1)=4(k''+1)-1$ setting $k+1=q$ and so forth you can show that all of them are of the form $n=mK-1$ for $m=2,3,4$. $\endgroup$ – user66733 Sep 5 '13 at 13:14

Here’s the explanation that I’d probably use at that level.

Suppose that $n$ is a positive integer satisfying all three conditions. The first condition says that $n+1$ is even; the second says that $n+1$ is a multiple of $3$; and the third says that $n+1$ is a multiple of $4$. Any multiple of $4$ is automatically even, so the first condition is redundant, and we want to choose $n$ so that $n+1$ is a multiple of both $3$ and $4$. The least common multiple of $3$ and $4$ being $12$, this means that we want $n+1$ to be a multiple of $12$. If the concept of least common multiple hasn’t yet been introduced, you can just point out that since $12=3\cdot 4$, any multiple of $12$ is guaranteed to be a multiple of both $3$ and $4$. Either way, it’s now pretty clear that all numbers of the form $12n-1$ work, and it’s almost as easy to see that they’re the only ones that work.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Thanks for the interesting explanation in terms of $n+1$. $\endgroup$ – user 726941 Sep 5 '13 at 18:16
  • $\begingroup$ @skullpatrol: You’re welcome. $\endgroup$ – Brian M. Scott Sep 5 '13 at 18:22

The simple answer could just be write out the sets; i.e,




As noted in the other answer, immediately we see that $-1,11$, and $23$ satisfy the conditions. From there, we can note that perhaps every $12$th number also satisfies. Then note that $LCM(2,3,4)=12$. Finally construct your formula as $LCM\cdot{n}-1$.

I tried not to use any modular arithmetic since they are middle schoolers, so I hope this helps.

$\mathbf{EDIT}$ After thinking about it, the last thing i would do is verify that the number $12n-1$ leaves the appropriate remainders when divided by $2,3,$ and $4$. Convert $12n-1$ to $12n+11$ for arithmetic's sake and show $$\frac{12n+11}{2}=6n+5+\frac{1}{2}$$ $$\frac{12n+11}{3}=4n+3+\frac{2}{3}$$ $$\frac{12n+11}{4}=3n+2+\frac{3}{4}$$

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ The "laying out" of the sets is very helpful, thank you. $\endgroup$ – user 726941 Sep 5 '13 at 5:36
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ You're welcome. I felt like the tangibility of the sets themselves would sit easier with 8th graders. I don't know the curriculum of the middle schools but it's also a good introduction to the idea of a set as well. Glad I could help $\endgroup$ – Eleven-Eleven Sep 5 '13 at 19:17

First, I'd likely flip these numbers a bit as your remainders are going to be "-1" modulo 2,3, and 4 which is something to note here about how you could get the "-1" magically.

Secondly, note that condition 3 implies condition 1. If there are going to be an odd remainder if divided by 4 this implies there would be 1 when divided by 2 which could be shown by looking at odd versus even and then dividing up the odds to being either 1 over a multiple of 4 or 1 under a multiple of 4. In university you could use algebra to show this but at lower grades it may be more important to get the links here.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.