2
$\begingroup$

Suppose $\kappa$ is a regular uncountable cardinal in the ground model $M$, and let $\mathbb P\in M$ be a forcing notion that has the $\kappa$ chain condition in $M$. Further suppose that $S\subseteq \kappa$ is stationary (in $M$). I would like to show that $S$ remains stationary in $M[G]$.

Toward that end, suppose $C\in M[G]$ is club and fix $f:\kappa\to\kappa$ to be its (continuous) increasing enumeration. Also fix names $\dot C,\dot f\in M$ and a condition $p\in G$ such that $$p\Vdash \text{$\dot C$ is club in $\check \kappa$ and $\dot f$ is an increasing enumeration of $\dot C$}.$$ For $\alpha<\kappa$, let $S_\alpha = \{\beta<\kappa \mid \exists q\leq p, \,q\Vdash \dot f(\check \alpha)=\check \beta\}$. Informally, $S_\alpha$ is the set of "possible values" of $f(\alpha)$ in a generic extension. The $\kappa$-cc tells us that $|S_\alpha|<\kappa$ for all $\alpha$ (any two values in $S_\alpha$ have corresponding incompatible conditions that realize $f(\alpha)$ taking that value), and thus each $S_\alpha$ is bounded in $\kappa$ by regularity. It's also not too hard to show that the sequence of $\min(S_\alpha)$ is strictly increasing.

So now, working in $M$, let $\theta$ be sufficiently large that $H(\theta)$ has all of the information about $\mathbb P,\dot C,\kappa$ that it needs. Let $X\prec H(\theta)$ such that $|X|<\kappa$ and $\mathbb P,\dot C,\kappa,S\in X$. Through an elementary chain argument we can further require that $X\cap \kappa$ is transitive and thus some ordinal $\delta$, and moreover that $\delta\in S$ (this takes some work, but I understand how to do it).

To finish the proof, it would suffice to show that $p\Vdash \delta \in \dot C$. I have in my notes that $\delta$ is a closure point of the map $\alpha\mapsto \sup(S_\alpha)$, which I believe follows from elementarity, but I don't see how to finish off the proof from there (although seemingly I did understand it in the moment because I didn't write anything else). I want to say it has something to do with this implying that $\delta$ is a limit point of $C$, but I don't quite see how to achieve it. Could I get some help?

$\endgroup$
1
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ You are right, you want to show that if $G$ is $\mathbb P$-generic over $M$ then $\delta$ is a limit point of $\dot C^G$ and you are already almost there! So for every $\alpha\in X\cap\kappa$ you want to show that there is some $\alpha\leq\beta\in\dot C^G$ with $\beta\in X\cap\kappa$. Note that you can take $\beta=\dot f^G(\alpha)$... $\endgroup$
    – Andreas Lietz
    Mar 13 at 15:04

1 Answer 1

Reset to default
2
$\begingroup$

Since you know that $\delta$ is a closure point of $\alpha\mapsto \sup(S_\alpha)$, you may notice that $\delta$ is also a closure point of $f$. Indeed for all $\alpha<\delta$, since $f(\alpha)\in S_\alpha$, we have $f(\alpha)\le\sup(S_\alpha)<\delta$. So since $f$ is increasing continuous, $f(\delta)\le\delta$.

However $f$ is strictly increasing, so we must have $f(\delta)\ge\delta$, which means that $f(\delta)=\delta$.

Now for all $\alpha<\kappa$ we have $f(\alpha)\in C$, so this means $\delta=f(\delta)\in C$ in particular.

$\endgroup$

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .