2
$\begingroup$

The following problem is from Chapter 15 "Trigonometric Functions" from Spivak's Calculus

  1. Prove that

$$\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}=\arcsin{(\alpha \sqrt{1-\beta^2}+\beta\sqrt{1-\alpha^2})}$$

indicating any restrictions on $\alpha$ and $\beta$.

My question is about the restrictions on $\alpha$ and $\beta$. I will show the solution from the solution manual first, and then specify my question.

Here is the solution manual solution

From the addition formula for $\sin$ we obtain, for $|\alpha|\leq 1$ and $|\beta|\leq 1$,

$$\sin{(\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta})}=\sin{(\arcsin{\alpha})\cos{(\arcsin{\beta})}}+\cos{(\arcsin{\alpha})\sin{(\arcsin{\beta})}}$$

$$=\alpha\sqrt{1-\beta^2}+\beta\sqrt{1-\alpha^2}$$

Note that though it is not mentioned a significant step is taken in showing that

$$\cos{(\arcsin{x})}=\sqrt{1-x^2}$$

This is done by computing the derivative of $\sin(x)$ as the reciprocal of the derivative of $\arcsin$ at $\sin{x}$.

Consequently

$$\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}=\arcsin{(\alpha\sqrt{1-\beta^2}+\beta\sqrt{1-\alpha^2})}\tag{1}$$

provided that $-\pi/2\leq\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}\leq\pi/2$. [If $\pi/2<\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}\leq \pi$, the right side must be replaced with $\pi-\arcsin{(\alpha\sqrt{1-\beta^2}+\beta\sqrt{1-\alpha^2})}$, and if $-\pi\leq \arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}\leq -\pi/2$, replaced with $-\pi-\arcsin{(\alpha\sqrt{1-\beta^2}+\beta\sqrt{1-\alpha^2})}$.]

My question is about the last paragraph.

Let's start at the point where we have

$$\sin{(\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta})}=\alpha\sqrt{1-\beta^2}+\beta\sqrt{1-\alpha^2}$$

and we want to take the $\arcsin$ of each side to obtain $(1)$.

Now, $\arcsin{\alpha}$ and $\arcsin{\beta}$ are each in $(-\pi/2, \pi/2)$. Their sum is in $(-\pi, \pi)$, and the whole left expression is thus in $[-1,1]$.

$\pm 1$ occur when $\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}=\pm \frac{\pi}{2}$.

If one of these two cases occurs, then $\arcsin$ isn't defined for $\sin{(\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta})}=\pm 1$.

EDIT: the sentence above is is incorrect. I confused $\arcsin$ with its derivative $\arcsin'$.

So my first question is about the following snippet of the solution manual solution

provided that $-\pi/2\leq\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}\leq\pi/2$

where the values $\pi/2$ and $-\pi/2$ are included in the possibilities. Are these values really allowed?

EDIT: given the first edit above, yes, these values are allowed.

My second question is about the discussion when $\pi/2<\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}\leq \pi$ or $-\pi\leq \arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}\leq -\pi/2$. What is happening in these cases, I don't know what Spivak's solution manual did there.

$\endgroup$
4
  • $\begingroup$ "If one of these two cases occurs, then arcsin isn't defined for sin(arcsinα+arcsinβ)=±1." I am not getting how you commented this. $\endgroup$
    – user1078285
    Commented Jul 18, 2022 at 1:12
  • $\begingroup$ You know what, I think I have been staring at these functions for too long today, and I have confused the derivative of $\arcsin$ with $\arcsin$ itself. $\endgroup$
    – xoux
    Commented Jul 18, 2022 at 1:18
  • $\begingroup$ This silly mistake solves the first question, but the second question remains. $\endgroup$
    – xoux
    Commented Jul 18, 2022 at 1:21
  • $\begingroup$ For the second question, while taking arcsin on both sides of $\sin{(\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta})}=\alpha\sqrt{1-\beta^2}+\beta\sqrt{1-\alpha^2}$,we have to make cases as $\sin${($\arcsin${$\alpha$}=$\alpha$ only when $\pi/2 \leq$ $\alpha$ $\leq\ \pi/2$. $\endgroup$
    – user1078285
    Commented Jul 18, 2022 at 1:35

3 Answers 3

3
$\begingroup$

I'd start from the conditions first.

When it exists, the right-hand side is an angle in the interval $[-\pi/2,\pi/2]$, so the left-hand side must as well.

The existence condition is (with $a=\alpha,b=\beta$ for ease of typing) $$ \textstyle \lvert\, a\sqrt{1-b^2}+b\sqrt{1-a^2}\,\rvert\le 1\tag{*} $$ In particular, $|a|\le1$ and $|b|\le1$, but this was already known from examining the left-hand side.

Condition (*) is satisfied for $|a|\le 1$ and $|b|\le 1$ by using Cauchy-Schwarz with the vectors $$ \textstyle v=(a,\sqrt{1-a^2}\,)\qquad w=(\sqrt{1-b^2},b) $$ and the standard CS inequality $|v\cdot w|\le\|v\|\,\|w\|$ becomes $$ \textstyle \lvert\, a\sqrt{1-b^2}+b\sqrt{1-a^2}\,\rvert\le\sqrt{a^2+1-a^2}\sqrt{1-b^2+b^2}=1 $$

OK, this leaves only the condition that $$ -\frac{\pi}{2}\le \arcsin a+\arcsin b\le\frac{\pi}{2} \tag{**} $$ Under this condition, we can take the sine of both sides. From the left-hand side we get $$ \textstyle \sin(\arcsin a)\cos(\arcsin b)+\cos(\arcsin a)\sin(\arcsin b) =a\sqrt{1-b^2}+b\sqrt{1-a^2} $$ because, for $|x|\le 1$, we have $$ \textstyle\cos(\arcsin x)=\sqrt{1-\sin^2(\arcsin x)}=\sqrt{1-x^2} $$ because $-\pi/2\le\arcsin x\le\pi/2$ and so $\cos\arcsin x\ge0$.

Thus we conclude that, for $|a|\le1$ and $|b|\le 1$,

$\arcsin a+\arcsin b=\arcsin\bigl(a\sqrt{1-b^2}+b\sqrt{1-a^2}\,\bigr)$ if and only if $\lvert\arcsin a+\arcsin b\rvert\le \pi/2$

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

Let's start at the point where we have

$$\sin{(\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta})}=\alpha\sqrt{1-\beta^2}+\beta\sqrt{1-\alpha^2}\tag{1}$$

and we want to take the $\arcsin$ of each side to obtain $(1)$.

First, let's just note that $\alpha$ and $\beta$ are each in $[-1,1]$, and thus $\arcsin{\alpha}$ and $\arcsin{\beta}$ are each in $[-\pi/2,\pi/2]$. The sum $(\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta})$ is thus in $[-\pi,\pi]$.

We need to consider what happens for all such possible values of $(\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta})$.

Case 1: $-\pi/2\leq \arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}\leq\pi/2 $

The equation

$$\arcsin{(\sin{(\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta})})}=\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}\tag{2}$$

is true.

We can thus take the $\arcsin$ of both sides of $(1)$ and end up with

$$\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}=\arcsin{(\alpha\sqrt{1-\beta^2}+\beta\sqrt{1-\alpha^2})}$$

Case 2: $\pi/2\leq \arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}\leq\pi $

Equation $(2)$ is no longer true (indeed, it doesn't even make sense because of the domain of $\arcsin$).

However, it is true that $\sin{x}=\sin{\pi-x}$. Thus,

$$(\pi-\arcsin{\alpha}-\arcsin{\beta}) \in (-\pi/2,0]$$

and

$$\sin{(\pi-\arcsin{\alpha}-\arcsin{\beta})}=\sin{(\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta})}=\alpha\sqrt{1-\beta^2}+\beta\sqrt{1-\alpha^2}\tag{3}$$

Now it is true that

$$\arcsin{(\sin{(\pi-\arcsin{\alpha}-\arcsin{\beta})})}=\pi-\arcsin{\alpha}-\arcsin{\beta}$$

So we can take the $\arcsin$ of the first and last expressions in $(3)$ to obtain

$$\pi-\arcsin{\alpha}-\arcsin{\beta}=\arcsin{(\alpha\sqrt{1-\beta^2}+\beta\sqrt{1-\alpha^2})}$$

and the desired

$$\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}=\pi-\arcsin{(\alpha\sqrt{1-\beta^2}-\beta\sqrt{1-\alpha^2})}$$

Case 3: $-\pi\leq \arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}<-\pi/2$

This case is similar to case 2. Since

$$\sin{(-\pi-x)}=\sin{x}$$

we have that

$$(-\pi-\arcsin{\alpha}-\arcsin{\beta}) \in (-\pi/2,0]$$

$$\sin{(-\pi-\arcsin{\alpha}-\arcsin{\beta})}=\alpha\sqrt{1-\beta^2}+\beta\sqrt{1-\alpha^2}\tag{3}$$

and taking the $\arcsin$ of each side we obtain

$$-\pi-\arcsin{\alpha}-\arcsin{\beta}=\arcsin{(\alpha\sqrt{1-\beta^2}-\beta\sqrt{1-\alpha^2})}$$

$$\arcsin{\alpha}+\arcsin{\beta}=-\pi-\arcsin{(\alpha\sqrt{1-\beta^2}-\beta\sqrt{1-\alpha^2})}$$

$\blacksquare$

Spivak's solution manual sure does skip a lotta steps.

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

HINT

  • $\arcsin(\sin\alpha)=\alpha$ only when $\alpha\in[-\frac\pi2,\frac\pi2]$

  • $\arcsin(\sin\alpha)=\pi-\alpha$ when $\alpha\in[\frac\pi2,\pi]$

  • $\arcsin(\sin\alpha)=-\pi-\alpha$ when $\alpha\in[-\pi,-\frac\pi2]$

$\endgroup$

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .