0
$\begingroup$

To prove:the identity given above where $ a, b $ are vectors, $ B $ is the unit bivector in the $ a\wedge b $ plane and $\theta $ is the angle between $ a$ and $ b$. (From "Geometric Algebra for Physicists" by Doran and Lasenby).
Expanding the L.H.S i get $$ \frac{1+b.a}{|a+b|} - \frac{|a\wedge b|}{|a+b|}B $$ The R.H.S gives me by definition, $$ \cos(\theta/2) - \sin(\theta/2)B $$ Using grade projection, we should have $$ \frac{1+b.a}{|a+b|} = \cos(\theta/2) $$ and $$ \frac{|b\wedge a|}{|a+b|} = \sin(\theta/2) $$ But i can't think of an easy way to prove either. I am trying to prove it using geometry and the rules of GA, rather than trigonometry.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Please check theta=0 and a=b. can this be true for any a, b pair? $\endgroup$ – ahala Jul 15 '13 at 4:02
  • $\begingroup$ For theta = 0 the plane of rotation is not defined anyway $\endgroup$ – user997712 Jul 18 '13 at 7:35
0
$\begingroup$

Remember that a rotation can be performed through a composition of two reflections. Let $c$ be the vector in the $a \wedge b$ plane that has an angle $\theta/2$ with both $a$ and $b$. Then a rotation that would rotate $a$ to $b$ can be seen as

$$\underline R(s) = \hat c \hat a s \hat a \hat c$$

for any vector $s$. (Here, we're choosing trivially to reflect over $a$ and then reflect over the angle bisector.)

The question then becomes how we can compute the vector $c$ that bisects that angle. In fact, $c = \hat a + \hat b$ does this nicely (not well defined if $\hat b = - \hat a$, but then the plane is not well-defined anyway). Then $\hat c = (\hat a + \hat b)/|\hat a + \hat b|$ and we get the resulting rotor to be

$$R = \hat c \hat a = \frac{\hat a \hat a + \hat b \hat a}{|\hat a + \hat b|}$$

which takes the form you want. It is, however, not immediately clear to me how to generalize the problem to using non-unit vectors. This argument that $c$ is the right vector to reflect over doesn't work if you don't use unit vectors.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Upon a careful reading of the text, i think $ a $ and $ b $ are meant as unit vectors, although it is not explicitly stated in the question. Thanks for laying out the geometric picture. $\endgroup$ – user997712 Jul 18 '13 at 7:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.