I am reading about the Poincaré-Bendixson theorem in the plane, I really liked the theorem. I have seen common applications in Sotomayor and Perko's book. But I would like to know what other applications outside of the common literature (mentioned above) there are, I mean interesting applications that you create valuable. If possible, mention a reference to your example. Thank you very much


1 Answer 1


Let me chime in with a striking application in topology, originally due to Smale.

First, an exercise: let $I = [0, 1]$ be a closed interval and consider $\mathrm{Diff}_\partial(I)$, the group of self-diffeomorphisms of $I$ fixing the boundary $\partial I = \{0, 1\}$ pointwise. There is an obvious way to make this a topological group, where we demand two diffeomorphisms are nearby if they are nearby upto derivatives of all orders. Then $\mathrm{Diff}_{\partial}(I)$ is contractible.

Here is a harder follow-up: let $D^n$ denote the closed $n$-disk and this time let $\mathrm{Homeo}_\partial(D^n)$ be the topological group of self-homeomorphisms of $D^n$ fixing $\partial D^n$ pointwise, the topology being $C^0$-topology. Then $\mathrm{Homeo}_\partial(D^n)$ is also contractible. (Here is an idea that you can try to make precise: given a homeomorphism $f : D^n \to D^n$ fixing the boundary, we need to construct a canonical path to the identity homeomorphism, in the space $\mathrm{Homeo}_\partial(D^n)$; so find a homotopy of $f$ to identity where every level is a homeomorphism - also called an isotopy. One way to do it is to first make sure $f(0) = 0$ by an isotopy, and then consider $D^n$ as foliated by the concentric spheres around the origin. Applying $f$ will wildly move around the leaves of this foliation, but on the outermost leaf $\partial D^n$, it is identity, so in particular $f$ preserves this one leaf. Using this as a pivot, "comb" the messed-up foliation inward by a linear interpolation trick and make the "mess" disappear into the point $0$, so that at the end you're left with the same foliation as before.)

If you have successfully figured out the follow-up, you'll realize that the above, known as the Alexander trick, could never have worked if we started out with $\mathrm{Diff}_\partial(D^n)$, because any semblance of differentiability will be lost at the origin where all the wild stuff shrinks off. Nevertheless, we have:

Theorem (Smale): $\mathrm{Diff}_\partial(D^2)$ is contractible.

Here is a rough sketch of Smale's original proof. First, one can take $I^2$ instead of $D^2$ and focus only on diffeomorphisms which are identity on an unspecified collar neighborhood of the boundary; these are easily seen to be weak homotopy equivalent. So pick such an $f : I^2 \to I^2$, and just for convenience extend $f$ by identity to $f : \Bbb R^2 \to \Bbb R^2$. We must come up with a canonical isotopy between $f$ and identity, through diffeomorphisms supported on a slightly smaller square in $I^2$.

The main idea is to consider the vector field $X = f_*(\partial/\partial x)$, which is a nonzero vector field that agrees with $\partial/\partial x$ outside a slightly smaller square in $I^2$. Then $f$ can be recovered from $X$ as $f(x, y) = \Phi^x_X(0, y)$. It so happens, now, that any arbitrary nonzero vector field $X$ which agrees with $\partial/\partial x$ outside a slightly smaller square in $I^2$ will be of this form. To see this, the first step is to prove every flowline of $X$ emanating from a point of $0 \times I$ exits through a unique point on $1 \times I$ in finite time. If not, choose an offending flowline $\gamma$. Then by Poincare-Bendixson theorem the forward-time limit set of $\gamma$ is (1) a fixed point, (2) a bunch of disjoint homoclinic/heteroclinic flowlines going between fixed points, or (3) a periodic flowline. (1) and (2) are impossible as $X$ is nowhere vanishing; if (3) happens then the periodic flowline traps a Jordan domain in $\Bbb R^2$, and the flow of $X$ is a self-diffeomorphism of this topological disk, which must have a fixed point, again a contradiction. This proves the claim. Uniqueness of the point it hits $1 \times I$ at is obvious since $X = \partial/\partial x$ in a neighborhood of $1 \times I$.

Next, denote for any $(0, y) \in 0 \times I$ the hitting time $\tau_X(y)$ to be the time it takes for the flowline of $X$ starting at $(0, y)$ to reach $1 \times I$. Then $f(x, y) = \Phi^{\tau_X(y)}_X(0, y)$ is a diffeomorphism of $\Bbb R^2$, except it won't be identity outside a smaller square in $I^2$ as the flow of $X$ might scale in the $x$- and $y$-directions. This is easily fixable; essentially the reason is contractibility of $\mathrm{Diff}_\partial(I)$, where one takes $I$ to be one of the four edges of $I^2$.

This shows $\mathrm{Diff}_\partial(D^2)$ is homotopy equivalent to the space $\mathcal{S}$ of nowhere-zero vector fields on $I^2$ which agrees with $\partial/\partial x$ on a collar neighborhood of $\partial I^2$, which is the same as the subspace of the space of maps $\phi : I^2 \to \Bbb R^2 \setminus \{0\}$ such that $\phi \equiv (1, 0)$ on a collar neighborhood of $\partial I^2$. Map-lifting to the universal cover of $\Bbb R^2 \setminus \{0\}$ and doing an appropriately smoothened straightline-homotopy, we get that $\phi$ is canonically homotopic to the constant map to $(1, 0)$. This proves a contraction of $\mathcal{S}$ to the vector field $\partial/\partial x$, hence $\mathrm{Diff}_\partial(D^2) \simeq \mathcal{S}$ is contractible. $\blacksquare$

Smale conjectured, and Hatcher famously proved that $\mathrm{Diff}_\partial(D^3)$ is also contractible. In higher dimensions such things are in general false, because of existence of exotic spheres. Hatcher's "A 50-Year View of Diffeomorphism Groups" might be a good introduction to what is known. I learnt the above proof from Sanders Kuper's excellent book "Lectures on Diffeomorphism Groups Of Manifolds", where the remaining details of the sketch may be found.

  • $\begingroup$ Wow what a beautiful application, thank you very much for spending your time on such a detailed answer. I will leave the question open so that others are encouraged to write their most interesting application, meanwhile I will read the book you mentioned, thanks again $\endgroup$
    – Zaragosa
    Feb 22 at 14:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.