Here is the theorem I use:

Two solutions $\phi_1$, $\phi_2$ of $L(y)=y''+a_1y'+a_2y=0$, where $a_1$ and $a_2$ are constants, are linearly independent on an interval $I$ if, and only if, the Wronskain $W(\phi_1,\phi_2)\ne0$ for all $x\in I.$

Then, consider the functions: $$\phi_1(x)=x,\phi_2(x)=|x|, x\in(-\infty,\infty). $$Are they linearly dependent ot independent?

My answer is that they are linearly dependent since when $x\ge0$, $\phi_1(x)=x=\phi_2(x)$ and I plug them and the corresponding derivatives into the Wronskian, $W=0$ for all $x\ge0$; and also check when $x\lt0$, the Wronskian also equals to 0, thus $\phi_1$ and $\phi_2$ here are linear dependent. But the answer in the back of the book says they are linearly independent. Where went wrong?

A similar example is $$\phi_1(x)=x^2, \phi_2(x)=x|x|, x\in(-\infty,\infty).$$The answer is also linear independence, but I think they are linear dependence.

Thanks for your answer.

  • $\begingroup$ What differential equation do $\phi_1$ and $\phi_2$ solve? $\endgroup$ – Mercy King Jun 26 '13 at 13:53

Note: I wonder what DEQ this would be a solution for? Regardless, lets proceed.

We know that if $f(x)$ and $g(x)$ are linearly dependent on $I$ then $W(f,g)(x) = 0$ for all $x$ in the interval $I$.

Is this telling you anything about the linear dependence of the functions themselves? It does not imply that if $W(f,g)(x) = 0$ then $f(x)$ and $g(x)$ are linearly dependent. It is possible for two linearly independent functions to have a zero Wronskian!

We would analyze

$$ W(f,g) = \det\begin{bmatrix}f & g\\f' & g'\end{bmatrix} = fg' - gf'$$

  • $x < 0 \rightarrow |x| = -x \rightarrow \text{Wronskian} = 0$ since $fg' - gf' = x(-1) - (-x)(1) = 0$
  • $x = 0 \rightarrow |x| = 0 \rightarrow \text{Wronskian} = 0$ since $fg' - gf' = 0-0 = 0$
  • $x > 0 \rightarrow |x| = x \rightarrow \text{Wronskian} = 0$ since $fg' - gf' = x(1) - (x)(1) = 0$

Since the Wronskian is zero, no conclusion can be drawn about linear independence!

For linear independence, we want to go back to the basic definitions again. We have:

  • $|x| = x$ if $x \ge 0$ and $|x| = -x$ if $x \lt 0$. Thus, our equations to check for linear independence of these functions become:

$$c_1 x + c_2 x = 0~~~~ \text{for}~ x \ge 0 \\ c_1x - c_2 x = 0~~~~\text{for}~ x \lt 0$$

The only solution to this system is $c_1 = c_2 = 0 \rightarrow$ linear independence. Note that at the single point $x = 0$ does not matter.

You can also see the same argument for your second example Calculate the Wronskian of $f(t)=t|t|$ and $g(t)=t^2$ on the following intervals: $(0,+\infty)$, $(-\infty, 0)$ and $0$?

| cite | improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.