1
$\begingroup$

Let $x^2=y$, then $x=\pm\sqrt y$. But why can't it be $\pm x=\sqrt y$? I started thinking about this when i encounter this answer to a question but I didn't really understand it. In the answer, it says that there are two possible definitions for the notation $√$:

  1. For any positive real number $a$, $\sqrt a$ is defined as the square roots of $a$
  2. For any positive real number $a$, $\sqrt a$ is defined as the positive square root of $a$

By the first definition, $\sqrt {16}= \pm 4$. It also says that if I use the first definition,then I will encounter some problems in the future and that’s why we use the second definition. In the answer it says that solving for $x$ in $x^2 - \pi =0$ for $x>0$, by doing $x=\sqrt \pi$, would be incorrect. I still can’t understand why $x=\sqrt \pi$ would be incorrect if I use the first definition.

For me, $\pm x = \sqrt y$ and $x=\pm \sqrt y$ looks like they mean the exact same thing, but I suppose they don’t. Why is that?

$\endgroup$
8
  • $\begingroup$ I think the source of confusion here is not the definition of $\sqrt{\cdot}$, but what you mean by $\pm$. $$ x = \pm \sqrt{y} \Leftrightarrow x = \sqrt{y} \vee x = -\sqrt{y}$$ but $$ \sqrt{y} = \pm x \Leftrightarrow \sqrt{y} = x \vee \sqrt{y} = -x $$ So, the second expression only gives a valid alternative (depending on the sign of $x$) while the firs always gives two alternatives. $\endgroup$ Commented Nov 3, 2021 at 9:17
  • 5
    $\begingroup$ $(1)$ the square root is the non-negative solution by convention $(2)$ $\pm x=\sqrt{y}$ is the same as $x=\pm \sqrt{y}$ , but it is stange to have $\pm x$ on the left side if we want to have the value of $x$. $(3)$ If $x>0$ , then we only have one solution which is the square root without a sign. $\endgroup$
    – Peter
    Commented Nov 3, 2021 at 9:17
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ @Peter I think your (2) is the true answer here: It's correct but strange. Why not make an answer? $\endgroup$
    – Arthur
    Commented Nov 3, 2021 at 9:49
  • $\begingroup$ Why so much downvotes on the question (-3) ? It is in mathjax, OP explains thoroughly his source of confusion and ask for clarifications, this is fine for me. $\endgroup$
    – zwim
    Commented Nov 3, 2021 at 10:34
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @PierreCarre so from what I understand, $\pm x = \sqrt y$ is pretty much the same thing as $x = \pm \sqrt y$? $\endgroup$ Commented Nov 3, 2021 at 14:11

4 Answers 4

6
$\begingroup$

Neither is incorrect. $x =±\sqrt{y}$ is the same as $\sqrt{y}=±x$.

However, you'd usually want to have the variable on one side (usually left) and its solution(s) on the other side (usually right).

Thus, one would normally interpret $x=±\sqrt{y}$ as $x$ is the variable and $±\sqrt{y}$ are its solutions while $\sqrt{y} = ±x$ would be interpreted as $\sqrt{y}$ is the variable and its solution is $±x$. Both are of course, equivalent ways of saying the same thing.

$\endgroup$
2
  • $\begingroup$ so, it’s just a convention? saying $\pm x = \sqrt y$, for $x ≥ 0$, wouldn’t be wrong? $\endgroup$ Commented Nov 3, 2021 at 14:09
  • $\begingroup$ @Mohammadmuazzamali Why $x≥0$? Did you mean $y≥0$ instead? Because $x$ can be any real number and only $y$ needs to be non-negative (for $\sqrt{y}$ to be defined) in the equation $x^2 =y \Leftrightarrow x = ± \sqrt{y} \Leftrightarrow ±x = \sqrt{y}$. In that case, yes. It's a convention to want to have the unknown on one side and its solutions on the other. $\endgroup$
    – Ibrahim
    Commented Nov 3, 2021 at 23:57
2
$\begingroup$

Let $y\geq0$. If $\sqrt{y}$ is defined as the set of solutions to the equation $y=x^2$ and $x$ is one solution then I would say that $\sqrt{y}=\pm x$ is perfectly sensible notation (since $x$ and $-x$ are the only solutions). More commonly, however, $\sqrt{y}$ is defined as the unique non-negative solution to $y=x^2$. In this case, if $x^2=y$ then $x=\sqrt{y}$ or $x=-\sqrt{y}$. In my opinion one should avoid writing either of the expressions "$x=\pm\sqrt{y}$" and "$\sqrt{y}=\pm x$". My point: $x$ is some number, but what is $\pm\sqrt{y}$, and similarly, $\sqrt{y}$ is some number but what is $\pm x$?

$\endgroup$
-1
$\begingroup$

$\sqrt {x}$ is the "principal root." That means that $\sqrt x \ge 0.$ (Or, at least it is until you learn about complex numbers.)

$x^2 = 4$ is multivalued and has two solutions. That is $x = \pm \sqrt 4 = \pm 2$

When you write $\pm x = \sqrt y$ this requires that it be possible that $\sqrt y$ be negative, which it can't.

$x = \pm \sqrt y$ says $\sqrt y$ is always positive, but $x$ can be negative.

$\endgroup$
3
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ "When you write $±x = \sqrt{y}$ this requires that it be possible that $\sqrt{y}$ be negative, which it can't." I don't think so. Writing $\sqrt{y} = ±x$ means $\sqrt{y}$ is "$x$ or $-x$", not "$x$ and $-x$" so it doesn't require anything of the sort. $\endgroup$
    – Ibrahim
    Commented Nov 3, 2021 at 9:40
  • $\begingroup$ @Ibrahim When we say $x = \pm 2$ then that means that both $2,$ and $-2$ are acceptable values for $x.$ $\endgroup$
    – user317176
    Commented Nov 3, 2021 at 9:44
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ Not quite, the sign $±$ means "plus or minus" where or is inclusive. So $x=±2$ simply means $x=2$ or $x=-2$ or both. $\endgroup$
    – Ibrahim
    Commented Nov 3, 2021 at 9:52
-2
$\begingroup$

There has been a lot of nonsense posted here. The facts are these:

The notation

$$a=\pm b$$ is simply a universally accepted shorthand for $$a=b\text{ or }a=-b$$

The notation $$\pm a=b$$ has no universally recognised meaning, and should never be used.

$\endgroup$
2
  • $\begingroup$ Can $\pm a = b$ be understand as $a = b$ or $-a = b$? that also seems pretty reasonable. $\endgroup$ Commented Nov 4, 2021 at 7:05
  • $\begingroup$ @Mohammadmuazzamali: There is no need for it, and it is not normal, or expected. Also, if we allow $\pm a=b$, then we should also allow $c=\pm a=b$; but what would that mean? $c=b$, or $c=\pm b$? Better not to use it $-$ I can't see why you would want to. $\endgroup$
    – TonyK
    Commented Nov 4, 2021 at 11:17

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .