How would one approach proving the following statements:

(a) A plane can be covered with the interiors of finite number of hyperbolas

(b) A plane cannot be covered with the interiors of finite number of parabolas


  1. interior is the part of the plane that contains a focus (foci) of the aforementioned shapes.

  2. It is clear that without losing generality one can take $y=ax^2$ and $xy=a$ for all meaningful values of the parameter $a$ (e.g. $a\ne0$) and all possible rotations of these curves around the origin.


For (a), the origin-centered rotations of $xy=1$ by $0^\circ$, $45^\circ$, $90^\circ$, and $135^\circ$ leave a bounded octagonal hole that's easily covered.

For (b), consider a finite collection of parabolas, and choose a line $\ell$ parallel to none of their axes. (Since there are finitely-many axes, we can make such a choice.) The intersection of this $\ell$ with the interior any parabola, if not empty, is a finitely-long (possibly zero-length) segment. An infinitely-long line certainly contains a point not covered by a finite collection of those.


Presumably you are allowed to have the interiors overlap. For a, you need to find such a finite collection. Think about $xy=1$ shifted up and right by some large amount, say $10$ units plus a copy shifted down and to the left by $10$ units. The center gets covered nicely. We still haven't got the whole plane, but ...

For b, think about trying to cover a very large circle. To be specific, we will think about how much is covered by the interior of $y=x^2$. If you take the circle $x^2+y^2=R^2$, you only cover from roughly $(-R,R^2)$ to $(R,R^2)$ (I know these aren't on the circle, but they almost are for large $R$ ). This represents an angle of about $\frac 2R$ radians, which can be made arbitrarily small by taking $R$ large enough. It works even if the parabola doesn't go through the origin, you just need to work on $R$. So given a finite set of parabolas, take $R$ large enough that... There are a lot of holes to fill, but the idea is there.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.