Consider a triangle with side lengths 3, 4, and 5. By Heron's formula, its area is $\sqrt{6(6 - 5)(6-4)(6 - 3)} = \sqrt{6(1)(2)(3)} = \sqrt{36} = 6$. Are there any other triangles like this?

  • $\begingroup$ Why was this question closed? Although it was about finding Heronian triangles, it was about a specific subset of those triangles, with consecutive integer sides. This has considerably different implications from simply finding all triangles with integer sides and area. $\endgroup$ – Lee Sleek May 29 '13 at 22:45

Because of a liking for symmetry, we let the sides be $y-1$, $y$, and $y+1$. Using the Heron Formula, we find, exactly like you did, that $\frac{3}{16}y^2(y^2-4)$ should be a perfect square. Thus $y$ must be even, say $y=2s$. So we want $3(s^2-1)$ to be a perfect square, say $(3t)^2$. We arrive at the equation $$s^2-3t^2=1,$$ an instance of a Pell Equation.

In this case, the equation has the fundamental solution $s_1=2$, $t_1=1$. By general theory of the Pell equation, the positive solutions $(s,t)$ are given by $$s=\frac{(2+\sqrt{3})^n+(2-\sqrt{3})^n}{2},\qquad t=\frac{(2+\sqrt{3})^n-(2-\sqrt{3})^n}{2},$$ where $n$ ranges over the positive integers.

In our case we are primarily interested in $s$. Let $s_0=1$ and $s_1=2$. Define $s_n$ by the recurrence $$s_{n+2}=4s_{n+1}-s_n.$$ For suitable $t_n$, $(s_n,t_n)$ ranges over the positive solutions of the Pell equation. For example, $s_2=7$, giving $y=14$. This is your $x=13$. Continuing, we get $s_3=26$, and $s_4=97$. These give your computed values. There are infinitely many others.

Remark: The Pell equation is dealt with in most introductions to number theory. There is also a very nice book on the equation, by Ed Barbeau.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ For clarity, the actual formula that generates the solutions as $f(x) = (2 + \sqrt{3})^x + (2 - \sqrt{3})^x - 1$. $\endgroup$ – Lee Sleek May 29 '13 at 18:41
  • $\begingroup$ The first 10 values are $3, 13, 51, 193, 723, 2701, 10083, 37633, 140451, 524173$. $\endgroup$ – Lee Sleek May 29 '13 at 18:51
  • $\begingroup$ @LeeSleek: Yes, I only gave explicit formula for the $s_n$. We have $y_n=2s_n$, and therefore we get $x_n=\dots$. Note that we can replace $(2+\sqrt{3})^n +(2-\sqrt{3})^n$ by $\lceil (2+\sqrt{3})^n\rceil$ (here I am ussing the ceiling function). By the way, the recurrence is computationally more tractable, can use exact integer arithmetic instead of relying on approximations to square roots. $\endgroup$ – André Nicolas May 29 '13 at 18:53

The general formula for the area of a triangle whose side lengths are consecutive integers can be derived as follows: let x equal the length of the smallest side. The other two sides are then x + 1 and x + 2, and s (half the sum of the sides) is $\frac{3x + 3}{2}$. Subtracting each of the three sides from s and multiplying out gives

$$\sqrt{\frac{(3x + 3)(x + 3)(x - 1)(x + 1)}{16}} = \frac{\sqrt{3(x+3)(x-1)(x+1)^2}}{4}.$$

As we are adding and subtracting only odd numbers in this expression, only odd numbers can possibly give an even number (i.e. divisible by 4) under the radical, and therefore only odd x can yield an integer.

Continuing on this line of reasoning, $(x + 1)^2$ will always be a square no matter what x is. Additionally, since it will always be even (i.e. divisible by 2 at the very least), squaring it will always give a number divisible by 4 (eliminating any risk that we will get a perfect square in the numerator that is not divisible by 4) This means that the other three factors determine the nature of the triangle's area. Obviously, they must be a square for the radical to yield an integer. So we can conclude:

Given a triangle whose side lengths are consecutive integers, in which x is the length of the shortest side, the area will be an integer only if x is odd and $3(x+3)(x-1)$ is a perfect square.

Having tried nearly every odd number under 200, I have found only four such triangles, with side lengths 3 (area 6), 13 (area 84), 51 (area 1170), and 193 (area 16296). It would still be good to know if there is something else that can generate these numbers.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Good analysis. Continuation leads to the Pell equation $u^2-3v^2=1$, which has infinitely many solutions, that can be generated in a systematic way. One can produce a recurrence that generates all solutions, and even find an explicit "closed form" formula. The solutions grow quite rapidly. $\endgroup$ – André Nicolas May 29 '13 at 17:29
  • $\begingroup$ How to arrive at and/or do any of those things isn't obvious to me. $\endgroup$ – Lee Sleek May 29 '13 at 17:38
  • $\begingroup$ I will write a sketch. $\endgroup$ – André Nicolas May 29 '13 at 17:39
  • $\begingroup$ I notice the ratio of the solutions is very close: $\frac{13}{3} = 3.3333..., \frac{51}{13} = 3.923..., \frac{193}{51} = 3.784...$ Does this eventually converge at about 3.5? $\endgroup$ – Lee Sleek May 29 '13 at 17:52
  • $\begingroup$ @LeeSleek Yes, exactly - the exact value is $2+\sqrt3\approx 3.732$, for reasons similar to why the ratio of Fibonacci numbers settles at the golden ratio. See Andre's answer for the precise details. $\endgroup$ – Steven Stadnicki May 29 '13 at 18:02

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.