0
$\begingroup$

I came across the following question online (stats.libretexts.org).

De Anza statistics estimated that the amount of change daytime students carry is exponentially distributed with a mean of $0.88. Suppose that we randomly pick 25 daytime statistics students.

Find the probability that the average of the 25 students was between \$0.80 and $1.00. Graph the situation, and shade in the area to be determined.

My approach:

Since it is about the mean, we have to use the central limit theorem. Since E(x) = 0.88, and we have an exponential distribution, the standard deviation is 0.88 as well.

Hence, we get:

$$P\left(\frac{(0.8-0.88)}{0.88 / \sqrt(25)} ≤ Z ≤ \frac{(1-0.88)}{0.88 / \sqrt(25)}\right) = P(-0.4545 ≤ Z ≤ 0.68181) = 0.4276$$

Yet, the solution says the corresponding probability is 0.1882. Where is my mistake?

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

It is not a good idea to edit the post inserting another question. I was just to reply to your first question when you edited and posted the new one.

First problem

The result in your textbook is wrong. Anyway, I do not know why you calculated (correcty) an appoximation of the result, given that for an exponential distribution it is very easy to get the exact result:

$X_i\sim Exp(25/22)$

$Y=\sum_{i=1}^{25}X_i\sim Gamma(25;25/22)$

$\frac{25}{11}Y\sim \chi_{(50)}^2$

Thus $P(0.8<\overline{X}_{25}<1)=P(20<Y<25)=P\Big(\frac{25}{11}20<\chi_{(50)}^2<\frac{25}{11}25\Big)=0.656-0.236=0.420$

Second problem

they assumed normality.

In effect,

$P(X>12)=P\Bigg(Z>\frac{12-10.53}{2}\Bigg)=1-\Phi(0.735)\approx 0.231170$

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.