Q. If $a + bp^\frac{1}{3} + cp^\frac{2}{3} = 0$, prove that $a = b = c = 0$ ($a$, $b$, $c$ and $p$ are rational and $p$ is not a perfect cube.)

My approach:

Solving the quadratic, I get:

$p^\frac{1}{3} = \dfrac{-b ± \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2c}$

Case 1: If the $b^2 - 4ac$ is a perfect square, I get the LHS as irrational and the RHS as rational, which is a contradiction.

Case 2: If $b^2 - 4ac$ is not a perfect square, $b = \pm \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac} - 2cp^\frac{1}{3}$

Here, the LHS is rational and the RHS is irrational, contradiction again. (Edit: The answer of @GNUSupporter has the proper proof.)

So the equation is not quadratic and $c = 0$.

$a + bp^\frac{1}{3} = 0$

$-\dfrac{a}{b} = p^\frac{1}{3}$

This is a contradiction and hence $b = 0$ and $a = 0$

Is there any other way to solve this?

  • 6
    $\begingroup$ You mean $p^{1/3} = \cdots.$ $\endgroup$
    – mjw
    Dec 21 '20 at 15:46
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Why is $b = ± \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac} - 2cp^⅔$ a contradiction? $\endgroup$
    – Arthur
    Dec 21 '20 at 15:48
  • 4
    $\begingroup$ There is, a priori, no immediate reason to conclude that the RHS is irrational. It is a difference between irrational numbers, the result could be rational. $\endgroup$
    – Arthur
    Dec 21 '20 at 15:50
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ $\sqrt 2-\sqrt 2$, for one. Any constructed example is going to look similarly trivial, unless I go out of my way to obfuscate it (like with $\sqrt{3+2\sqrt2}-\sqrt2=1$). But they prove that it can be done. $\endgroup$
    – Arthur
    Dec 21 '20 at 15:57
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ But can you find $x^{1/2} - y^{1/3} = 0$ (where x and y are not perfect squares and cubes respectively)? $\endgroup$
    – Shub
    Dec 21 '20 at 16:05

I have somewhat weird way to see this. Consider the system \begin{align*} a + b p^{1/3} + c p^{2/3} & = 0\\ cp + a p^{1/3} + b p^{2/3} & = 0\\ bp + cp p^{1/3} + a p^{2/3} & = 0 \end{align*} or $$\begin{pmatrix} a & b & c \\ cp & a & b \\ bp & cp & a \end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} 1 \\ p^{1/3} \\ p^{2/3} \end{pmatrix} =0. $$

So the coefficient matrix has zero determinant, i.e. $$a^3 + b(b^2-3ac)p + c^3 p^2=0.$$ Now we can proceed with infinite descent.

(The essence is until here, and below is just some calculations.)

Note that we can assume that $p$ is an integer; If $a + b (n/d)^{1/3} + c (n/d)^{2/3}=0$ then $$ad^2 + bd\cdot d^{2/3} n^{1/3} + c d^{4/3}n^{2/3}=0,$$ i.e. $$ad^2 + bd\cdot (d^2n)^{1/3} + c (d^2n)^{2/3}=0$$ so we are reduced to the integer $p$ case.

Let $q$ be a prime factor or $p$. One can assume that $q^3 \not\mid p$; in this case $q$ factor is absorbed into coefficients $b$ and $c$. Assume $(a, b, c)$ is a nontrivial integer solution. We have two cases;

  • Case 1: Let $p = qN$ with $q\not\mid N$. Then $$a^3 + b(b^2-3ac)qN + c^3 q^2N^2=0,$$ i.e. $a = qA$. Then $$q^2A^3 + b(b^2-3qAc)N + c^3 qN^2=0,$$ i.e. $b = qB$. Then again $$qA^3 + B(q B^2-3Ac)qN + c^3 N^2=0,$$ i.e. $q|c$, i.e. $c = qC$, and $$A^3 + B(B^2-3AC)qN + C^3 q^2 N^2 = A^3 + B(B^2-3AC)p + C^3 p^2 =0.$$ Thus, if $(a, b, c)$ is an integer solution then $(a/q, b/q, c/q)$ also is an integer solution; this descent cannot be done infinitely since $a, b, c$ are finite, i.e. a contradiction.

  • Case 2 : Let $p = q^2 N $ with $q\not\mid N$. Then $$a^3 + b(b^2-3ac)q^2 N + c^3 q^4 N^2=0.$$ One can assert $a = q A$, then $$q A^3 + b(b^2-3qAc) N + q^2c^3 N^2=0,\quad \mathbf{(**)}$$ i.e. $b = qB$. Thus $$ A^3 + B(q B^2-3Ac)q N + q c^3 N^2=0,$$ i.e. $A$ can be divided by $q$ once again. Let $A = qA'$ to have $$ q^2 A'^3 + B( B^2-3A'c)q N + c^3 N^2=0,$$ i.e. $c = qC$, $$ q A'^3 + B( B^2-3qA'C) N + q^2 C^3 N^2=0 \quad \mathbf{(**)}$$ Compare two equations marked by (**); If $(A, b, c)$ satisfies $$q A^3 + b(b^2-3qAc) N + q^2c^3 N^2=0 $$ then we have another integer solution $(A/q, b/q, c/q)$. So, again by infinite descent, there is no such $(a, b, c)$.

This method also works for $p^{1/4}$ case.

I think I have never seen the matrix of the form $$\begin{pmatrix} a & b & c \\ cp & a & b \\ bp & cp & a \end{pmatrix} $$ or its variants. Are there any reference?

  • $\begingroup$ I have never seen it either, +1 for the nice method! $\endgroup$ Dec 22 '20 at 3:13
  • $\begingroup$ Consider $p^{1/3} = \alpha$ and $K = \mathbb{Q}(\alpha)$ a field extension, which is a vector space over $\mathbb{Q}$ generated by $1, \alpha, \alpha^2$. Then any $t = a + b \alpha + c \alpha^2$ generates a map $m_t \colon K \to K$; $m_t(x) = tx$. This map is linear as a vector space map, and the matrix above is essentially $m_{a + b \alpha + c \alpha^2}$ with appropriate basis choice for $K$. $\endgroup$
    – dust05
    Aug 29 '21 at 15:13
  • $\begingroup$ What i have done last year is just finding contradiction under assumption of $N_{K/\mathbb{Q}}=0$; This is somewhat clear since any $\sigma \colon K\hookrightarrow \mathbb{C}$ doesn't map $x\ne0$ into $0$; but the procedure assumes that the minimal polynomial of $\alpha$ is cubic polynomial, so concrete calculation above is somewhat needed. $\endgroup$
    – dust05
    Aug 29 '21 at 15:14
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks for your explanation. It is some kind of a miracle that I understood everything you've said now, because I would not have understood it had you responded on Dec 22,2020! Yes, it's a great idea all round, something that I saw and used in other examples as well. $\endgroup$ Aug 29 '21 at 16:23

There's a typo in the first step. @mjw caught it. Note that you're applying the quadratic formula on $p^{1/3}$, so $$p^{1/3} = \dfrac{-b ± \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2c}, \text{ if }c \ne 0.$$ Another missing link in your proof is your lack of argument about the claimed irrationality of $± \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac} - 2cp^{2/3}$.

As you handled the degenerate case "$c = 0$ and $b \ne 0$" well, we'll keep the assumption "$c \ne 0$ or $b = 0$" for the rest of the proof. Also we assume that $\sqrt{b^2-4ac}$ is irrational. Multiply $2c$ on both side of the above equality, then cube it.

\begin{align} 8c^3p =& -b^3 \pm 3b^2 \sqrt{b^2-4ac} - 3b(b^2-4ac) \pm (b^2-4ac)^{3/2} \\ =& -4b^3+12abc \pm 4(b^2-ac) \sqrt{b^2-4ac} \\ 2c^3p =& -b^3 + 3abc \pm (b^2-ac) \sqrt{b^2-4ac} \end{align}

Make $\sqrt{b^2-4ac}$ the subject of the above equality. If $b^2-ac \ne 0$,

$$\sqrt{b^2-4ac} = \pm \frac{2c^3p + b^3 - 3abc}{b^2-ac} \in \mathbb{Q},$$ contradicting our assumption on the irrationality of $\sqrt{b^2-4ac}$ if $b^2 - ac \ne 0$.

Assume that $b^2 - ac = 0$. Then $b^2 - 4ac = b^2 = -3b^2$, and $$p^{1/3} = \frac{(-b\pm\sqrt3|b|i)}{2c} = \begin{cases} \frac{b}{c} e^{2\pi i/3} \text{ or } \frac{b}{c} e^{4\pi i/3} \text{ if } b > 0 \\ \frac{b}{c} e^{\pi i/3} \text{ or } \frac{b}{c} e^{5\pi i/3} \text{ if } b < 0 \end{cases}.$$

In this case, if $b \ne 0$, we don't have the desired conclusion, since $p = \left(\dfrac{b}{c}\right)^3$ might not be an integer, so it's not a perfect cube.

If $b = 0$, we use the assumption $b^2 = ac$, we've $a = 0$ or $c = 0$.

  • If $a = 0$, only the term $cp^{2/3} = 0$ is left in the original equation, but $p \ne 0$ as $p$ can't be a perfect cube, so $c = 0$.
  • If $c = 0$, the original equation becomes $a = 0$. Done.
  • $\begingroup$ Thank you for proving the irrationality of $± \sqrt{b² - 4ac} - 2cp^{2/3}$ :) $\endgroup$
    – Shub
    Dec 22 '20 at 3:51
  • $\begingroup$ @Shub Thx for comment. Oops using Wolfram Alpha to verify an instance of the last case $4p^{2/3}-2p^{1/3}+1=0$, I found that $p^{1/3} = \frac12 e^{\pi i/3}$ or its conjugate, which gives $p = \frac18$. $\endgroup$ Dec 22 '20 at 8:30
  • $\begingroup$ If $b^2 - ac = 0$ then $$b^2 - 4ac<0$$ $$p^\frac{1}{3} \in \mathbb{C}$$ $$a + bp^\frac{1}{3} + cp^\frac{2}{3} \in \mathbb{C}$$, which is not possible. $\endgroup$
    – Shub
    Dec 22 '20 at 8:57
  • $\begingroup$ @Shub My previous numerical example with $a = 1$, $b = -2$, $c = 4$ and $p^{1/3} = \frac12 e^{\pi i/3}$ shows that $a+bp^{1/3}+cp^{2/3} \in \mathbb{R} \subseteq \mathbb{C}$. Note that the set of real numbers is included in that of complex numbers, so that's possible. $\endgroup$ Dec 22 '20 at 9:05

Let $K= \mathbb{Q}(p^{\frac{1}{3}}) \cong \mathbb{Q}[x]/(x^3-p).$ We have the following:

  1. $\text{Tr}_{K/\mathbb{Q}} (p^{\frac{1}{3}}) = 0 $, as the minimal polynomial of $p^{\frac{1}{3}}$ is $x^3-p.$
  2. $\text{Tr}_{K/\mathbb{Q}} (p^{\frac{2}{3}}) = 0 $, as the minimal polynomial of $p^{\frac{2}{3}}$ is $x^3-p^2.$
  3. $\text{Tr}_{K/\mathbb{Q}} (a) = 3a$, for all $a \in \mathbb{Q}.$

Now applying the trace to your equation we get \begin{align*} \text{Tr}_{K/\mathbb{Q}}(a + bp^\frac{1}{3} + cp^\frac{2}{3}) &= \text{Tr}_{K/\mathbb{Q}}(a)+ b \text{Tr}_{K/\mathbb{Q}}(p^\frac{1}{3} ) + c \text{Tr}_{K/\mathbb{Q}}(p^\frac{2}{3})\\ &= \text{Tr}_{K/\mathbb{Q}}(a)+0+0 = 3a = 0= \text{Tr}_{K/\mathbb{Q}}(0),\\ \end{align*} thus $a=0.$ Next multiply your equation by $p^{\frac{1}{3}}$, apply the trace, and conclude that $c=0.$ Repeat.

Edit: As Paramanand Singh correctly points out the problem reduces to showing that $f(x)= x^3-p$ is the minimal polynomial of $p^{\frac{1}{3}},$ which I assumed. However, this follows directly from Eisenstein's Criterion and the fact that $f(p^{\frac{1}{3}})=0.$ In light of this information, the polynomial given by the OP is of degree $2$, thus must be the zero polynomial.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Your first point that $x^3-p$ is the minimal polynomial for $p^{1/3}$ is what we need to prove here. It can't be assumed. More generally the problem boils down to showing that if $x^3-p\in\mathbb {Q} [x] $ has no roots in $\mathbb {Q} $ then it is irreducible over $\mathbb{Q} $. $\endgroup$
    – Paramanand Singh
    Dec 27 '20 at 3:01
  • $\begingroup$ @ParamanandSingh You're right! I was so eager to use traces so I jumped. Thank you for your comment $\endgroup$ Dec 27 '20 at 8:25

Here's another way. If $a+bq+cq^2=0$, then $a=-(bq+cq^2)$, hence $a^2=b^2q^2+2bcq^3+c^2q^4$. So if $q^3=p$, then we have two equations:

$$\begin{align} a+bq+cq^2&=0\\ (a^2-2bcp)-c^2pq-b^2q^2&=0 \end{align}$$

Multiplying both sides of the first equation by $b^2$ and the both side of the second equation by $cp$, and then adding the resulting equations, we have


Now if $q$ is irrational (i.e., if $p$ is not a perfect cube) and the other variables are rational, then we must have $ab^2+a^2c-2bc^2p=b^3-c^3p=0$. But $b^3-c^3p=0$ for a non-cube $p$ implies $b=c=0$, in which case the original equation, $a+bq+cq^2=0$, implies $a=0$.


Since $q=p^{1/3}$ is irrational it follows that minimal polynomial of $q$ over $\mathbb{Q} $ is of degree greater than $1$. If we have $a+bq+cq^2=0$ for some rational $a, b, c$ with $c\neq 0$ then $f(x) =(a/c)+(b/c)x+ x^2\in\mathbb{Q}[x]$ is the minimal polynomial of $q$.

And therefore it must divide the polynomial $g(x) =x^3-p\in\mathbb{Q} [x] $ (which has $q$ as a root) leading to a linear factor of this polynomial $g(x)$. But $g(x) $ has no rational root so we get a contradiction.

We must have thus $c=0$ and then it is easy to conclude $a=b=0$ just from irrationality of $q$.

The fact that we are dealing with cube roots and polynomials of degree $3$ makes the algebra a lot simpler. If a polynomial of degree $3$ is reducible it must have a linear factor and hence a rational root. And thus if a third degree polynomial with rational coefficients has no rational roots then it is irreducible.

The same can't be said of a general polynomial of degree greater than $3$. But for polynomials of the form $x^n-p$ the same result holds.

Let $n$ be a positive prime and $p$ be a positive rational number which is not an $n$-th power then $x^n-p$ is irreducible over $\mathbb{Q} $.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.