# Why doesn't trig substitution work for definite integrals?

In the following example, I am attempting to find the area of a semicircle using calculus, which is obviously $$\frac{\pi{r}^2}{2}$$. Effectively, I am trying to find $$\int_{-r}^r\sqrt{r^2-x^2}dx$$ Here goes: Let $$x=r\sin\theta$$: $$\frac{dx}{d\theta}=r\cos\theta\implies dx=r\cos\theta d\theta$$ When: $$x=r, ~~~~\text{Then}~~~~\sin\theta=1\implies\theta=\frac{\pi}{2}$$ $$x=-r, ~~~~\text{Then}~~~~\sin\theta=-1\implies\theta=-\frac{\pi}{2}$$ $$\therefore\int_{-r}^r\sqrt{r^2-x^2}dx=\int_{-\frac{\pi}{2}}^{\frac{\pi}{2}}r\cos\theta\sqrt{r^2-r^2\sin^2\theta} ~~d\theta$$ $$=\int_{-\frac{\pi}{2}}^{\frac{\pi}{2}}r^2\cos^2\theta~~d\theta=\frac{r^2}{2}\int_{-\frac{\pi}{2}}^{\frac{\pi}{2}}(1+\cos2\theta)~~d\theta=\frac{r^2}{2}\left[\theta+0.5\sin2\theta\right]_{-\frac{\pi}{2}}^{\frac{\pi}{2}}=\frac{r^2}{2}((\frac{\pi}{2}+0)-(-\frac{\pi}{2}-0))=\frac{\pi r^2}{2}$$ as required.

BUT Back to the stage when I was working out the limits of the new integral with respect to $$\theta$$. Let's say I wrote something like this:

When: $$x=r, ~~~~\text{Then}~~~~\sin\theta=1\implies\theta=\frac{5\pi}{2}$$ $$x=-r, ~~~~\text{Then}~~~~\sin\theta=-1\implies\theta=-\frac{5\pi}{2}$$ Then , I would get an eventual answer of $$\frac{5\pi r^2}{2}$$ Where have I gone wrong? It seems to me that my logic is faultless, but the definite integral is simply ambiguous when using trig substitutions. This would apply to any integral involving trig substitutions; in short, can't all definite integrals computed using trig substitutions generate an incorrect answer?

If so, isn't the maths of definite integrals faulty? Thanks for your help.

The part of the statement of the Fundamental theorem of calculus on which the proof of the substitution theorem relies has no requirement that the change of variable be a bijection. This is a common error. (I made it myself until I first taught Calculus.) (I'll return to this point at the end of answering your Question because this Question gives the appearance that bijectivity is required.)

Another common error is to believe that, during trigonometric substitution of a definite integral, one "pushes" the bounds of integration from the old integral to the new integral along the change of variable. This is true when one uses the substitution theorem in the forward direction and false when used in reverse, as it is in trigonometric substitution. One must "pull" the bounds along the inverse function of the substitution (with whatever domain restriction it has) to the new bounds. In your case, $$x = r \sin \theta$$ gives the inverse $$\theta = \arcsin(x/r)$$. So you have no choice but to find the $$\theta$$s \begin{align*} \theta_{\text{lower}} &= \arcsin(-1) = -\pi/2 \\ \theta_{\text{upper}} &= \arcsin(1) = \pi/2 \text{.} \end{align*} You could use a different restriction of the domain of sine for your arcsine, but to apply the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus, this choice of inverse function must be continuous (hence defined) on the interval of integration. There is no such restriction giving an arcsine that contains the interval $$[-5\pi/2, 5\pi/2]$$. This is where bijectivity enters the picture -- to ensure the inverse function exists over the entire interval of integration. (And it only enters the picture when applying the theorem in reverse.)

We need to fix the exceedingly common algebra error in your derivation. In particular, $$\sqrt{a^2} = |a|$$ for any $$a$$. Let's take that square root correctly. \begin{align*} I &= \int_{-r}^r \; \sqrt{r^2 - x^2} \,\mathrm{d}x & & \hspace{-1in}\begin{bmatrix} x = r \sin \theta \\ \mathrm{d}x = r \cos \theta \,\mathrm{d}\theta \\ \theta = \sin^{-1}(x/r) \end{bmatrix} \\ &= \int_{\sin^{-1}(-r/r)}^{\sin^{-1}(r/r)} \; \sqrt{r^2 - (r \sin \theta)^2}\, r \cos \theta \,\mathrm{d}\theta \\ &= \int_{-\pi/2}^{\pi/2} \; \sqrt{r^2(1 - \sin^2 \theta)}\, r \cos \theta \,\mathrm{d}\theta \\ &= \int_{-\pi/2}^{\pi/2} \; \sqrt{r^2 \cos^2 \theta}\, r \cos \theta \,\mathrm{d}\theta \\ &= \int_{-\pi/2}^{\pi/2} \; |r \cos \theta| r \cos \theta \,\mathrm{d}\theta \\ &= \int_{-\pi/2}^{\pi/2} \; |r| |\cos \theta| r \cos \theta \,\mathrm{d}\theta \\ &= \int_{-\pi/2}^{\pi/2} \; |\cos \theta| r^2 \cos \theta \,\mathrm{d}\theta & & \hspace{-1in}[ r \geq 0 ] \\ \end{align*} Recall that cosine is nonnegative on our interval of integration, quadrants I and IV and the quadrantal angle $$0$$. \begin{align*} I &= r^2 \int_{-\pi/2}^{\pi/2} \; \cos^2 \theta \,\mathrm{d}\theta \\ &= r^2 \left.\left( \frac{\theta}{2} + \frac{\sin(2\theta)}{4} \right) \right|_{\theta = -\pi/2}^{\pi/2} \\ &= r^2 \left( \left( \frac{\pi}{4} + \frac{\sin(\pi)}{4} \right) - \left( \frac{-\pi}{4} + \frac{\sin(-\pi)}{4} \right) \right) \\ &= r^2 \left( \frac{\pi}{4} + \frac{\pi}{4} \right) \\ &= \frac{1}{2} \pi r^2 \text{.} \end{align*}

An actual statement of the substitution theorem (footnote) is this:

Let $$\varphi:[a,b] \rightarrow I$$ be a differentiable function with a continuous derivative, where $$I \subseteq \Bbb{R}$$ is an interval. Suppose that $$f:I \rightarrow \Bbb{R}$$ is a continuous function. Then, if $$u = \varphi(x)$$ $$\int_a^b \; f \left( \varphi(x) \right) \varphi'(x) \,\mathrm{d}x = \int_{\varphi(a)}^{\varphi(b)} \; f(u) \,\mathrm{d}u \text{.}$$

That English Wikipedia article also explains why trigonometric substitution is a little different from normal substitution.

The formula is used to transform one integral into another integral that is easier to compute. Thus, the formula can be read from left to right or from right to left in order to simplify a given integral. When used in the former manner, it is sometimes known as $$u$$-substitution or $$w$$-substitution in which a new variable is defined to be a function of the original variable found inside the composite function multiplied by the derivative of the inner function. The latter manner is commonly used in trigonometric substitution, replacing the original variable with a trigonometric function of a new variable and the original differential with the differential of the trigonometric function.

Let me give two examples to really clarify what is meant by right-to-left and left-to-right. First, left-to-right: $$J = \int_{-2}^{1} \frac{2 x \, \mathrm{d}x}{\sqrt{x^2 + 1}} \text{.}$$ Here, we choose $$u$$ to stand for some combination of the dummy variable, making parts of the integrand simpler and we hope that the resulting differential will consume part of the integrand, leaving something simpler. So we set $$u = x^2 + 1$$. That is, $$\varphi(x) = x^2 + 1$$. This is not a bijection. $$\varphi(1) = \varphi(-1)$$. Then, $$\mathrm{d}u = 2 x \,\mathrm{d}x$$. That is, $$\varphi'(x) = 2x$$. We are matching to the left side of the substitution equation. So we apply the theorem and obtain the version on the right-hand side of the equation: $$J = \int_{\varphi(-2) = 5}^{\varphi(1) = 2} \frac{\mathrm{d}u}{\sqrt{u}} \text{,}$$ which is easy to finish. Now, right-to-left: $$K = \int_{-r}^r \; \sqrt{r^2 - x^2} \,\mathrm{d}x \text{.}$$ Here, we set $$x = r \sin \theta$$, making no attempt to capture some combination of the dummy variable and making no attempt to capture a piece of the integrand by means of the differential. We start with the simpler looking integral on the right of the equation in the theorem and replace it with the elaborated integral on the left. This is why the inverse function has to work on the entire interval, because we have to be able to carry the endpoints of integration along the inverse function, to the endpoints of the interval $$I$$ (notation from the theorem).

When using the theorem right-to-left, one applies $$\varphi^{-1}$$ to the endpoints. In your Question, there is no choice of $$\varphi^{-1}$$ that gives an interval $$I$$ with the endpoints $$-5\pi/2$$ and $$5\pi/2$$. The maximal interval for any inverse of sine has width $$\pi$$.

(footnote) One might be (justifiably) concerned that the statement of the theorem at the English Wikipedia is incomplete.

Rogowski et al. "Calculus: Early Transcendentals, 4th ed.", p. 340:

Theorem 1: The Substitution Method: If $$F'(x) = f(x)$$, and $$u$$ is a differentiable function whose range includes the domain of $$f$$, $$\int f(u(x))u'(x)\,\mathrm{d}x = F(u(x)) + C \text{.}$$

(Since $$F$$ is an antiderivative of $$f$$, the object on the right is $$\int f(u) \,\mathrm{d}u$$.)

No bijectivity requirement here. You will also not find a bijectivity requirement in other careful statements of the theorem because there is no explicit or implicit bijectivity requirement in the forward direction. Bijectivity is only relevant in the reverse direction and is expressed implicitly by means of the interval $$I$$, in the English Wikipedia quote, and in Rogowski by writing $$F(u(x))$$, which requires the domain of $$F$$ to include the range of $$u$$, which is given to include the domain of $$f$$. (Recall that in a definite integral, we may replace "$$f$$" with a function that is undefined outside the interval of integration.)

• +1. I think the bijection myth stems from examples where the real complication is what happens at asymptotes.
– J.G.
Sep 27, 2020 at 16:36
• I think the sign of the second term is wrong in $r^2 \left.\left( \frac{\theta}{2} + \frac{\sin(2\theta)}{4} \right) \right|_{\theta = -\pi/2}^{\pi/2}$. It results from applying the half-angle formula $\cos^2 \theta = 1/2 \, (1 + \cos 2\theta)$ and taking antiderivatives. The antiderivative of $\cos 2\theta$ is $-1/2 (\sin 2\theta)$, which should yield a negative term. Since this term evaluates to zero when bounds are taken into account, the error does not affect the result. Mar 12 at 12:07
• @PapaSmurf : Checking three references, I find the version I wrote. See line 4 at ref 1, line 2 at ref 2, and formula 2 at ref 3. Jul 18 at 21:57
• @EricTowers: Indeed, I was wrong. The antiderivative of $\cos 2\theta$ is $+1/2\,(\sin 2\theta)$. yesterday

Ideally, as others have pointed out, you will set up the bounds of your trigonometric substitution so that each value of $$x$$ you need is produced once and only once, in a continuous stream. For $$-\frac\pi2 \leq \theta \leq \frac\pi2,$$ if $$x = r\sin\theta$$ then $$x$$ increases monotonically from $$-r$$ to $$r$$ as $$\theta$$ increases monotonically from $$-\frac\pi2$$ to $$\frac\pi2.$$ This makes a very "clean" substitution.

(Note: throughout this answer I am assuming $$r > 0.$$ In the case where $$r<0$$ then $$\int_{-r}^r\sqrt{r^2-x^2}dx$$ is negative and is not the answer to the initial problem, "What is the area of a semicircle?")

When you increase $$\theta$$ from $$-\frac{5\pi}2$$ to $$\frac{5\pi}2,$$ the value of $$x$$ starts at $$-r,$$ increases to $$r,$$ then decreases back to $$-r$$, then increases to $$r$$ again, decreases to $$-r$$ again, and finally increases to $$r.$$ That's a lot of increasing and decreasing just to cover the distance from $$-r$$ to $$r.$$

But the up-and-down-and-up movement of $$x$$ is not really the problem. What is the problem is that your substitution is not correct over the entire domain $$-\frac{5\pi}2 \leq \theta \leq \frac{5\pi}2.$$

In particular, look at this equation on which you rely (where I have written $$a$$ and $$b$$ as the bounds of the interval of integration, since you propose to use the same method from $$-\frac{5\pi}2$$ to $$\frac{5\pi}2$$ as for $$-\frac{\pi}2$$ to $$\frac{\pi}2$$):

$$\int_a^b r\cos\theta \sqrt{r^2-r^2\sin^2\theta} \,d\theta =\int_a^b r^2\cos^2\theta\,d\theta.$$

In order to justify this equation, you must show that $$\sqrt{r^2-r^2\sin^2\theta} = r\cos\theta.$$ That is easily proved when $$\cos\theta \geq 0,$$ but it is false when $$\cos\theta < 0.$$ When $$\cos\theta < 0,$$ the correct equation is

$$\int_a^b r\cos\theta \sqrt{r^2-r^2\sin^2\theta} \,d\theta =\int_a^b -r^2\cos^2\theta\,d\theta.$$

Alternatively, you could combine the two equations as $$\int_a^b r\cos\theta \sqrt{r^2-r^2\sin^2\theta} \,d\theta =\int_a^b -r^2\cos\theta \lvert\cos\theta\rvert \,d\theta,$$ but the integral of $$\cos\theta \lvert\cos\theta\rvert$$ is not the same as the integral of $$\cos^2\theta,$$ so you still have some work to do to sort things out.

Here's how the integral can be correctly integrated from $$-\frac{5\pi}2$$ to $$\frac{5\pi}2$$:

\begin{align} \int_{-r}^r \sqrt{r^2-x^2}\,dx &= \int_{-5\pi/2}^{5\pi/2} r\cos\theta\sqrt{r^2-r^2\sin^2\theta} \,d\theta\\ &= \int_{-5\pi/2}^{5\pi/2} r^2(\cos\theta)\lvert\cos\theta\rvert \,d\theta\\ &= \int_{-5\pi/2}^{-3\pi/2} r^2\cos^2\theta \,d\theta\\ &\qquad + \int_{-3\pi/2}^{-\pi/2} -r^2\cos^2\theta \,d\theta\\ &\qquad + \int_{-\pi/2}^{\pi/2} r^2\cos^2\theta \,d\theta\\ &\qquad + \int_{\pi/2}^{3\pi/2} -r^2\cos^2\theta \,d\theta\\ &\qquad + \int_{3\pi/2}^{5\pi/2} r^2\cos^2\theta \,d\theta\\ &= \frac{\pi r^2}{2} - \frac{\pi r^2}{2} + \frac{\pi r^2}{2} - \frac{\pi r^2}{2} + \frac{\pi r^2}{2} \\ &= \frac{\pi r^2}{2}, \end{align} using the fact that $$\lvert\cos\theta\rvert = -\cos\theta$$ when $$\cos\theta \leq 0.$$

You actually get the correct answer, but only if you integrate the correct function over the entire interval. Also notice that each time $$\sin\theta$$ decreases from $$1$$ to $$-1$$ (that is, each time $$x$$ decreases from $$r$$ to $$-r$$) you precisely wipe out the amount you integrated on the previous increase. In effect, by allowing $$x$$ to go up and down all these times, you end up integrating

$$\begin{multline} \int_{-r}^r \sqrt{r^2-x^2}\,dx + \int_r^{-r} \sqrt{r^2-x^2}\,dx + \int_{-r}^r \sqrt{r^2-x^2}\,dx\\ + \int_r^{-r} \sqrt{r^2-x^2}\,dx + \int_{-r}^r \sqrt{r^2-x^2}\,dx, \end{multline}$$

in which the first four integrals cancel each other out.

• Very interesting, thank you for that, I was wondering about the point you have brought up, and you have clarified it. Incidentally, how would you go about integrating that function including the modulus that you have written above? Sep 26, 2020 at 22:10
• I was already in the process of writing it out with the square root by the time you commented, but I could use the absolute value to shorten the equations a bit. Let's try one more edit. Sep 26, 2020 at 22:27
• Thanks so much for the detailed answer, it's extremely informative! Sep 27, 2020 at 7:08
• You have this half-corrected. $\sqrt{r^2 \cos^2 \theta} = |r| |\cos \theta|$. With this change, $r|r| = \mathrm{sgn}(r) r^2$ and you don't have to spend time reasoning about signs. Sep 27, 2020 at 12:57
• @EricTowers what does $\sgn$ mean? Sep 27, 2020 at 15:01

When, in order to compute a primitive $$\int f(x)\,\mathrm dx$$, we do a substitution of the type $$x=g(y)$$ (together with $$f(x)=g'(x)\,\mathrm dy$$, of course), the substitution function $$g$$ must be a bijection. If you take $$x=r\sin\theta$$, with $$\theta\in\left[-\frac\pi2,\frac\pi2\right]$$, you do have a bijection, and so all works as it should. Or if $$\theta\in\left[\frac32\pi,\frac52\pi\right]$$. But if you take the interval $$\left[-\frac52\pi,\frac52\pi\right]$$, you don't have a bijection anymore.

• Sorry, what is a bijection? A fixed range for the given function? (I am only in high school.) Sep 26, 2020 at 21:39
• A bijection is a function $f$ from a set $A$ into a set $B$ which has in inverse, that is, for which there is a function $g\colon B\longrightarrow A$ such that you always have $g(f(x)=x$ and $g(f(x))=x$. The function $\theta\mapsto r\sin\theta$ is a bijection from $\left[-\frac\pi2,\frac\pi2\right]$ into $[-1,1]$, but it is not a bijection anymore if you take $\left[-\frac52\pi,\frac52\pi\right]$ instead. Sep 26, 2020 at 21:43
• I think I understand now; do all functions used in substitution for integration need to be bijective? Sep 26, 2020 at 21:55
• Thank you so much for answering my question so clearly, I understand it now, I really appreciate it! I'd just like to let you know, I've always found it incredible that you have helped so many people and spent so much time helping poeple, it reallly demonstrates what a kind person you must be. Sep 26, 2020 at 22:02
• Citation needed. The statement of the substitution theorem makes no mention of bijectivity. Additionally, the substitution for $$\int_{-2}^{1} \frac{2 x \, \mathrm{d}x}{\sqrt{x^2 + 1}}$$ is not a bijection. Sep 27, 2020 at 15:13

The original integral has $$x=0$$ only once, therefore you must use a $$\theta$$ range where $$sin(\theta)$$ has only one zero.

• Is that a general rule? Sep 26, 2020 at 21:53
• The general rule is that the integration range is an increasing function of x. Any change in variables must reflect that property, although it could end up in reverse. My answer was simplifing it to the specific question. Sep 26, 2020 at 23:54
• Citation needed. The statement of the substitution theorem makes no mention of monotonicity. Additionally, the substitution for $$\int_{-2}^{1} \frac{2 x \, \mathrm{d}x}{\sqrt{x^2 + 1}}$$ is not monotonic (increasing or decreasing). Sep 27, 2020 at 15:18
• @EricTowers I don't have a citation. However if the range of the new variable is not monotone, it will be necessary to split up the integral at the places where there is a change in direction. In the example cited, it works out without the split only because part of the original $\int_{-1}^1 \frac{2xdx}{\sqrt{x^2+1}}=0$ Sep 27, 2020 at 18:32
• Actually, you do not have to split up the interval. You get the same answer if you make no attempt to split up the interval. The antiderivative already encodes this information. Sep 27, 2020 at 19:13