For both volume & surface area, the sphere is split into many discs and the area or circumference of the discs are summed up in an integral. But the summation process uses $dy$ for volume & $r\,d\theta$ (arc-length) for surface area. Why this discrepancy?

Supposing we have a sphere in the $x$-$y$-$z$ plane where you split the sphere into discs along the $y$ axis.. If you visualise the problem from $z$ axis looking down over the $x$-$y$ plane.. The sphere will look like a circle and the disc will be a line segment inside the circle (chord). The length of the line segment will be the diameter of the disc. And the point where the line segment and circle meet - (x,y) can be solved by plugging in the value of y and the x we solve for will then be the radius of the disc.

Now to calculate surface area, we need to sum up the circumference of each disc $ s(x) = 2\pi x$ & and for volume, we need to sum up the area of each disc $ v(x) = \pi x^2 $

Say, the point $(x,y)$ makes an angle $\theta$ with the origin. Then for surface area, we assume for length $r\,d\theta$, the disc radius is not changing (across arc length) & we integrate it as: $$\int s(x)\, rd\theta $$

But for volume, instead of using the arc length, we use the diameter $dy$ to integrate it as: $$\int v(x) \,dy$$

Why this discrepancy? In both cases, the number of discs is the same so why should the summation be different?

I tried interchanging the summation process and when i converted everything into polar co-ordinates ($x = r\,cos\theta, y = r\,sin\theta $) i get an extra $cos\theta$ since $ dy = rd\theta.cos\theta$

The same happens to me when i calculate Moment of Inertia for a solid sphere & hollow sphere. Similarly when i calculate gravity for a point outside a solid sphere & hollow sphere.

Can someone please tell me, why we need to change the summation process?? What decides the summation process, why the difference?


When you have a ball $B_R:=\bigl\{(x,y,z)\bigm| x^2+y^2+z^2\leq R\bigr\}$ and its boundary $S_R:=\partial B_R= \bigl\{(x,y,z)\bigm| x^2+y^2+z^2= R\bigr\}$ at stake then there are various variables around: Of course $x$, $y$, $z$, and then $r:=\sqrt{x^2+y^2+z^2}$, the geographical longitude $\phi:=\arg(x,y)$, and the geographical latitude $$\theta:=\arg\bigl(\sqrt{x^2+y^2},z\bigr)\quad\in\left[-{\pi\over2},{\pi\over2}\right]\ ,$$ whereby sometimes other normalizations are in place.

Now you are told to compute the volume of $B_R$, or the area of $S_R$. Both tasks involve some integration. This integration can take place in $(x,y,z)$-space, or in the space of spherical coordinates $(r,\phi,\theta)$, and it can also involve "heuristical" arguments, depending on your state of sophistication.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.