0
$\begingroup$

Here is Prob. 10, Sec. 29, in the book Topology by James R. Munkres, 2nd edition:

Show that if $X$ is a Hausdorff space that is locally compact at the point $x$, then for each neighborhood $U$ of $x$, there is a neighborhood $V$ of $x$ such that $\overline{V}$ is compact and $\overline{V} \subset U$.

My Attempt:

Suppose that $X$ is a Hausdorff space, that $x \in X$, and that $X$ is locally compact at the point $x$. Let $U$ be any neighborhood of $x$ in $X$ (i.e. an open set containing $x$).

Since $X$ is locally compact at $x$, there exists a compact subspace $C$ of $X$ and a neighborhood $U^\prime$ of $x$ such that $$ U^\prime \subset C. \tag{0} $$

Now let us put $$ V \colon= U \cap U^\prime. \tag{Definition 0} $$ Then $V$ is a neighborhood of $x$, and (by (Definition 0) and (0) above), we obtain $$ V \subset U^\prime \subset C, $$ and hence $$ V \subset C. \tag{1} $$

Now as $C$ is a compact subspace of the Hausdorff space $X$, so $C$ is closed in $X$, by Theorem 26.3 in Munkres.

Moreover, as $C$ is a closed set in $X$ and as $V \subset C$ by (1) above, so we can also conclude that $$ \overline{V} \subset C. \tag{2} $$

And, as $\overline{V}$ is a closed set in $X$ and as $\overline{V} \subset C$, so $$ \overline{V} = \overline{V} \cap C, $$ and thus by Theorem 17.2 in Munkres we can also conclude that $\overline{V}$ is also closed in the subspace $C$ of $X$

Finally, as $\overline{V}$ is a closed set in the compact space $C$, so $\overline{V}$ is also compact, by Theorem 26.2 in Munkres; as $\overline{V}$ is compact as a subspace of $C$ and as $C$ is a subspace of $X$, so $\overline{V}$ is also compact as a subspace of $X$.

What next? How to proceed from here to show that $\overline{V} \subset U$ also?

$\endgroup$

1 Answer 1

2
$\begingroup$

You need to use that $C$, being compact in a Hausdorff space, is (a normal and hence) regular space, and in a regular space we have, whenever $x \in O$ open, an open $O'$ such that $x \in O' \subseteq \overline{O'} \subseteq O$.

Apply this to your $U \cap U'$ and inside we get the required $V$ almost for free from this regularity (open in open is open again, and $\overline{V}$ sits inside $C$ so is compact).

Added upon request:

Without using regularity directly, in Lemma 26.4 Munkres shows that whenever $Y$ is a compact subset of a Hausdorff space $X$ and $x_0 \notin Y$, there are open and disjoint $U$ and $V$ containing $x_0$ resp. $Y$, which is all the regularity we need:

We have $C$ compact and $U'$ the open neighbourhood of $x$ inside $C$. Then $C':=C \cap \left( X \setminus \left( U \cap U^\prime \right) \right)$ is compact (being closed in $C$) and $x \notin C'$. So by 26.4 we have open $x \in O_1$ and $O_2 \ \supseteq C'$ that are disjoint.

It's then not too hard to see that $V= U \cap U' \cap O_1$ is as required, it's certainly an open neighbourhood of $x$ and $\overline{V} \subseteq U$.

(For the last inclusion, which is clear (for me at least) from a picture, a more formal proof:

Suppose $y \in \overline{V}$, then in particular $y \in \overline{U'} \subseteq \overline{C}=C$ (using Hausdorff again!; also when we applied 26.4 of course). Also $y \in \overline{O_1}$, so $y \notin O_2$ (any point in $O_2$ has a neighbourhood, namely $O_2$, that is disjoint from $O_1$ to guarantee that it's not in the closure of $O_1$), and so $y \notin C'$ either. Knowing the definition of $C'$ and $y \in C$ we see that $y \notin X\setminus (U \cap U')$ which implies $y \in U' \cap U \subseteq U$ as required.

The regularity route is easier, so that's why I chose it first, but Munkres treats regularity after compactness, hence this addition.

$\endgroup$
2
  • $\begingroup$ regularity and normality are covered in Chap. 4 in Munkres. So can you please modify your proof to just use the material on compactness and local compactness as has been discussed by Munkres until Sec. 29? $\endgroup$ Apr 8, 2020 at 10:50
  • $\begingroup$ @SaaqibMahmood Done. See last part. $\endgroup$ Apr 8, 2020 at 11:27

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.