Solve the following system of equation, provided that x and y are positive real numbers: $$ \log_9{x} = \log_6{y} = \log_4(2x+y) $$

Attempt number 1:

I tried to change all the bases to the natural logarithm: $$ \dfrac{\ln{x}}{\ln{9}} = \dfrac{\ln{y}}{\ln{6}} = \dfrac{\ln(2x+y)}{\ln{4}} $$ Then, I tried to represent $y$ in terms of $x$: $$ y = e^{\dfrac{\ln{6}\ln{x}}{\ln{9}}} $$ Then I tried to subtitute in and solve for $x$: $$ \dfrac{\ln{x}}{\ln{6}} = \dfrac{\ln\left(2x+e^{\dfrac{\ln{6}\ln{x}}{\ln{9}}}\right)}{\ln{4}} $$ This equation is too complicated for me to solve.

Attempt number 2:

Let $y = kx$, then we have: $$ \log_9{x} = \log_6{kx} = \log_4(x(k+2)) $$ $$ \log_9{x} = \log_6{x} + \log_6{k} = \log_4{x} - log_4(k+2) $$ I then tried to solve for $k$ but the resulting equation is not very promising: $$ \log_9{k} = \dfrac{(\log_4{x} + \log_4(k+2))(1 - \log_9{6})}{\log_9{6}} $$

I would like to know whether there is another way to solve this problem. Thanks in advance.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Don't try to do it all at once. Break it into two or maybe even three parts. $\endgroup$ – fleablood Apr 3 '20 at 16:22
  • $\begingroup$ @fleablood Thanks for your reminder, I will notice it in the future. $\endgroup$ – KM02 Apr 3 '20 at 18:20

With your second approach, plug $y=kx$ into $ \log_9{x} = \log_6{y}$ and $ \log_9{x} = \log_4(2x+y)$ respectively to get

$$\ln x = \frac{2\ln k \ln 3}{\ln2-\ln3},\>\>\>\>\> \ln x = \frac{\ln (2+k) \ln 3}{\ln2-\ln3}$$

which leads to $2\ln k = \ln (2+k)\implies k=2$ and, in turn, the solutions

$$x = 2^{-\ln_{3/2}9}, \>\>\>\>\> y = 2^{1-\ln_{3/2}9}$$

  • $\begingroup$ Wow, I did not notice to plug $kx$ into those equations to get $k = 2$. Thank you for your explanation. $\endgroup$ – KM02 Apr 3 '20 at 18:18
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @KM02 - no problem $\endgroup$ – Quanto Apr 3 '20 at 18:20

Always remember the golden rule of ratio and proportions: $$\dfrac ab=\dfrac cd\implies\dfrac ab=\dfrac cd=\dfrac {ma+nc}{mb+nd}$$ for any real $m$ and $n$ such that the denominator $mb+nd\ne 0$. In your first attempt, you got,

$$ \dfrac{\ln{x}}{\ln{9}} = \dfrac{\ln{y}}{\ln{6}} = \dfrac{\ln(2x+y)}{\ln{4}} $$

Taking $m=1$ and $n=-1$, use ratio and proportions in the first two and last two elements to get, $$\color{red}{\dfrac{\ln x-\ln y}{\ln9-\ln 6}}=\dfrac{\ln{x}}{\ln{9}} = \dfrac{\ln{y}}{\ln{6}} = \dfrac{\ln(2x+y)}{\ln{4}}=\color{blue}{\dfrac{\ln y-\ln(2x+y)}{\ln6-\ln 4}}\\ \implies \dfrac xy=\dfrac y{2x+y}$$ (on equating the red and blue fractions) Now it is easy to solve.

  • $\begingroup$ Oh wow, I don't think that I have ever encountered such magic equality about ratio like that (or I didn't pay enough attention to my teacher). Anyways, thanks for your explanation. $\endgroup$ – KM02 Apr 3 '20 at 18:18

Absolutely totally.

$\dfrac{\ln x}{\ln (2x+y)}=\dfrac{\ln 9}{\ln 4}=\dfrac{2\ln 3}{2\ln 2}=\dfrac{\ln 3}{\ln 2}$

$\dfrac{\ln y}{\ln (2x+y)}=\dfrac{\ln 6}{\ln 4}=\dfrac{\ln 2+\ln 3}{2\ln 2}=\dfrac{1}{2}\left(1+\dfrac{\ln x}{\ln (2x+y)} \right)$

$\dfrac{\ln y}{\ln (2x+y)}=\dfrac{1}{2} \cdot \dfrac{\ln (2x+y) + \ln x}{\ln (2x+y)}$

$2\ln y=\ln (2x^2+xy)$


My answer is no different from the one up there but I guess it's a different perspective.


Setting $x=9^{u}$ and $y=6^{v}$, we get:



$v= \log_4{(2.3^{2u}+6^{v})}$,

$v =\log_4{(2.3^{2v}+6^{v})}$,




$2. 3^{v}=2^{v}$,

Applying the logarithm natural to first and second members, we obtain:

$\ln{(2. 3^{v})}=\ln{(2^{v})}$,


$v=-\frac{\ln{(2)}} {\ln{(\frac{3}{2})}}$;

the x and y values are:

$x=9^{-\frac{\ln{(2)}} {\ln{(\frac{3}{2}})}},$



$x=\frac{e^{-\frac{2\ln{(2)}^{2}}{\ln{(\frac{3}{2})}}}} {4}$



Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.