7
$\begingroup$

I am going to be taking a first course in abstract algebra this fall and we are using Jacobson's Basic Algebra I for the course text. It looks like a good textbook, but it is lacking a lot of motivation (I am new to higher math), so I was wondering if there are other books to supplement my studies. Particularly historical or geometric motivations; Something to give me an idea about why we are learning about ideals, modules, etc. so I can "picture" what we are learning.

Thanks for any input!

$\endgroup$
9
$\begingroup$

That's a good question that - alas - does not really have a good answer - at least not a single textbook that one could point to. The best motivation for ideals and modules comes from number theory. As such, you might find it helpful to attempt to learn some algebraic number theory in parallel, e.g. factorization theory in quadratic number fields. Unfortunately most of the algebraic number theory textbooks already assume solid algebra background, so you'll need to interpolate your own motivational examples.

One crucial point deserves emphasis. When first learning about new abstractions such as ideals and modules it is absolutely essential to understand their motivating concrete instances. Thus when you are learning about ideals in algebra you should revisit your knowledge of elementary number theory and reinterpret results in terms of these new abstractions. For example, see my post here and its links - which explains how various proofs of irrationality of sqrt's by descent on the size of a denominator are merely special cases of proofs that a denominator ideal - Dedekind's conductor ideal - is principal or invertible. From this general viewpoint the proof is a one-liner: the conductor ideal is invertible so cancelable. This shows that any Dedekind domain or PID is integrally closed - a monic generalization of the rational root test to a very wide class of rings. This is but one of many generalizations that you will meet when studying factorization theory in wider classes of rings. To better hone your intuition it is essential that you learn to easily move back-and-forth in this way between the concrete and abstract. Unfortunately most textbooks omit explicit discussion of such motivational material, so you'll need to develop it on-the-fly as need be.

$\endgroup$
2
$\begingroup$

I highly recommend Artin's Algebra, which is full of great motivation and originally kindled my love for algebra.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

I know this is an old post but I am facing a similar problem right now. I studied some basic group theory on my own and want to study a course in abstract algebra from a good book. After browsing a lot of reviews it seems Jacobson's first volume is a comprehensive treatment of abstract algebra topics at the undergraduate level. The only problem for me is I don't really know my way around algebra yet and have heard, as pointed out by @Bill Dubuque, that a lot of the ideas often seem unmotivated to a beginner.

After much browsing I stumbled upon a book titled Basic Abstract Algebra by Robert B. Ash. I purchased a copy (very affordable Dover edition) and from the preface alone one can see that it is meant to be a source of motivation and assistance for newcomers to the subject. It also comes with lots of exercises and a complete set of solutions (which is indispensable for someone self-studying the material). I'll update this answer with details as I continue studying through these topics.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy