I came across this equation: $x + \dfrac{3x}{\sqrt{x^2 - 9}} = \dfrac{35}{4}$

Wolfram Alpha found 2 roots: $x=5$ and $x=\dfrac{15}{4}$, which "coincidentally" add up to $\dfrac{35}{4}$. So I'm thinking there should be a better way to solve it than the naïve way of bringing the fractions together and then squaring. Is there any?


As $x>0$

WLOG $x=3\sec t, 0< t<\dfrac\pi2\implies \sin t,\cos t>0$

$$\dfrac{35}4=3\sec t+\dfrac{3\sec t}{3\tan t} \iff\sec t+\csc t=\dfrac{35}{12}$$


Let $\sin t+\cos t=u$



As $u>0, u=\sin t+\cos t=\dfrac75$

Now use $(\sin t+\cos t)^2+(\cos t-\sin t)^2=2$

$\cos t-\sin t=\pm\sqrt{2-\left(\dfrac75\right)^2}=\pm\dfrac15$

$2\cos t=\cos t-\sin t+\cos t+\sin t=\dfrac{7\pm1}5$


As $\sec^2t+\csc^2t=\sec^2t\csc^2t$

Let $u=\sec t\csc t=\dfrac2{\sin2t}$

Squaring we get $$\left(\dfrac{35}{12}\right)^2=u^2+2u\iff(u+1)^2=\left(\dfrac{37}{12}\right)^2\implies u=\dfrac{25}{12}\text{ as }u>0$$


$x=\dfrac3{\cos t}=+\dfrac6{\sqrt{2(1+\cos2t)}}=?$


We see that we need $x>3$ then let $x=\frac3{\cos y}$ with $y\in\left(0,\frac \pi 2\right)$

$$x + \dfrac{3x}{\sqrt{x^2 - 9}} = \dfrac{35}{4} \iff \frac1{\cos y}+\frac1{\sin y}=\dfrac{35}{12}$$

and by half tangent identities by $t=\tan \frac y2$ we obtain

$$\frac{1+t^2}{1-t^2}+\frac{1+t^2}{2t}=\dfrac{35}{12} \iff (3t-1)(2t-1)(t^2-7t-6)=0$$

and $t=\frac 13, \frac12$ lead to the answer indeed

  • $\dfrac3{\cos(2\cdot \arctan\left(\frac13\right)}=5$
  • $\dfrac3{\cos(2\cdot \arctan\left(\frac12\right)}=\frac{15}4$

It' not a coincidence. Let $f(x)=x + g(x)$ where $g(g(x))=x$, that is, $g$ is an involution. We'll show that $f(x)=f(a-x)$, provided that $f(x)=a$.

Assume $f(x)=a$, that is $a-x=g(x)$. Now $$f(a-x)=f(g(x))=g(x)+g(g(x))=g(x)+x=f(x)$$.

In our case define $$g(x)=\frac{3x}{\sqrt{x^2 - 9}}.$$ Indeed, $g$ is an involution as $$g(g(x))=\dfrac{3\frac{3x}{\sqrt{x^2 - 9}}}{\sqrt{\frac{9x^2}{x^2 - 9} - 9}}= \dfrac{x\frac{9}{\sqrt{x^2 - 9}}}{3\sqrt{\frac{x^2}{x^2 - 9} - 1}}= \dfrac{x\frac{9}{\sqrt{x^2 - 9}}}{3\sqrt{\frac{9}{x^2 - 9}}}=x. $$


Like Solve the equation $x^2+\frac{9x^2}{(x+3)^2}=27$

Clearly $x>0$

Let $\dfrac{3x}{\sqrt{x^2-9}}=y$ so that $x+y=\dfrac{35}4$


Use $x+y=\dfrac{35}4$ and $xy>0$ for find $xy=\dfrac{75}4$

So, $x,y$ are the roots of $$t^2-\dfrac{35}4t+\dfrac{75}4=0$$


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.