I had some trouble solving this problem from Barron's Math Level 2 workbook.

If $(\sec x)(\tan x) < 0$, which of the following must be true?

I. $\tan x < 0$

II. $\csc x \cot x < 0$

III. $x$ is in the third or fourth quadrant

I immediately eliminated Statement I, because either one of the factors, or both of them, could be less than 0, but the question asks for which statements must be true.

Statement II, I figured was wrong because the reciprocal of $\sec x \tan x$ is $\cos x \cot x$, not $\csc x \cot x$.

Statement III, however, I did not understand how to definitively prove or disprove. I converted the given expression to $\frac{\sin x}{\cos^2x}$. For it to be less than 0, one of the numerator or denominator must be less than 0. $\sin x$ is positive in Quadrants I and II, so it is negative in III and IV. $\cos^2x$ cannot be negative, so it must be in Quadrants I or IV, where it is positive. Therefore, $\sin x$ must be in Quadrants III and IV (to be negative) and $\cos x$ in Quadrants I or IV (to be positive). Where do I take it from there? The text says choice III is true, only.

  • $\begingroup$ Part III is determined only by the sign of $\sin x$ because $\cos^2 x$ is nonnegative for all $x$ (due to the squaring) $\endgroup$ – MPW Oct 27 at 18:16

Doing it as you did, you know that $\cos^2x$ is always positive. Therefore, the expression is negative if and only if $\sin x$ is negative. As you note, that happens only in quadrants III and IV, so the third statement is true.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Another question: For this problem, is it safe to assume that $\cos^2 x \ne 0$? $\endgroup$ – bin Oct 27 at 18:32
  • $\begingroup$ @bin No, but for whatever reason we traditionally play fast and loose when talking about whether points on the axes belong to quadrants. $\endgroup$ – Matthew Daly Oct 27 at 18:34
  • $\begingroup$ You can write down that cos(x) ≠ 0. It's fine, because whenever cos(x) is 0, x is 90 degrees, 270 degrees... etc, and x will not lie on any quadrant anyway. $\endgroup$ – helpme Oct 27 at 20:29

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.