Inspired by yesterday's closed question with many upvotes, I studied the functional equation $$f(x+1)-f(x)=f\left(\frac 1x\right)\qquad\forall x\in\mathbb R\setminus\{0\}\qquad f\in C^1$$

I have solved the equation by construction, and I will present my solution as an answer. However, my solution only includes the conditions for once-differentiability, and I cannot see any ways to generalize it to infinite-differentiability.

My question is

Are there any smooth/analytic solutions to the functional equation?

Notably, user @John Omielan gave a nearly-analytic solution: $$f(x)=x+2+\frac1{x+1}$$


My approach is by construction.

Firstly, I will solve the functional equation on $\mathbb R^+$, without considering continuity/differentiability, which I will care about later.

Denote $\phi$ the golden ratio.

Partition $\mathbb R^+$ into

  1. $[0,\phi]$
  2. $[\phi,1]$
  3. $[1,1+\phi]$
  4. $[1+\phi,\infty)$

(Call the $n$th partition P$n$)

(Why $\phi$? : My initial idea is to define arbitrary functions on $[0,a]$ and $[1,1+a]$, and use the functional equation to extend the function. It turns out that this allows extension to $[\frac1a,\infty)$. To prevent overlapping of 'arbitrary region' and 'extension region', the critical $a$ satisfies $1+a=\frac 1a\implies a=\phi$.)

In my studies, I found that we can define two arbitrary functions $f_1$ and $f_3$ on P1 and P3 respectively. Then, on P4, we have $$f(x)=f_4(x):=f_3(1+1/x)-f_1(1/x)\qquad x\in [1+\phi,\infty)$$

Furthermore, for $x$ in P2, $$f(x)=f_2(x):=f_4(x+1)-f_3(1/x)=f_3\left(1+\frac1{x+1}\right)-f_1\left(\frac1{x+1}\right)-f_3\left(\frac1x\right)$$

Secondly, I will solve the functional equation on $\mathbb R^-$.

This case is not analogous to the one above. Partition $\mathbb R^-$ into $[-n,-n-1]$ for $n=0,1,2,\cdots$, and $f(x)=f_{-n}(x)$ on $[-n,-n-1]$.

Since in the functional equation, the arguments are $x$, $x+1$, and $\frac1x$, it is impossible that only one argument is negative. Therefore, $f$ on $\mathbb R^-$ is not completely determined by $f$ on $\mathbb R^+$, and we do have some degrees of freedom on the $\mathbb R^-$.

It turns out that we can define an arbitrary $f_0$.

Then, $$f_{-1}(x)=f_0(x+1)-f_0(1/x)$$ $$f_{-2}(x)=f_{-1}(x+1)-f_0(1/x)=f_0(x+2)-f_0(1/(x+1))-f_0(1/x)$$ $$\cdots$$ $$f_{-n}(x)=f_0(x+n)-\sum^{n-1}_{k=0}f_0\left(\frac1{x+k}\right)$$

Now let us find the conditions for continuity.

In general, we require

  1. $f_{-(n-1)}(-n)=f_{-n}(-n)$ for $n=1,2,3,\cdots$.
  2. On $\mathbb R^+$ neighbouring functions have to agree on the boundary.

After a lot of tedious algebra, it turns out that it is required that

  1. $f_1(\phi)=0$
  2. $f_3(3/2)=2f_3(1)+f_1(1/2)$
  3. $2f_0(-1)=f_0(0)=f_1(0)$

Similarly, for differnetiability,

  1. $\phi \cdot f_1'(\phi)=\sqrt5 \cdot f_3'(\phi+1)$
  2. $f_3'(3/2)=f_1'(1/2)$
  3. $f_0'(0)=f_1'(0)=0$

To sum up:

If two differentiable functions $\mu:[-1,\phi]$ and $\nu:[1,1+\phi]$ satisfy the following conditions:

  1. $\mu(\phi)=0$
  2. $\nu(3/2)=2\nu(1)+\mu(1/2)$
  3. $2\mu(-1)=\mu(0)$
  4. $\phi \cdot \mu'(\phi)=\sqrt5 \cdot \nu'(\phi+1)$
  5. $\nu'(3/2)=\mu'(1/2)$
  6. $\mu'(0)=0$

then, $$f(x) = \begin{cases} \nu(1+1/x)-\mu(1/x) & x>1+\phi \\ \nu(x) & 1+\phi > x > 1 \\ \nu\left(1+\frac1{x+1}\right)-\mu\left(\frac1{x+1}\right)-\nu\left(\frac1x\right) & 1 > x > \phi \\ \mu(x) & \phi > x > -1 \\ \mu(x+n)-\sum^{n-1}_{k=0}\mu\left(\frac1{x+k}\right) & -n>x>-n-1 \quad (n=1,2,3,\cdots) \end{cases}$$


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.