I am trying to calculate the magnitude of sum three unit vectors $$\vec{d}_{1},\vec{d}_{2},\vec{d}_{3}$$ with $|\vec{d}_{1}|=1=|\vec{d}_{2}|=|\vec{d}_{3}|$. Now ,$\vec{d}_{1} \cdot \vec{d}_{2} =\cos(\gamma_{12})$ and $\vec{d}_{2} \cdot \vec{d}_{3} =\cos(\gamma_{23})$ . Similarly for $\vec{d}_{1} \cdot \vec{d}_{3} =\cos(\gamma_{13})$.

Now Computing the magnitude of the sum of three vectors $$|\vec{d}_{1} +\vec{d}_{2}+\vec{d}_{3}|= \sqrt{|\vec{d}_{1}|^{2}+|\vec{d}_{2}|^{2}+|\vec{d}_{3}|^{2}+2\vec{d}_{1}\cdot\vec{d}_{2}+2\vec{d}_{2}\cdot \vec{d}_{3}+2\vec{d}_{1}\cdot\vec{d}_{3}}$$ $$=\sqrt{1+1+1+2\cos(\gamma_{12})+2\cos(\gamma_{23})+2\cos(\gamma_{13})}$$ suppose I take $\cos(\gamma_{12})=\cos(\gamma_{23})=\cos(120)=-\frac{1}{2}$. Then the expression boils down to ,$$=\sqrt{3-2(\frac{1}{2})-2(\frac{1}{2})+2\cos(\gamma_{13})}$$ This further reduces to $$=\sqrt{1+2\cos(\gamma_{13})}$$. Here $\cos(\gamma_{13})$ can take value between -1 and +1. Here if the value of $\cos(\gamma_{13})<-\frac{1}{2}$. The answer become complex. How could this be possible when I am trying to compute magniture of three real vectors in 3D space ?. I have fixed the angles $\gamma_{12}=\gamma_{23}=120$degrees. I have made the angle $\gamma_{13}$ to take any arbitrary angles between 0 degrees to 360 degrees. I have expressed this angle in terms of spherical polar angle variables in 3D space. $$\cos(\gamma_{13})=\cos(\theta_{1})\cos(\theta_{3})+\sin(\theta_{1})\sin(\theta_{3})\cos(\phi_{1}-\phi_{3})$$. I have two questions here,

(1)How can these magnitudes become complex ?

(2)How do we get the region of $\theta_{1},\theta_{3},\phi_{1}$ and $\phi_{3}$ which are not making the expression complex ?

  • $\begingroup$ Gamma 13 can have maximum value of 120 degree. You can't have higher than that. $\endgroup$ – Ajay Mishra Jun 28 at 5:30
  • $\begingroup$ Show me any diagram of $ \gamma_{13} > 120$ degrees $\endgroup$ – Ajay Mishra Jun 28 at 5:32
  • $\begingroup$ Being vectors, you're limited by $\gamma_{12} + \gamma_{13} + \gamma_{23} \leq 360$. $\endgroup$ – user3257842 Jun 28 at 6:15
  • $\begingroup$ How sum of the three angles less than 360 ? $\endgroup$ – vigneshwaran kannan Jun 28 at 6:33

No, of course it can't be complex. Express the sum in an orthonormal base and you find that the length is real non-negative.

Without loss of generality you can assume that the space has three dimensions. Now the sum of the angels must be no larger that $2\pi$ (ie. $360^\circ$) which makes it impossible for $\cos \gamma_{13}$ to be larger than $2\pi/3$.

The reason the sum of the angels must be no larger than $2\pi$ is because projected onto a plane the sum of angles will be exactly $2\pi$ and the non-projected angle is no larger than that of the projection.

  • $\begingroup$ How do I find out the allowed region in terms of the polar angle coordinates? I mean how do I find out the answer for my second question? $\endgroup$ – vigneshwaran kannan Jun 28 at 8:46
  • $\begingroup$ @vigneshwarankannan The whole space is the region as there is no possibility of the sum to have complex length (ie no possibility to be outside the allowed region). $\endgroup$ – skyking Jun 30 at 7:35

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.