I'm reading the paper Rational Analogs in projective planes by Zhixu Su. I am trying to work out the example to calculate the form $e_2$ for dimension 16 in the paper. I am however not sure how to proceed from the step before the last one to the last one. I tried grouping things with $p_j=\sum_{i_1<...<i_j}^{k/2}x_{i_1}^2...x_{i_j}^2$, the jth Pontryagin class, without success. In the expression, $k$ represents the dimension of the manifold. Here are the steps that are featured in the paper:

$$ e_2 = \sigma_2 (e^{x_1} + e^{-x_1}-2,x^{x_2} + e^{-x_2}-2,...) \\ =\sum_{j,k}(e^{x_j}+e^{-x_j}-2)(e^{x_k}+e^{-x_k}-2) \\ =\sum_{j,k}(x_j^2+\frac{x_j^4}{12}+\frac{x_j^6}{360}+\frac{x_j^8}{20160} + O(x_j^9))(x_k^2+\frac{x_k^4}{12}+\frac{x_k^6}{360}+\frac{x_k^8}{20160} + O(x_k^9)) \\ =\sum_{j,k}(x_j^2x_k^2 + \frac{x_j^4x_k^4}{144}+\frac{x_j^2x_k^6}{360}+\frac{x_j^6x_k^2}{360})+\text{terms of degree other than 8 and 16} \\ =p_2+\frac{p_2^2}{720}+\frac{p_4}{360} $$

Where we set beforehand $p_1=p_3=0$.

  • $\begingroup$ Do you mean $j$s instead of $k$s in the RHS of your formula for $p_j$? $\endgroup$ – user10354138 Jun 12 at 14:37
  • $\begingroup$ @user10354138, sorry, what $ks$? $\endgroup$ – Alonso Perez Lona Jun 12 at 16:25
  • $\begingroup$ All occurrence of $k$ in $p_j=\sum_{i_1<\dots<i_k}^{k/2}x_{i_1}^2\dots x_{i_k}^2$, RHS doesn't depend on $j$ but on this mysterious $k$? $\endgroup$ – user10354138 Jun 12 at 16:27
  • $\begingroup$ Oh, true, thanks for pointing out. $\endgroup$ – Alonso Perez Lona Jun 12 at 16:30

Hmm.. you are using $k$ for two different things, the dummy in $\sum_{j,k}$, and the dimension of manifold? Anyway, let's forget about the dimension of manifold and let every letter appearing in $\sum_{\dots}$ be dummy.

We have, by Newton-Girard formulae (and imposing $p_1=p_3=0$), \begin{align*} \sum_j x_j^4 &= p_1^2 - 2p_2=-2p_2\\ \sum_j x_j^6 &= p_1(p_1^2-2p_2)-p_2p_1+3p_3\\ &=p_1^3-3p_1p_2+3p_3=0\\ \sum_j x_j^8 &= p_1(p_1^3-3p_1p_2+3p_3)-(p_1^2 - 2p_2)p_2+p_3p_1-4p_4\\ &=p_1^4-4p_1^2p_2+4p_1p_3 + 2p_2^2-4p_4\\ &=2p_2^2-4p_4 \end{align*} So $$ \sum_{j<k} x_j^4x_k^4=\frac{\left(\sum_j x_j^4\right)^2-\sum_j x_j^8}2 =p_2^2+2p_4 $$ and $$ \sum_{j<k} (x_j^2x_k^6+x_j^6x_k^2)=\left(\sum_j x_j^2\right)\left(\sum_k x_k^6\right)-\sum_j x_j^8= 4p_4-2p_2^2 $$ Hence \begin{align*} &\sum_{j<k}\left(x_j^2x_k^2+\frac{x_j^4x_k^4}{144}+\frac{x_j^2x_k^6+x_j^6x_k^2}{360}\right)\\ &=p_2+\frac{p_2^2+2p_4}{144}+\frac{4p_4-2p_2^2}{360} \\ &=p_2+\frac{p_2^2}{720}+\frac{p_4}{40}. \end{align*}


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.