Let $S$ be a simply connected subset of $\mathbb{R}^2$ and let $x$ be an interior point of $S$, meaning that $B_r(x)\subseteq S$ for some $r>0$. Is it necessarily the case that $\pi_1(S\setminus\{x\})\cong\mathbb{Z}$?

Let $B=B_r(x)$ and let $G=\pi_1(S\setminus\{x\})$. I can show that $G^{ab}\cong\mathbb{Z}$. Consider the commutative diagram of topological spaces $$ \newcommand{\ra}[1]{\kern-1.5ex\xrightarrow{\ \ #1\ \ }\phantom{}\kern-1.5ex} \newcommand{\ras}[1]{\kern-1.5ex\xrightarrow{\ \ \smash{#1}\ \ }\phantom{}\kern-1.5ex} \newcommand{\da}[1]{\bigg\downarrow\raise.5ex\rlap{\scriptstyle#1}} \begin{array}{c}B\setminus\{x\}&\ra{}&S\setminus\{x\}&\ra{}&\mathbb{R}^2\setminus\{x\}\\\da{}&&\da{}\\B&\ra{}&S\end{array} $$ Applying the fundamental group functor gives a commutative diagram of groups $$ \begin{array}{c}\mathbb{Z}&\ra{}&G&\ra{}&\mathbb{Z}\\\da{}&&\da{}\\1&\ra{}&1\end{array} $$ where the composition of the top two maps is the identity homomorphism on $\mathbb{Z}$. By the Seifert-van Kampen theorem, the square is a pushout diagram of groups, meaning that the normal closure of the image of $\mathbb{Z}\to G$ is all of $G$. In particular, if $A$ is an abelian group then any two homomorphisms $G\to A$ that agree on the image of $\mathbb{Z}\to G$ must agree on all of $G$. Another way to put this is that if we have two homomorphisms $G\to A$ such that the two compositions $\mathbb{Z}\to G\to A$ are equal then the two homomorhpisms $G\to A$ are equal.

I claim that the map $G\to\mathbb{Z}$ is an abelianization map. To see this, let $A$ be an abelian group and let $G\to A$ be a homomorphism. Now recall that the composition $\mathbb{Z}\to G\to\mathbb{Z}$ is the identity. Then the composition $\mathbb{Z}\to G\to\mathbb{Z}\to G\to A$ agrees with the composition $\mathbb{Z}\to G\to A$. By the remark at the end of the previous paragraph, this means that the composition $G\to\mathbb{Z}\to G\to A$ agrees with the map $G\to A$. In other words, the composition $\mathbb{Z}\to G\to A$ makes the abelianization diagram commute.

To show uniqueness, let $\mathbb{Z}\to A$ be a map making the abelianization diagram commute. Then the composition $G\to\mathbb{Z}\to A$ agrees with the map $G\to A$. Then the composition $\mathbb{Z}\to G\to\mathbb{Z}\to A$ agrees with the composition $\mathbb{Z}\to G\to A$. Since the composition $\mathbb{Z}\to G\to\mathbb{Z}$ is the identity, this shows that the map $\mathbb{Z}\to A$ is given by the composition $\mathbb{Z}\to G\to A$.

This shows that the map $G\to\mathbb{Z}$ is an abelianization map.

  • $\begingroup$ @freakish How do you know H is isomorphic to $\mathbb{Z}$? $\endgroup$ Jun 11 '19 at 12:02
  • $\begingroup$ @ConnorMalin Ok, after diving into details I can only prove that $H$ is a normal closure of some image of $\mathbb{Z}$ in $\pi_1(V)$. That's not enough. $\endgroup$
    – freakish
    Jun 11 '19 at 13:41
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ If $S$ is open, then complex analysis tells us that it's either $\mathbb{R}^2$, in which case the answer is clear, or it's conformally equivalent, so in particular homeomorphic to $D^2$, in which case the answer is clear too. So we're looking at widely non-open sets. I think the best way to go would then be to somehow manage to get back to the open case $\endgroup$ Jun 11 '19 at 15:23
  • $\begingroup$ It’s worth noting that there are noncontractible simply connected (closed) sets. $\endgroup$ Jun 11 '19 at 16:42
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ You can try Mathoverflow (the question is at the right level). Make sure you link to the original MSE question. $\endgroup$ Dec 16 '19 at 18:31

This is a complete revision of an earlier answer.

I am not sure about the question in full generality, but here is what I can prove:

Theorem 1. Suppose that $S\subset R^2$ is a simply-connected compact subset. Then for every $x\in int(S)$, the group $G=\pi_1(S-\{x\})$ is infinite cyclic.


Lemma 1. Let $S\subset R^2$ be a subset (not necessarily compact) with $H_0(S)=H_1(S)=0$. Then for every $x\in int(S)$, $H_1(S-\{x\})\cong {\mathbb Z}$.

Proof. Let $B\subset int(S)$ be an open ball centered at $x$. The set $S$ is the union of $X=S-\{x\}$ and $B$, with $X\cap B= B-\{x\}$.
We have the (exact) Mayer-Vietoris sequence $$ 0= H_1(S) \leftarrow H_1(B)\oplus H_1(X) = H_1(X) \leftarrow H_1(B-\{x\})={\mathbb Z}\leftarrow H_2(S)=0 $$ (the equality $H_2(S)=0$ is not completely trivial). From this, we obtain $H_1(X)= {\mathbb Z}$. qed

In particular, the abelianization of $G=\pi_1(S-\{x\})$ is infinite cyclic.

In order to proceed, I will need a bit of group theory.

Definition. A group $F$ is called fully residually free if for every finite subset $E\subset F$, there exists a homomorphism $f: F\to F_n$, a free group of some rank (depending on $E$), such that $f|_E$ is one-to-one.

Notation. Given a group $H$ and an element subset $a\in H$, I will denote $<a>^H$ the normal closure of $a$ in $H$, i.e. the smallest normal subgroup of $H$ containing $a$.

Lemma 2. Suppose that $H= F_\alpha$ is a free group of (possibly infinite) rank $\alpha\ge 1$ and assume that $H/<a>^{H}$ is trivial. Then $n=1$, i.e. $H$ is infinite cyclic.

Proof. Use the fact that the abelianization of $F$ is $\cong {\mathbb Z}^\alpha$ and if the quotient of ${\mathbb Z}^\alpha$ by a rank $\le 1$ subgroup is trivial then $\alpha=1$. qed

Lemma 3. Suppose that $G$ is a fully residually free group whose abelianization is isomorphic to ${\mathbb Z}$, and $g\in G$ is such that $G=<g>^G$, i.e. $G$ is normally generated by $g$. Then $G\cong {\mathbb Z}$.

Proof. First of all, every quotient group $Q$ of $G$ is normally generated by the projection of $g$. Therefore, if such quotient is a free group, by Lemma 2, the group $Q$ is cyclic, in particular, abelian. I now claim that $G$ is abelian. Indeed, take $g_1, g_2\in G$ and let $E=\{1, [g_1, g_2]\}$. Since $G$ is fully residually free, there is a free quotient group of $G$ to which the set $E$ projects injectively. As noted above, such quotient is abelian, forcing $[g_1, g_2]=1$. Hence, $G$ is abelian. But $G$ is assumed to have infinite cyclic abelianization, which implies that $G\cong {\mathbb Z}$. qed

I will also need the following theorem proven in Corollary 7 of

H. Fischer, A. Zastrow, The fundamental groups of subsets of closed surfaces inject into their first shape groups, Algebraic and Geometric Topology 5 (2005) 1655-1676.

Theorem 2. For every path-connected compact subset $X\subset S^2$, the fundamental group $\pi_1(X)$ is fully residually free.

We can now finish the proof of Theorem 1. Recall that $S\subset R^2\subset S^2$ is compact, $G=\pi_1(X)$, where $X=S-\{x\}$. Since $x$ is in the interior of $S$ and $S$ is path-connected, it follows that $X=S-\{x\}$ is path-connected. Let $g\in \pi_1(X)$ be an element represented by a small circle centered at $x$. Since $\pi_1(S)=1$, by the van Kampen theorem, $G=<g>^G$, i.e. $G$ is normally .generated by $G$. By Lemma 1, $G$ has infinite cyclic abelianization. Thus, by combining Theorem 2 with Lemma 3, we see that $G\cong {\mathbb Z}$. qed

  • $\begingroup$ Doesn't Corollary 7 in the paper require that $X$ is proper and compact? $\endgroup$ Dec 14 '19 at 16:58
  • $\begingroup$ @ThomasBrowning: You are right, I was careless. See the edit. $\endgroup$ Dec 14 '19 at 23:21

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.