0
$\begingroup$

Given this frequency response: Frequency response

I need to find the maximum sensitivity for closed system for automatic regulation $ M_\text{s} $. I now that $$ M_\text{s} = \max|S(j\omega)| = \max\left|\frac{1}{1+G(wj)C(wj)}\right|$$ however $G(j\omega)$ and $C(j\omega)$ are not given.

The teacher has given us the following hint: $$[1+G(j\omega)C(j\omega)]^2 = -0.402^2 + (-0.506)^2$$ Although I get some idea on how to proceed with solving the task I don't get from where $$[1+G(j\omega)C(j\omega)]^2 = -0.402^2 + (-0.506)^2$$ comes.

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I think the given hints are not correct as they are written at the moment. Did your teacher mean $|1+G(j\omega)C(j\omega)|^2=(-0.402)^2+(-0.506)^2$? $\endgroup$ – MachineLearner May 8 '19 at 18:49
0
$\begingroup$

Consider the two points $s_\text{critical}=-1$ (can be interpreted as the vector from the origin to the critical point) and the point on the Nyquist curve $G(j\omega)C(j\omega)$ (can be interpreted as the vector from the origin to the Nyquist curve). I refer to them as points because they have real and imaginary components. We can also think of these points as vectors from the origin.

The vector $s_0$ connecting the critical point and the Nyquist curve can be calculated from

$$ s_\text{critical} + s_0 - G(j\omega)C(j\omega)=0$$

This equation can be interpreted as "go from the origin to the critical point" ($s_\text{critical}$) then "go from the critical point to the Nyquist curve" ($s_0$) then "go from the Nyquist curve to the origin" ($-G(j\omega)C(j\omega)$). If we add these vectors we will come back to the origin $0$. Note, that $|s_0|$ is just the distance between the critical point and the Nyquist curve.

We can rewrite the previous equation as: $$\implies s_0 = -s_\text{critical} +G(j\omega)C(j\omega)$$ $$\implies s_0 = -(-1) +G(j\omega)C(j\omega)$$ $$\implies s_0 = 1+G(j\omega)C(j\omega).$$

Hence, $s_0$ is the inverse of the sensitivity function. Instead of maximizing the magnitude of the sensitivity function $\max |S(j\omega)|$ we can as well minimize the inverse of the magnitude of the sensitivity function. This is equivalent to minimizing $|s_0|$. But $|s_0|$ is just the distance between the critical point $s_\text{critical}=-1$ and the Nyquist curve $G(j\omega)C(j\omega)$. So we need to find a point at the Nyquist curve $G(j\omega)C(j\omega)$ such that the distance to the critical point $s_\text{critical}=-1$ is minimized.

As we only have the graphical representation of the Nyquist curve we need to draw circles centered at the critical point $s_\text{critical}$ and increas the radius of the circle until the circle is a tangent (graphically) to the Nyquist curve. The point in which the circle touches the Nyquist curve is what we are looking for. Let us call this point $s_\text{min}=\sigma_\text{min}+j\omega_\text{min}$. Then $$M_\text{s}=\max|S(j\omega)|=\max\left|\dfrac{1}{1+G(j\omega)C(j\omega)} \right|$$ $$=\max \left|\dfrac{1}{s_0}\right|=\min|s_0|$$ $$=|\sigma_\text{min}+j\omega_\text{min}|=\sqrt{\sigma_\text{min}^2+\omega_\text{min}^2}.$$

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.