Q1 Prove that every simple subgroup of $S_4$ is abelian.

Q2 Using the above result, show that if $G$ is a nonabelian simple group then every proper subgroup of $G$ has index at least $5$.

My attempt

For Q1:

$|S_4| = 4\cdot3\cdot2 = 2^3 \cdot 3$.

One can exhibit all possible orders of subgroups of $S_4$ and eliminate subgroups according to the requirement that the subgroup is simple.

For example, any subgroup of order $2\cdot 3$ is not simple so needs not to be considered.

Then it might be possible to show that all remaining subgroups are abelian using results like a group of order $p^2$, where $p$ is a prime, is abelian.

For Q2

I think Cayley's Theorem is involved and I should probably consider the quotient of $G$ on a proper subgroup of $G$. But since $G$ is simple, the quotient is not a group. And I don't really know where to go from here.

My question

For Q1, I'm not sure that the above approach would work and even if it does, I feel like it is too cumbersome and there might be a more principled and more concise way.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

  • $\begingroup$ Please ask one question at a time. $\endgroup$ – Shaun May 5 '19 at 18:15
  • $\begingroup$ @Shaun Given that the second question relies heavily on the result of the first question, I do not see the need to break them into two separate posts. $\endgroup$ – msd15213 May 5 '19 at 18:17
  • $\begingroup$ Fair enough :) ${}$ $\endgroup$ – Shaun May 5 '19 at 18:18
  • $\begingroup$ @Shaun thanks ;) $\endgroup$ – msd15213 May 5 '19 at 18:19

For the first question, every simple non-abelian group has order at least $60$, and hence cannot be a subgroup of $S_4$, which has only $24$ elements.

Reference: $G$ is non abelian simple group of order $<100$ then $G\cong A_5$

For the second question, if $G$ is a simple group with a subgroup of index $n>1$, then $G$ injects into the symmetric group $S_n$.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I think the result you are using to answer the first question is more advanced than the question itself. $\endgroup$ – Derek Holt May 5 '19 at 15:16
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @DerekHolt True, but on the other hand we only need to look for the cases of divisors of $24$, which are included in the other answer, too. So we do not need the "advanced cases". The case $n=24$ is discussed in detail, too. $\endgroup$ – Dietrich Burde May 5 '19 at 15:17
  • $\begingroup$ @DietrichBurde I looked at the other question you referred to and it's quite some work lol. But thanks I think I will spend some time on understanding that question. $\endgroup$ – msd15213 May 5 '19 at 15:36
  • $\begingroup$ @DietrichBurde About your answer to my second question, though. Could you please give some details on the specific map that we can construct from $G$ to $S_n$? I am trouble finding one. Thanks. $\endgroup$ – msd15213 May 5 '19 at 15:37
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @mkmlp You only have to look at a few cases, the divisors of $24$. As for $n=2,4,8$, these groups are nilpotent, hence not simple. For the injection to $S_n$ see the answer here. $\endgroup$ – Dietrich Burde May 5 '19 at 15:37

For the record, here is an elementary way of doing the first part - you might have another way of doing order $6$. It avoids any analysis of what the subgroups of order $8$ and $12$ actually are, but shows that if they exist, they have proper normal subgroups and therefore aren't simple.

The order of a subgroup is a factor of the order of the group.

Possible subgroup orders for $S_4$ are $12, 8, 6, 4,3,2$

The only groups of order $4,3,2$ are abelian.

A subgroup of order $6$ will contain an element of order $3$ and this will generate a normal subgroup (since the subgroup will have index $2$).

A subgroup of order $8$ will contain an odd permutation of order $2$ or $4$, and the even permutations will form a proper normal subgroup. (There aren't enough even permutations of order $2$ or $4$ to make a group of even permutations of order $8$)

A subgroup of order $12$ will either contain an odd permutation (in which case the even permutations form a proper normal subgroup) or will be all even permutations in which case the elements $e, (12)(34), (13)(24), (14)(23)$ will form a proper normal subgroup (union of conjugacy classes closed under multiplication and inverse).

The second part is covered by a link you have already been given.

  • 3
    $\begingroup$ You have missed out $24$ and $1$ from your list of possible orders of subgroups. $1$ is trivial, but you need to deal with $24$. Of course that just means showing that $S_4$ itself is not simple. $\endgroup$ – Derek Holt May 5 '19 at 16:14
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @DerekHolt I was aware I hadn't dealt with those cases - you are right, of course, I should at least have done $24$ for which the even permutations form a normal subgroup. $\endgroup$ – Mark Bennet May 5 '19 at 17:01

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.