Given a closed $n$-manifold $M$, Poincare duality equips us with an isomorphism: $$H_k(M)\cong H^{n-k}(M)$$ Here I'm speaking of singular homology with coeffecient in $\mathbb{Z}_2$.

Suppose now $M$ has a triangulation $K$. Then clearly, we have a similar Poincare isomorphism as above for $K$ as well. In fact, even more can be said: there exists a polyhedral dual structure $K^{\vee}$ of $K$ which gives an isomorphism already at the level of (co)chain complexes: $$C_k(K^{\vee})\cong C^{n-k}(K)$$ (in order to be safe let's further assume we are considering smooth manifolds so stuff as https://mathoverflow.net/questions/194297/dual-cell-structures-on-manifolds do not occur)

My question is:

Is there an isomorphism of the form $C_k(K^{\vee})\cong C^{n-k}(K)$ even when $K$ is not necessarily a triangulation of $M$, but instead only homotopy equivalent $M$

I'll remark, that I'm in fact interested in Poincare-Lefschetz duality (i.e for manifolds with boundary) but thought it is better to start from here. Furthermore, I'm in particular interested in the case where $K$ is the nerve of some "good cover" of $M$ (and thus homotopy equivalent from the nerve lemma)


Your question is not very precise, but I would say the answer is no. Consider $M$ to be the $0$-manifold given by the singleton. Take the simplicial complex given by the simplest triangulation of $[0,1]$ (two vertices, one edge), which satisfies $M \simeq [0,1]$. Then the cellular complex of $K$ is $C_0(K) = \mathbb{F}_2^2$ and $C_1(K) = \mathbb{F}_2$. There is no triangulation $K^\vee$ such that $C^0(K^\vee) = \mathbb{F}_2^2$ and $C^{-1}(K^\vee) = \mathbb{F}_2$.

  • $\begingroup$ I agree that my question is not very precise.. I wasn't aware of how problematic it is to construct a dual polyhedral structure to some abstract simplicial complex. Even for a triangulation of a manifold with boundary there are subtleties to deal with. I assume that's your point there right? But then I must ask, in your answer what do you mean by $K^\vee$? do you mean some standard construction of a dual complex for a triangulation of a manifold with boundary, one which gives a Lefschetz type duality? $\endgroup$ – Itamar Vigi Apr 2 at 13:49
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @ItamarVigi For a manifold with boundary, in general you would want an isomorphism $C_*(K) \cong C^{n-*}(K^\vee, \partial K^\vee)$ (this is Poincaré–Lefschetz duality). Here in my answer, $K^\vee$ is just a notation: what I am saying is that there is no cell complex $X$ such that $C^{-1}(X) = \mathbb{F}_2$. There is never anything in negative degrees. $\endgroup$ – Najib Idrissi Apr 2 at 13:51
  • $\begingroup$ Thank you for pointing out the absurdity of what I'm looking for. $\endgroup$ – Itamar Vigi Apr 4 at 8:12

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.