My preliminary working suggests that this is false but the book I'm following (Real Analysis : Theory of Measure and Integration by James Yeh) suggests it's true. From experience, it's more likely that the author is correct and so I'm asking where did I go wrong?

For reference, here's the quoted text where the relevant part is highlighted:

Source of confusion.

I decided to verify myself (below) if indeed $\sigma(\mathfrak{C})\cap A$ is a $\sigma$-algebra of subsets of $A$:

$\sigma(\mathfrak{C}) \cap A = \{F \cap A: F\in \mathfrak{C}\}$

My first thought was to check if $A \in \mathfrak{C}$ because this implies $A \in \sigma(\mathfrak{C}) \cap A $ which fulfils one of the conditions of being a $\sigma$-algebra. I decided to investigate a naive case to see if this is always true below:

  • let $X = \{1,2,3\}$, $\mathfrak{C}$ = $\{\{1\}\} \subset 2^{X}$, $A = \{1,3\} \subset X$.

    Then clearly, $A = \{1,3\} \notin \sigma(\mathfrak{C}) = \sigma(\{\{1\}\}) = \{\emptyset, \{1,2,3\}, \{1\}, \{2,3\}\}$.

What I got from that is that it's not guaranteed that a subset $A$ of $X$ would be contained in a $\sigma$-algebra of subsets of an arbitrary collection $\mathfrak{C}$ of $X$.

And this is where I've come stuck. Any help would be appreciated!


I don't know why I didn't think of the obvious $X\cap A$...


Nowhere does the book say that $A \in \sigma (\mathbb C)$. Is says that $\sigma (\mathbb C) \cap A$ is a sigma algebra of subsets of $A$. First note that this contains $A$ because $A=X\cap A$ and $X \in \sigma (\mathbb C)$. If $A_n \in \sigma (\mathbb C) \cap A$ for $n=1,2,...$ then $A_n= C_n \cap A$ with $C_n \in \sigma (\mathbb C)$ and $\cap_n A_n =\cap_n C_n \cap A$ so $\cap_n A_n \in \sigma (\mathbb C) \cap A$. can you verify closure under complements? Remenber to take complements in $A$, not in $X$.

| cite | improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.