1
$\begingroup$

I've got ${\bf v} = x^2\partial_x$, and I'm trying to find $\exp(\varepsilon{\bf v})$, but I'm having some trouble.

If I define ${\bf v}^{n+1} = {\bf v}{\bf v}^n$ then I get a different outcome to ${\bf v}^{n+1} = {\bf v}^n{\bf v}$.

For example:

$${\bf v}^2 = {\bf vv} = (x^2\partial_x)(x^2\partial_x) = x^2(\partial_xx^2)\partial_x = x^2(2x)\partial_x = 2x^3\partial_x$$

$${\bf v}^3 = {\bf v}{\bf v}^2 =(x^2\partial_x)(2x^3\partial_x)=x^2(\partial_x2x^3)\partial_x = x^2(6x^2)\partial_x = 6x^4\partial_x$$ $${\bf v}^3 = {\bf v}^2{\bf v} = (2x^3\partial_x)(x^2\partial_x) = 2x^3(\partial_xx^2)\partial_x = 2x^3(2x)\partial_x = 4x^4\partial_x$$

Using ${\bf v}^{n+1} = {\bf v}{\bf v}^n$ gives $$\exp(\varepsilon {\bf v})x = \frac{x}{1-\varepsilon x}$$

While using ${\bf v}^{n+1} = {\bf v}^n{\bf v}$ gives $$\exp(\varepsilon {\bf v})x = \frac{x}{2}(1+\mathrm e^{2\varepsilon x})$$

In both cases, when $\varepsilon =0$, we get just $x$, i.e. the identity element. Also, in both cases, we get $$\lim_{\varepsilon \to 0} \frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm d\varepsilon} \exp(\varepsilon {\bf v})x = {\bf v}$$

The same ${\bf v} \in \mathfrak g$ can't possible generate two different flows, can it?

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Doesn't it seem odd to you that you are not getting iterates (i.e. nested compositions) of $\partial_x$? For instance, if $\mathbf{v} = \partial_x$, what should $\mathbf{v}^2$ be? $\endgroup$ – Eric Towers Mar 14 at 17:37
  • $\begingroup$ If ${\bf v} = \partial_x$ then I would say ${\bf v}^2 = (1\partial_x)(1\partial_x) = 1(\partial_x 1)\partial_x=0$. Similarly ${\bf v}^n =0$ for all $n \ge 2$, meaning that $\exp(\varepsilon {\bf v})x= (1+\varepsilon \partial_x)x=x+\varepsilon$, which is the correct flow. $\endgroup$ – Fly by Night Mar 14 at 18:16
  • $\begingroup$ And yet, "the derivative with respect to $x$ of the derivative with respect to $x$" is not the zero operator (without projection to first order operators). If $\mathbf{v} = \partial_x$, $\mathbf{v}^2 = \partial_x^2$, the second derivative with respect to $x$. (... which projects onto the zero vector on the subspace of first order differentials.) But in short, in your expression "$1(\partial_x 1) \partial_x$", you have made an error: the first $\partial_x$ acts on the rest of the expression; you should have "$1 \partial_x (1 \partial_x) = 1 (1 \partial_x^2 + 0 \partial_x)$". $\endgroup$ – Eric Towers Mar 15 at 14:03
1
$\begingroup$

If you apply the product rule carefully, you don't get two different answers. In your example, \begin{align*} \mathbf{v}(f(x)) &= (x^2 \partial_x)(f(x)) \\ &= x^2 f'(x) \text{, and }\\ \mathbf{v}^2(f(x)) &= (x^2 \partial_x)\left( (x^2 \partial_x)(f(x)) \right) \\ &= (x^2 \partial_x)\left( x^2 f'(x) \right) \\ &= x^2(2x f'(x) + x^2 f''(x) ) \text{, or } \\ \mathbf{v}^2(f(x)) &= \left((x^2 \partial_x) (x^2 \partial_x) \right) (f(x)) \\ &= (x^2(2x \partial_x + x^2 \partial_x^2))(f(x)) \\ &= x^2(2x f'(x) + x^2 f''(x) ) \end{align*} so we see $\mathbf{v}^2 = 2x^3 \partial_x + x^4 \partial_x^2$. Similarly, $\mathbf{v}^3 = 6 x^4 \partial_x + 6 x^5 \partial_x^2 + x^6 \partial_x^3$.

(Of course, if we're linearizing, we project onto the first term in both of those.)

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks for the reply. Am I right to think that ${\bf v}$ is best understood by its action on a function, i.e. ${\bf v}(f)$, and so "multiplying on the right" doesn't make sense. ${\bf v}[{\bf v}(f)]$ is fine, while $[{\bf v}(f)]{\bf v}$ doesn't make sense because it's not a function. Hence ${\bf v}^{n+1} = {\bf v}{\bf v}^n$ is the only way to go? $\endgroup$ – Fly by Night Mar 14 at 18:22
  • $\begingroup$ @FlybyNight : $[\mathbf{v}(f)]\mathbf{v}$ is an operator as much as $x^2 \partial_x$ is since $\mathbf{v}(f)$ is some function and the $\mathbf{v}$ on the right still has an open slot to consume a function. Note that I showed both $\mathbf{v}(\mathbf{v}(f))$ and $(\mathbf{v}(\mathbf{v}))(f)$ above, so both "wrap another $\mathbf{v}$ on the left" ($\mathbf{v} (\mathbf{v}^n(f))$) and "let $\mathbf{v}^n$ act on $\mathbf{v}(f)$" ($\mathbf{v}^n (\mathbf{v}(f))$), arriving at the same result both ways. $\endgroup$ – Eric Towers Mar 15 at 13:57
  • $\begingroup$ But ${\bf v}(f){\bf v}$ isn't a function, while ${\bf vv}(f)$ is. That's what I meant. $\endgroup$ – Fly by Night Mar 16 at 18:22
1
$\begingroup$

You are looking at the simplest Lie advective flow in perturbation theory (as applied in physics: QFT) and the workhorse example in the 19th century book of Georg Sheffer cited.

v generates a shift operator, and it pays to define suitable canonical coordinates, $$ y=-1/x, \qquad \Longrightarrow \qquad x^2 \partial_x=\partial_y , $$ so that you are shifting y by $\epsilon$, $$ e^{\epsilon \partial_y} ~~f(y)= f(y+\epsilon), $$ which reads
$$ e^{\epsilon x^2\partial_x} ~~g(x)= g\left(\frac{-1}{y+\epsilon}\right )=g\left (\frac{x}{1-\epsilon x}\right ), $$ a standard formula in the RG advection of QFT.

Your difficulties are traceable to your refusal to perform your Heaviside calculus manipulations of functions of differential operators with a "test-function" f(x) on the right, which keeps track of the proper chain rule action of noncommuting derivative operators.

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

The action of a vector field as a derivation on the space of functions means that it only makes sense to multiply on the left because ${\bf v}(f)$ is a function and so ${\bf v}[{\bf v}(f)]$ is also a function, while $[{\bf v}(f)]{\bf v}$ is a function times a vector field, i.e. a vector field.

The differential operator ${\bf v} = x^2\partial_x$ is best understood as differentiate with respect to $x$, and then multiply by $x^2$.

Applied to $x$, we get $x \mapsto 1 \mapsto x^2$, meaning ${\bf v}(x) = x^2$.

Applied to $x^2$, we get $x^2 \mapsto 2x \mapsto 2x^3$, meaning ${\bf v^2}(x) = 2x^3$.

Applied to $2x^3$, we get $2x^3 \mapsto 6x^2 \mapsto 6x^4$, meaning ${\bf v}^3(x) = 6x^4$.

In general, ${\bf v}^n(x) = n!x^{n+1}$, and so for all $|\varepsilon x|<1$ \begin{eqnarray*} \sum_{n \ge 0} \frac{\varepsilon^n}{n!}{\bf v}^n(x) &=& \sum_{n \ge 0} \frac{\varepsilon^n}{n!}n!x^{n+1} \\ \\ &=& x\sum_{n \ge 0} (\varepsilon x)^n \\ \\ &=& \frac{x}{1-\varepsilon x} \end{eqnarray*}

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.