If $x_1,x_2,\cdots$ are all positive solutions of the equation $\tan x-x=0$ Find value of:


My try:

The first solution will be in the interval $\left(\frac{\pi}{2}, \frac{3\pi}{2}\right)$ in which $\tan x$ is monotonic.

So the solution in that interval is given by $$x_1=\tan^{-1}(x_1)$$

So $$\cos(x_1)=\cos(\tan^{-1}(x_1))=\frac{1}{\sqrt{1+x_1^2}}$$



Any way to proceed here?


This reminds me of an old AoPS thread. Not exactly the same problem - that was $\sum_k \frac1{x_k^2}$ - but similar ideas should apply. Following my argument over there, we will try to find an analytic function with residues $\frac1{1+x_k^2}=\cos^2 x_k$ at its poles, which also decays in the right places (away from the real axis, and on the vertical segments we'll use). $$\text{Let }f(z) = \frac{z\sin z}{(z^2+1)(\sin z-z\cos z)}$$ This $f$ has poles at each $x_k$, at $0$, and at $\pm i$. Each of those poles are simple; this is clear for the $x_k$ and $\pm i$, and at zero $f(z)=\frac{z^2+O(z^4)}{(1+O(z^2))(z-\frac16z^3+O(z^5)-z+\frac12z^3+O(z^5))}=\frac{z^2+O(z^4)}{\frac13z^3+O(z^5)}=\frac3z+O(z)$.

Now, the residues. At a root $x_k$, we have $\sin x_k=x_k\cos x_k$, or $x_k=\tan x_k$. The residue of $f$ there is $$R(x_k) = \left.\frac{z\sin z}{z^2+1}\right|_{z=x_k}\cdot\left.\frac1{\frac{d}{dz}(\sin z-z\cos z)}\right|_{z=x_k} = \frac{x_k\sin x_k}{x_k^2+1}\cdot\frac1{x_k\sin x_k}=\frac1{x_k^2+1}$$ The residue $R(0)$ at zero is $3$ by our power series calculation above. The residues at $\pm i$ are $$R(\pm i) = \left.\frac{z\sin z}{\sin z-z\cos z}\right|_{z=\pm i}\cdot\left.\frac1{\frac{d}{dz}(z^2+1)}\right|_{z=\pm i} = \frac{\pm i}{1-\pm i\cot\pm i}\cdot \frac1{\pm 2i}=\frac1{2(1-\coth 1)}$$ using $\cos it=\cosh t$ and $\sin it=i\sinh t$ there.

And now, we build a contour integral to take advantage. Consider $I(N,M)=\int_C f(z)\,dz$, where $f$ is the rectangle with vertices at $N\pi+iM, -N\pi+iM, -N\pi-iM, N\pi-iM$ for some large $M$ and large integer $N$. For convenience, also rewrite $f(z)=\frac{z}{z^2+1}\cdot \frac1{1-z\cot z}$. Now, on a vertical segment $N\pi+iy$, $\cot z=\frac{\cos(N\pi)\cosh y}{i\cos(N\pi)\sinh y}=-i\coth y$ and $$f(N\pi+iy)= \frac{N\pi + iy}{N^2\pi^2-y^2+1+2N\pi yi}\cdot \frac1{N\pi i+1-y\coth y}$$ As long as $M \le N\pi$, $N^2\pi^2>y^2$ and $|z^2+1|>z^2$ on the vertical segment. The first term is then less than $|z|^{-1}<\frac1{N\pi}$ in absolute value, and the second term is less than $\frac1{N\pi}$ in absolute value. Integrating that product over a length of $2M$, we get at most $\frac{2M}{(N\pi)^2}\le\frac{2}{N\pi}$.

On the horizontal segments, we have that $\cot (x+iy)$ tends to $-i$ uniformly as $y\to\infty$ and to $i$ uniformly as $y\to-\infty$. Choose $M$ so that it's within $\epsilon$ on the segments $x+\pm iM$, and we have $$|f(z)|\le \frac{|z|}{|z|^2-1}\cdot\frac1{(1-\epsilon)|z|-1}$$ By limit comparison to $\frac1{M^2}$, the integral of this is at most a constant times $\frac{N}{M^2}$. As long as $N$ isn't too much larger than $M$ - say, $M=N\pi$ to match the other direction - this goes to zero.

Therefore, $\lim_{N\to\infty}I(N,N\pi) = 0$. And now, we calculate the integral by the residue theorem. Inside the contour, there are $2N+1$ poles: $0,i,-i,x_1,-x_1,\dots,x_{N-1},-x_{N-1}$. The residue at each $x_k$ is equal to that at each $-x_k$, and $$I(N,N\pi) = 2\pi i\left(3+\frac1{2(1-\coth 1)}+\frac1{2(1-\coth 1)} + \sum_{k=1}^{N-1}\frac1{x_k^2+1}+\sum_{k=1}^{N-1}\frac1{x_k^2+1}\right)$$ $$0 = 3+\frac1{1-\coth 1}+2\sum_{k=1}^{\infty}\frac1{x_k^2+1}$$ $$\sum_{k=1}^{\infty}\frac1{x_k^2+1} = -\frac12\left(\frac{\sinh 1}{\sinh 1-\cosh 1}+3\right)=\frac12\left(e\cdot\frac{e-e^{-1}}{2}-3\right)=\frac{e^2}{4}-\frac74$$

| cite | improve this answer | |
  • $\begingroup$ Beautiful solution and surprising result ! $\endgroup$ – Claude Leibovici Mar 8 '19 at 5:11

We will use techniques similar to those used in this answer.

Consider the function $$\newcommand{\Res}{\operatorname*{Res}}\newcommand{\Im}{\operatorname{Im}} f(z)=\frac{\frac{z^2}{1+z^2}}{\tan(z)-z}\tag1 $$ $f$ has $3$ singularities other than those in $S=\{z_n\in\mathbb{C}\setminus\{0\}:\tan(z_n)=z_n\}$: $\{0,+i,-i\}$.

Near $z=0$, we have $\tan(z)=z+\frac{z^3}3+O\!\left(z^5\right)$, thus, $$ \begin{align} f(z) &=\frac{z^2\left(1+O\!\left(z^2\right)\right)}{\frac{z^3}3\left(1+O\!\left(z^2\right)\right)}\\ &=\frac3z+O(z)\tag2 \end{align} $$ Therefore, $$ \Res_{z=0}(f(z))=3\tag3 $$

Near $z=i$, we have $\frac1{1+z^2}=\frac1{z+i}\frac1{z-i}$, thus, $$ \begin{align} f(z) &=\frac1{z-i}\frac{\frac{i^2}{2i}}{\tan(i)-i}+O(1)\\ &=\frac1{z-i}\frac1{2(\tanh(1)-1)}+O(1)\tag4 \end{align} $$ Therefore, $$ \Res_{z=i}(f(z))=\frac1{2(\tanh(1)-1)}\tag5 $$

Since $f$ is odd, $$ \Res_{z=-i}(f(z))=\frac1{2(\tanh(1)-1)}\tag6 $$

Near $z=z_n$, where $z_n\in S$, we have $$ \begin{align} f(z) &=\frac1{z-z_n}\frac{\frac{z_n^2}{1+z_n^2}(z-z_n)}{\tan(z)-z}+O(1)\\ &=\frac1{z-z_n}\frac{\frac{\tan^2(z_n)}{1+\tan^2(z_n)}}{\sec^2(z_n)-1}+O(1)\\[6pt] &=\frac{\cos^2(z_n)}{z-z_n}+O(1)\tag7 \end{align} $$ Therefore, $$ \Res_{z=z_n}(f(z))=\cos^2(z_n)\tag8 $$

For each $k\in\mathbb{Z}$, $$ |\tan(k\pi+iy)|=|\tanh(y)|\lt1\tag9 $$ Furthermore, for $\Im(z)\gt\pi$, $$ |\tan(z)|\le\coth(|\Im(z)|)\le\coth(\pi)\tag{10} $$ Therefore, on the square of side $2k\pi$ centered at $0$, we have $|\tan(z)|\le\coth(\pi)$. Thus, on those squares, $$ \begin{align} f(z) &=\frac{1+O\!\left(\frac1{z^2}\right)}{-z\left(1+O\!\left(\frac1z\right)\right)}\\ &=-\frac1z+O\!\left(\frac1{z^2}\right)\tag{11} \end{align} $$ Therefore, the sum of all the residues is $-1$.

Pulling together $(3)$, $(5)$, $(6)$, $(8)$, and $(11)$, we get $$ -1=3+\frac1{\tanh(1)-1}+\sum_{z_n\in S}\cos^2(z_n)\tag{12} $$ gives $$ \begin{align} \sum_{z_n\in S}\cos^2(z_n) &=-4-\frac1{\tanh(1)-1}\\ &=\frac{e^2-7}2\tag{13} \end{align} $$ This includes both positive and negative solutions of $\tan(x)=x$. Thus, the sum over the positive solutions is $$ \sum_{z_n\in S^+}\cos^2(z_n)=\frac{e^2-7}4\tag{14} $$

| cite | improve this answer | |

If you look at the MathWorld page "du Bois-Reymond Constants", you will see that $S$ is one half of the second du Bois-Reymond constant, $C_2$. It is somewhat astonishing that an explicit formula for $C_2$ is available in terms of $e$: $$ C_2 = \frac{e^2 - 7}{2} \approx 0.194528049465 $$ Consequently, $$ S = \frac{e^2 - 7}{4} \approx 0.097264024733 $$ No hint of a proof is given there, but perhaps one of the references will help.

| cite | improve this answer | |
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ For a surprise, this is a surprise ! $\endgroup$ – Claude Leibovici Mar 8 '19 at 5:10
  • $\begingroup$ Years ago, I saw a remark in the Schaum's Outline Series numerical Analysis book that $\sum_{k=1}^\infty{1\over x_k^2}={1\over10}$ and I astonished myself by proving it. If I remember correctly, I used the product expansion of $\sin{z}-z\cos{z}$ so perhaps some extension of this idea would work here. $\endgroup$ – saulspatz Mar 8 '19 at 18:30

To me, what you wrote is very correct but I am not sure that an explicit solution does exist for the summation you are looking for.

The positive solutions of the equation $x=\tan(x)$ can be written explicitely in series form as $$x_k=q-\frac 1q-\frac 2{3\,q^3}-\frac {13}{15\,q^5}-\frac {146}{105\,q^7}-\frac {781}{315\,q^9}-\frac {16328}{3465\,q^{11}}-\cdots\qquad \text{where}\qquad q=(2k+1)\frac \pi 2$$ (have a look here).

If we use $x_k \sim q$, we can get a lower bound for the sum $$S_0=\sum_{k=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{1+x_k^2}>\frac{(4 +\pi ^2) \tanh (1)-8}{2 \left(4+\pi ^2\right)}\approx 0.0923966$$ If we use $x_k \sim q-\frac 1q$, a second approximation is (this had been given by a CAS) $$S_1=\sum_{k=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{1+x_k^2}>\frac{3 e^2+2 \sqrt{3} e \sin \left(\sqrt{3}\right)-3}{6 \left(1+e^2+2 e \cos \left(\sqrt{3}\right)\right)}-\frac{4 \pi ^2}{16-4 \pi ^2+\pi ^4}\approx 0.0971218$$ For better approximations, I have not been able to get any closed form and only numerical evaluations have been made showinga value just a little greater than $S_1$.

Using all terms of the given expansion and computing, the sum is $\approx 0.0972640$.

| cite | improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.