I came across a question from another forum - find the $x$ in the following diagram: enter image description here

I managed to deduce an equation from the following diagram: enter image description here

which is: $\dfrac{\sqrt{5}(\cos \theta - \sin \theta)}{3\sqrt{2}}=\tan \theta$

and I know the answer (from WolframAlpha) is: $\cos \theta= \dfrac{3}{\sqrt{10}}$

but I'm not able to deduce the answer myself, any ideas?

By the way, $x=2\sqrt{5}$, which can be easily deduced by:


I also tried to solve the original question geometrically: enter image description here

Somehow, I managed to figure out that $y=3$ in the above diagram, but I can't prove it either.

  • $\begingroup$ Did you already find $x$ from the given information? $\endgroup$ – Toby Mak Mar 2 '19 at 2:48
  • $\begingroup$ @TobyMak, $x=2\sqrt{5}$ $\endgroup$ – lochiwei Mar 2 '19 at 2:51
  • $\begingroup$ I understand now; you're just trying to simplify $\frac{\sqrt{5}(\cos \theta - \sin \theta)}{3\sqrt{2}}=\tan \theta$ right? $\endgroup$ – Toby Mak Mar 2 '19 at 2:54
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ What program did you use to draw and label the triangles? Or is it done by hand? $\endgroup$ – JavaMan Mar 2 '19 at 3:39
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @JavaMan I used Paper to draw those diagrams, and yes, by hand. $\endgroup$ – lochiwei Mar 2 '19 at 3:44

Probably not the most elegant solution.

If you use the tangent half-angle substitution $x=\tan \left(\frac{\theta }{2}\right)$, you end with $$\sqrt{10}\, x^4-2 \left(6-\sqrt{10}\right)\, x^3-2 \sqrt{10} \,x^2-2 \left(6+\sqrt{10}\right) x+\sqrt{10}=0 \tag 1$$

Using the method for quartic equations, there are two real roots and one of them is $$x=\sqrt{10}-3\implies \cos(\theta)=\frac{3}{\sqrt{10}}$$ The other roots are really messy.


Defining $c := \cos\theta$ and $s := \sin\theta$, we can write $$c^2\sqrt{5} = s\left(3 \sqrt{2} + c\sqrt{5}\right) \tag{1}$$ Squaring, re-writing $s^2 = 1-c^2$, and re-arranging, $$10 c^4 + 6 c^3 \sqrt{10} + 13 c^2 - 6c \sqrt{10} - 18 = 0 \tag{2}$$

At this point, if we had the presence of mind to identify $10$ as $\sqrt{10}^2$ and $13$ as $-27 + 4\sqrt{10}^2$, then (defining $r:=\sqrt{10}$) we could gather terms and factor

$$\begin{align} 0 &= r^2 c^4 +\left(-3r + 9 r\right)c^3 + (-27+4r^2)c^2 +(-12r+ 6r)c - 18 \\[4pt] &= \left(r^2 c^4 - 3rc^3\right) + \left(9 rc^3 -27c^2\right)+\left(4r^2c^2 -12rc\right)+ \left(6rc - 18\right)\\[4pt] &= \left(r c - 3 \right) \left( rc^3 + 9 c^2 +4 r c + 6 \right) \tag{3} \end{align}$$ (That is, we have factored over $\mathbb{Q}\left[\sqrt{10}\right]$.) The first factor yields the target root, $\cos\theta = 3/\sqrt{10}$. (Note that the second factor obviously has no positive solutions.)

Without such intuition, but with a suspicion that the $\sqrt{10}$s were impeding progress to a reasonably-nice solution, we could write $(2)$ as $$10 c^4 + 13 c^2-18 = 6c\sqrt{10}\left(1-c^2\right) \tag{4}$$ Now, squaring will eliminate the pesky $\sqrt{10}$, and we have $$100 c^8 - 100 c^6 + 529 c^4 - 828 c^2 + 324 = 0 \tag{5}$$ From here, old-fashioned factoring gives

$$\left(10 c^2 - 9\right) (10 c^6 - c^4 + 52c^2 -36 ) = 0\tag{6}$$

Again, the first factor gives the target root, $\cos\theta=3/\sqrt{10}$ (as well as a newly-introduced extraneous root, $\cos\theta=-3/\sqrt{10}$). It's not clear that the second factor has no valid roots; indeed, Mathematica gives the positive solution $\cos\theta = 0.80501\ldots$ (amid otherwise negative or non-real candidates), but we can check that it doesn't satisfy $(1)$.


If we start with this diagram:

enter image description here

we can deduce that:

$$ \overline{CE}=\sqrt{(k+1)^2+1} \\ \overline{DE}=\frac{1}{k+1}\sqrt{(k+1)^2+1} \\ \frac{\overline{DE}}{\overline{BC}} =\frac{\frac{1}{k+1}\sqrt{(k+1)^2+1}}{k} =\frac{\sqrt{(k+1)^2+1}}{k(k+1)} =\frac{\sqrt{5}}{3\sqrt{2}} \\ 5k^2(k+1)^2=18(k+1)^2+18 \\ 5k^4+10k^3-13k^2-36k-36=0 \\ (k-2)(5k^3+20k^2+27k+18)=0 $$

hence we have only one positive solution $k=2$.

Now we can deduce any segment length on the diagram from this solution.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.