Note: by "infinitely many", I'm confident I always mean $\beth_1$ many herein.

We can easily show the quaternions contain infinitely many copies of $\Bbb C$ because, given any unit vector $\in\Bbb R^3$ of components $b,\,c,\,d$, $\Bbb R[h]$ is isomorphic to $\Bbb C$ with $h:=bi+cj+dk$. Sure, these aren't "independent" copies of $\Bbb C$ in the same way $\Bbb R[i],\,\Bbb R[j],\,\Bbb R[k]$ are. But it's still of interest because, for example, a family of tensor products over matrices using different copies of $\Bbb C$ provide an easy definition of a determinant, even though general matrices of quaternions prohibit this. For example, if $A_1,\,\cdots,\,A_n$ are matrices and $O$ denotes a contextually appropriate zero matrix, the block matrix $$\left(\begin{array}{cccc} A_{1} & O & \cdots & O\\ O & A_{2} & \cdots & O\\ \vdots & \vdots & \ddots & O\\ O & O & \cdots & A_{n} \end{array}\right)$$can be said to have determinant $\prod_l\det A_l$. The order is important, but one in particular is natural.

I may be overlooking some details of the above benefit to arbitrarily many copies of $\Bbb C$ in $\Bbb H$, wherein a very rich commuting family of matrices is constructed, but my question isn't about that. I'm wondering how we'd prove there are infinitely many copies of $\Bbb H$ in $\Bbb O$. (Again, block matrices provide a benefit, in this case inheriting the associativity of the $A_l$.) I suspect a proof exists that admits the following sketch:

  • In $\Bbb O$, create some $h_1,\,h_2$ each analogous to $i\in\Bbb C$, generating an associative algebra and satisfying $h_1h_2=-h_2h_1$;
  • Note that any such pair of square roots of $-1$ can model the quaternions viz. $i=h_1,\,j=h_2,\,k=h_1h_2$;
  • Show the above can be done in infinitely many different ways.

Of course there are infinitely many ways to choose the pair $(h_1,\,h_2)$, but $\Bbb R[h_1,\,h_2]$ won't always be a different set for such pairs. That's why I suspect the proof requires a few clever i-dotting t-crosses.

  • $\begingroup$ In fact, we can identify the space of copies of $\Bbb H$ in $\Bbb O$ with the compact Riemannian symmetric space of type $G$, namely, $G_2 / SO(4)$; in particular this space has dimension $8$. $\endgroup$ – Travis Willse Feb 2 at 5:29

Yes. One can show the following 2 things:

  1. Any octonion $x$ not in $\mathbb R$ generates a subalgebra $A$ isomorphic to $\mathbb C$.

  2. For any octonion $y$, the subalgebra $B$ generated by $x$ and $y$ is associative.

This should be covered in treatments of composition algebra, e.g. it is probably in Springer-Veldkamp.

Hence if we take $y$ outside of $A$ in 1, by Frobenius' classification of $\mathbb R$-division algebras, $B$ must be isomorphic to $\mathbb H$ (a priori it may not be obvious $B$ is division, but you can get this a posteriori from Frobenius' theorem as adjoining inverses to $B$, which necessarily lie in $\mathbb O$, still gives you an associative algebra), and thus the 4-dimensional space spanned by $1, x, y, xy$. Since no finite collection of $\mathbb R^4$ subspaces of $\mathbb R^8$ cover $\mathbb R^8$, you get infinitely many copies of $\mathbb H$.

To say that you get (at least) the cardinality of the continuum copies of $\mathbb H$, it suffices to show

  1. For any nonreal octonion $z$, there is a subalgebra $B \simeq \mathbb H$ as above not containing $z$.

To see this, take $x$ as above not in $\mathbb R z$. Then $x$ and $z$ generate a space $B' \simeq \mathbb H$. Simply take $y \not \in B'$. Then the algebra $B$ generated by $x$ and $y$ cannot contain $B'$ since $B \ne B'$ but $\dim B = \dim B'$.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ For what it's worth, property (2) is called alternativity. $\endgroup$ – Travis Willse Feb 2 at 5:30
  • $\begingroup$ I upvoted first and only later noticed this messes up your perfectly round reputation of 2000. I'm sorry $\endgroup$ – Vincent Mar 19 at 22:55

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.