4
$\begingroup$

The question is "State with a reason whether there are any solutions to |12-5x| = -2x+3"

I can clearly see there are no solutions when I graph it but I've learned to solve these questions doing the following:

$|x| = y$

$x = y $

$x = -y $

When doing this here, I get:

$|12 - 5x| = -2x + 3$

$12 - 5x = -2x + 3$

$12 - 5x = 2x - 3$

Solving for each of these I get $(3, -3)$ -> So no solution here as the y is negative - makes sense

But I also get $(15/7, 9/7)$ which would, in theory be an intersection.

Obviously this isn't right but algebraically I'm having trouble with the intuition.

Hope someone can help!

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Welcome to the website. Please use Mathjax to typeset your equations for better presentation. In this case, you need only enclose your equations by the $ symbol. $\endgroup$ – Shubham Johri Jan 10 at 16:16
2
$\begingroup$

Note that $|12-5x|=\begin{cases}12-5x,&12-5x\ge0\\5x-12,&12-5x<0\end{cases}$

When $12-5x\ge0$, you get $12-5x=3-2x\implies x=3,12-5x=-3<0$, which is inconsistent with the initial assumption that $12-5x\ge0$.

When $12-5x<0$, you get $12-5x=2x-3\implies x=15/7,12-5x=9/7>0$, which is inconsistent with the initial assumption that $12-5x<0$.

$\endgroup$
2
$\begingroup$

You can divide the study into two cases:

Case 1

\begin{cases} 12-5x\ge0 \\[4px] 12-5x=-2x+3 \end{cases} that becomes \begin{cases} x\le 12/5 \\[4px] x=3 \end{cases} No solution.

Case 2

\begin{cases} 12-5x<0 \\[4px] 5x-12=-2x+3 \end{cases} that becomes \begin{cases} x>12/5 \\[4px] x=15/7 \end{cases} No solution.

Where did you go wrong?

In order that $|x|=y$ holds, it's necessary that $y\ge0$. For $x=15/7$, you have $$ -2x+3=-\frac{30}{7}+3=-\frac{9}{7}<0 $$

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

So, what you've learned is... I'm not going to say wrong, exactly, but more "only occasionally right". More specifically, $|x| = y$ if and only if one of the following holds:

  1. $x \geq 0$ and $x = y$.
  2. $x \leq 0$ and $x = -y$.

You have considered only the second half of each of these.

Now, let's solve your question: if $12 - 5x > 0$, then we require $12 - 5x = -2x + 3$. Rearranging that, we have $x = 3$. But with $x = 3$, we have $12 - 5x = -3 < 0$, so we are not in this case, and this is not a solution.

On the other hand, if $12 - 5x < 0$, then we require $12 - 5x = 2x - 3$, but then $x = \frac{9}{7}$, and $12 - 5x = \frac{39}{7} > 0$, so again, we are not in this case, and this is not a solution.

Thus, we have no solutions.

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

A correct start would be: $$|x|=x\text{ if }x\geq0\text{ and }|x|=-x\text{ if }x\leq0$$

Then equation $|x|=y$ splits up in two cases that must be discerned:

  • $x=y$ if $x\geq0$
  • $-x=y$ if $x\leq0$

Applying that correctly on the problem you mention gives:

  • $12-5x=-2x+3$ if $12-5x\geq0$
  • $5x-12=-2x+3$ if $12-5x\leq0$

The first gives at first had solution $x=3$ but it must rejected because $12-5\cdot3\ngeq0$.

The second gives at first had solution $x=\frac{15}7$ but it must rejected because $12-5\cdot\frac{15}7\nleq0$.

The final conclusion is that there are no solutions.

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

Note that for an absolute value function, you have:

$$f(x) = \vert x\vert = \begin{cases} x; \quad x \geq 0 \\ -x; \quad x < 0 \end{cases}$$

You haven’t put any emphasis on the conditions (that $\vert x\vert = x$ if $x \geq 0$ and that $\vert x\vert = -x$ if $x < 0$), which are extremely important.

In $\vert 12-5x\vert = -2x+3$, you make two distinct cases, but you must also remember the constraints:

$$\begin{cases} \ 12-5x = -2x+3 ; \quad \color{blue}{12-5x \geq 0} \\ 12-5x = -(-2x+3) = 4x-3; \quad \color{blue}{12-5x < 0} \end{cases}$$

For case one, ignoring the extra condition, you get $x = 3$. Plug it in the condition given and see if it is met:

$$12-5x \overset{?}{\geq} 0; \quad x = 3$$

$$12-5(3) = 12-15 = -3 \ngeq 0$$

This is false, and is also reflected when the RHS becomes negative, as you correctly spotted.

For case two, ignoring the condition, you get $x = \frac{15}{7}$. Plug it in the condition given and see if it is met:

$$12-5x \overset{?}{<} 0; \quad x = \frac{15}{7}$$

$$12-5\left(\frac{15}{7}\right) = 12-\frac{75}{7} = \frac{9}{7} \nless 0$$

This is also false, so the equation has no solution.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.