Consider the following problem:

A prepared student answers correctly to each oral question independently from one another with probability $0.95$. If, however, he is not prepared, he answers correctly with probability $0.1$. $80$% of the students taking the exam are prepared. Donald answers wrong to the first question. What is the probability he is prepared? Donald asks his teacher if he can have a second question. Determine the probability that he will answer correctly.

So, as far as the first question is concerned, we easily compute:$$P(P|W_1)=\frac{P(P)\cdot P(W_1|P)}{P(P)\cdot P(W_1|P)+P(P^c)\cdot P(W_1|P^c)}=\frac{0.8\cdot 0.05}{0.8\cdot 0.05+0.2\cdot 0.9}$$ according to Bayes's theorem. I'm actually concerned with the second question. I approached it making the following thought: since we are given that each student answers each question independently of one another, it shouldn't matter whether Donald answered wrong or right to the first question in oder to answer correctly to the second question (I'm assuming from the text that $P(R_2|W_1)=P(R_2)$). Thus I computed:$$P(R_2)=P(P)\cdot P(R_2|P)+P(P^c)\cdot P(R_2|P^c)=0.8\cdot 0.95+0.2\cdot 0.1$$which is $0.78$. According to my teacher, right answer is:$$P(R_2|W_1)=\frac{P(W_1R_2|P)\cdot P(P)+P(W_1R_2|P^c)\cdot P(P^c)}{P(W_1)}$$$P(W_1)$ is computed as before in the previous equation. Whereas the numerator is:$$P(W_1|P)\cdot P(R_2|P)\cdot P(P)+P(W_1|P^c)\cdot P(R_2|P^c)\cdot P(P^c)$$this gives $0.25$ as overall result, which is way lower than mine. He's assuming that each $R_i$, $W_i$ is idependent from each other knowing that either event $P$ or $P^c$ occured. Thus he's assuming, if I'm not mistaken, conditional independence. So, what is the correct way to solve this problem? Which is the best approach? What will you assume reading that text? I would probably stick with my solution, since it's weird that one answers independently of each question only if he's either prepared or not.

  • $\begingroup$ Suppose someone is asked $99$ questions and answers wrong on - let's say 90 of them. What is the probability that he answers correct on a $100$-th question? I don't think $0.78$, do you? $\endgroup$ – drhab Dec 24 '18 at 11:45
  • $\begingroup$ mmh, but this reasoning doesnt apply to the coin. If I flip it 99 times and say, i get 99 heads, the probability i get a tail is always 0.5, doesnt matter what happened before. Yeah its true that intuitively 0.78 is high, because you expect him to be a bad student :) $\endgroup$ – Dude Dec 24 '18 at 11:54
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ It will give us at least great doubts about the fairness of the coin ;-). The result of first question(s) give us information that must be applied. That's what your teacher did. $\endgroup$ – drhab Dec 24 '18 at 11:56
  • $\begingroup$ @Dude You must use the proability that the particular student is prepared, not the $0.8$ , which is the probability that a random student is prepared. $\endgroup$ – Peter Dec 24 '18 at 12:32

The word "independently" here is somewhat hard to interpret.

I expect it is meant to mean that, for any given student, the two events " getting questions $A$, $B$ right" are independent. However, this does not apply to an unspecified student.

Let's work this out. You computed the probability that a randomly selected student gets the first question right. That is $.78$ and, of course, this is also the probability that this student gets the second question right, assuming we don't know how they did on the first one. But what's the probability that they get both right? Well, by the same methodology you used, we see that this is $$.8\times .95^2+.2\times .1^2=.724$$

But of course $$.78^2=.6084\neq .724$$

It's unintuitive, somewhat, but you can gain intuition by thinking about an extreme case. Say a prepared student is never wrong and an unprepared one is never right. Then, of course, the probability of getting one right is $.8$ since there is a $.8$ chance that the student is prepared. But the probability of getting two right is also $.8$, not $.8^2$.

For what it's worth, I wouldn't refer to this as "independence" since, as your apparent contradiction indicates, we do in fact get a huge amount of information from the first question and that changes our expectation for the second. I'd say something like "a prepared student answers each question correctly with a probability of $.95$, independent of all other questions and an unprepared student answers each question correctly with a probability of $.1$, independently of all other questions."

  • $\begingroup$ Alright, so 0.724 is correct right? Assuming we want to find the probability that both answers are correct $\endgroup$ – Dude Dec 24 '18 at 16:43
  • $\begingroup$ Well, to be clear: $.724$ is the probability that a randomly selected student will answer each of two given questions correctly. To be sure, after we see the result of the first test we re-estimate the probability accordingly. $\endgroup$ – lulu Dec 24 '18 at 16:50
  • $\begingroup$ Oh, so I think I didn't get why 0.78^2 shouldn't be the same. $\endgroup$ – Dude Dec 24 '18 at 16:52
  • $\begingroup$ So, go through what I wrote. In particular, think about the extreme case..,wherein the prepared student is always correct and the unprepared student is never correct. Convince yourself that (in the extreme case) a randomly selected student answers two in a row correctly with probability $.8$, not $.8^2$. $\endgroup$ – lulu Dec 24 '18 at 16:54
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Once again, you are mis-using independence. The answers are NOT independent for a randomly selected student. A correct answer for the first is strong evidence that the student is prepared, hence strong evidence that the second answer will also be correct. I can't stress enough: go through the extreme case. Everything you need is in that one. $\endgroup$ – lulu Dec 24 '18 at 17:11

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.