I am helping my daughter with her high school pre-calc. We've both got stuck on this. Below is a copy of the exercise as presented.

We've come up with the following equations (none of which are in the answer set).

$$ A = -y^2 + 600y $$ $$ A = -x^2 + 300x $$

Since both areas are equal:

$$ -y^2 + 600y = -x^2 + 300x $$ or $$ y^2 - 600y = x^2 - 300x $$

Three trivial solutions (out of infinitely many): $(0,0),(300,0)$ and $(0,600)$ (curious ways to build a fence) can be seen in the graph below. Knowing the area would not make this problem seem any less strange.

Am I missing something embarrassingly obvious here?

Edit: I originally had the second equation as $ A = -2y^2 + 600y $ and I "fixed" it. Working too late and losing efficiency.

This leads to

$$-2y^2 + 600y = -x^2 + 300x $$ or $$2(y^2 - 300y) = (x^2 - 300x) $$

which produces a similar-looking graph and trivial (zero-area) results (among infinitely many): $(0,0), (0,300)$ and $(300,0)$.

enter image description here

Question from HW

  • $\begingroup$ I think here the area $A$ is being treated as a known quantity. You have to select the particular $(x,y)$ that simultaneously satisfies $y^2 - 600y = x^2 - 300x,A = -x^2 + 300x,A = -y^2 + 600y$ $\endgroup$ – Shubham Johri Dec 20 '18 at 7:52
  • $\begingroup$ You know what? I had -2y^2 and I "fixed" it. $\endgroup$ – Adam Hrankowski Dec 20 '18 at 8:05

The solution and that of the book doesn't make any sense because the variables $x$ and $y$ are not defined and the problem actually has four unknowns.

From the given data, using field dimensions $w,h,w',h'$, we have


Eliminating $h$ and $h'$, we are left with


You can eliminate $A$ and end-up with a single equation in two unknowns, which is indeterminate.


Let the dimensions of the first field be $x,y$.


Let the dimensions of the second field be $l,b$, and say we have two sides of length $b$.


So the systems $(C),(D)$ will provide us with the required dimensions.

As for your query, I believe the area $A$ is being treated as a known quantity. We have to select that $(x,b)$ which satisfies $300x-x^2=A=600b-2b^2$ simultaneously.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.