enter image description here

I need to confirm the following solution. I'm making a mistake somewhere. But I can't find the error.

I apply the trigonometric form of the Ceva's theorem: enter image description here

$$\frac{\sin \angle 3}{\sin \angle 4}× \frac{\sin \angle 1}{\sin \angle 2}×\frac{\sin \angle 5}{\sin \angle 6} =1$$

$$\frac{\sin \angle 3}{\sin \angle 4}=\frac {\sin \angle 2 ×\sin \angle 6}{\sin \angle 1 ×\sin \angle 5}$$

$$\angle 3+\angle 4=\phi, \angle 1=\alpha, \angle 2=\frac{180°-\phi}{2}-\alpha ,\angle 3=x, \angle 4=\phi-x , \angle 5= \frac{180°-\phi}{2}-θ, \angle 6=θ$$

$$\frac {\sin x}{\sin (\phi -x)}=\frac{\sin \beta ×\sin θ }{\sin \alpha ×\sin \gamma}$$

$$\tan x=\frac{\frac{\sin \beta ×\sin θ }{\sin \alpha ×\sin \gamma}×\sin \phi}{1+\frac{\sin \beta ×\sin θ }{\sin \alpha ×\sin \gamma}×\cos\phi}$$

$$\tan x=\frac{\sin \beta ×\sin θ×\sin \phi}{\sin \alpha × \sin \gamma+\sin \beta ×\sin θ×\cos\phi}$$

$$x= \arctan \frac{\sin \beta ×\sin θ×\sin \phi}{\sin \alpha × \sin \gamma+\sin \beta ×\sin θ×\cos\phi}$$

$$\angle OBC=\phi-\arctan \frac{\sin \beta ×\sin θ×\sin \phi}{\sin \alpha × \sin \gamma+\sin \beta ×\sin θ×\cos\phi}$$

Finally, $$\alpha=\sqrt[3]{66,666°},\beta=6,667°-\sqrt[3]{66,666°}, \gamma=6,667°-\arctan 0,10666, θ=\arctan 0,10666$$

MathLab says that,

$x≈4,345102733435...°, \angle OBC= \phi-x≈166,666°-4,345102733435...°=161,654897266...°$

enter image description here

But, this answer creates a contradiction in my solution https://math.stackexchange.com/a/3026556/548054

Where is the error in my solution? Please show me where I made a mistake. Unfortunately, I can not see.

Thank you.

  • $\begingroup$ Computers are allowed in math contests? $\endgroup$ – GNUSupporter 8964民主女神 地下教會 Dec 9 '18 at 14:20
  • $\begingroup$ @GNUSupporter8964民主女神地下教會 Of course no. I mean, my answer creates contradiction with this answer :math.stackexchange.com/a/3026556/548054 $\endgroup$ – Elementary Dec 9 '18 at 15:43
  • $\begingroup$ @Beginner: You "know" the answer from the various solutions given to your previous question, so try this: At every stage of your analysis, substitute the known angle measures into your equation to double-check its correctness. When an equation breaks, you'll know where the problem (or the first problem) lies. $\endgroup$ – Blue Dec 11 '18 at 22:24
  • $\begingroup$ @Beginner, Can you clear me one thing, what do you mean by the comma separations - are they decimal points? $\endgroup$ – Awe Kumar Jha Dec 18 '18 at 7:28

The only problem with your symbolic manipulations I see is that $\tan x<0$, so $x$ is actually $$ \pi + \arctan \frac{\sin \beta ×\sin θ×\sin \phi}{\sin \alpha × \sin \gamma+\sin \beta ×\sin θ×\cos\phi} $$ According to my computations, this gives the same result as the answer you refer to.

However, there seems to be a bigger problem with your numerical computations (it should have given you a negative value for $x$), but I'm not familiar with MathLab, so I cannot say for certain what the problem is. Are you sure you're not mixing degrees and radians together, though? In your screenshot, there is a degree sign at the value 166.666, but not at the other angles, so maybe MathLab interprets the other angle values as radians?


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.