I would like to say that $\Bbb Q / \Bbb Z$ is not discrete (when $\Bbb Q$ has euclidean topology), since $\Bbb Z \subset \Bbb Q$ is not open. But OTOH we have $$\Bbb Q / \Bbb Z \cong \bigoplus_p \Bbb Q_p / \Bbb Z_p$$ which is a direct sum of discrete groups, so it should be a discrete group. Maybe the issue is that the above isomorphism is only as abstract groups, but not as topological groups.

Could anyone confirm/elaborate on this?

  • 3
    $\begingroup$ I think you're right, the above isomorphism is only an isomorphism of the underlying group structures. $\endgroup$ – Brahadeesh Nov 29 '18 at 9:53
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Note that $\Bbb Q$ with the Euclidean topology is isomorphic to $\Bbb Q$ with the discrete topology, if the isomorphism only requires to respect the group action and not the topology. $\endgroup$ – Asaf Karagila Nov 29 '18 at 9:54
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ The completion of the metric space $\mathbb{Q}/\mathbb{Z}, d(a,b) = \min_n |a-bn|$ is $\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z}$ while with the discrete metric $\tilde{d}(a,b) = \sup_p \inf_n |a-b n|_p$ it is complete and $\cong \bigoplus_p \Bbb Q_p / \Bbb Z_p$. $\endgroup$ – reuns Nov 29 '18 at 10:20
  • $\begingroup$ @reuns Frequently complete and non-complete-metrics on a set $X$ .induce the same topology. $\endgroup$ – Paul Frost Nov 29 '18 at 11:25
  • $\begingroup$ @PaulFrost For two group-invariant metrics it should be sufficient that the completion are not the same, I should have said that ? $\endgroup$ – reuns Nov 29 '18 at 11:52

A non-trival group $G$ can always be endowed with various distinct topologies making it a topological group. Two "universal choices" are the discrete topology and the indiscrete topology. See What is, exactly, a discrete group?.

However, you consider $G = \Bbb Q / \Bbb Z$ and emphasize that $\Bbb Q$ has the Euclidean topology. In that case the only reasonable topology on $G$ will be the quotient topology which is certainly not discrete.

The isomorphism $\Bbb Q / \Bbb Z \cong \bigoplus_p \Bbb Q_p / \Bbb Z_p$ is therefore only an algebraic isomorphism, not an isomorphism of topological groups.

Edited: I just considered which topology is given to an infinite sum $\bigoplus_{\alpha \in A} G_\alpha$ of abelian topological groups. There are various approaches, see for example

Higgins, P. J. "Coproducts of topological Abelian groups." Journal of Algebra 44.1 (1977): 152-159.


Chasco, M. J., and X. Dominguez. "Topologies on the direct sum of topological abelian groups." Topology and its Applications 133.3 (2003): 209-223.


In my opinion the conclusion is that an infinite sum of discrete abelian topological groups is not given the discrete topology. Whether one of the "reasonable" topologies on $\bigoplus_p \Bbb Q_p / \Bbb Z_p$ makes it isomorphic as a topological group to $\Bbb Q / \Bbb Z$ is not known to me.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.